8 ms·
When archaeologists say it "isn't possible to do X with Y", having attempted to do it in an afternoon of trying, I don't really believe them... 2,900 years ago
by londons_explore 4y ago
When archaeologists say it "isn't possible to do X with Y", having attempted to do it in an afternoon of trying, I don't really believe them...
2,900 years ago there were lots of people, each with lots of time. It seems very possible that there was some way to carve this stone, and we just haven't discovered it...
For example, maybe the stone is weakened if you try to carve it after a frosty night... Or is weakened by being soaked in lemon juice... Or is just worn away by being rubbed against another piece of the same stone...
There are all kinds of methods of achieving the apparently impossible which are non-obvious.
- andrewflnr 4y agoThey did also find the actual chisel, though. And it's very possible that, say, rubbing acid or scraping with a stone does make a mark, but I bet it's sufficiently distinct in shape, side effects, etc to be ruled out here.
- jjoonathan 4y ago> archaeologists say it "isn't possible to do X with Y" Do they? Many people use "everyone said X was impossible, but I found out how to do X!" as a framing device to tell their story, but whenever I investigate one of these I generally find that it isn't strictly, err, true. People weren't saying "X is impossible" so much as "we think tribe T didn't know how to do X so this artifact was probably imported" or something similarly hedged. The new information is genuine, but the narrative is just storytelling.
- barbazoo 4y ago> there were lots of people, each with lots of time I bet tons of Human innovation came from people just having time and nothing to do. I wonder, throughout history, if this was a privilege or if even ordinary people had time like this (obviously not the resources necessarily).
- londons_explore 4y agoI suspect that throughout history there has generally been quite a lot of 'free time'. Music and art and drinking alcohol all appear to be mostly free time/entertainment things, and I suspect a group of people who had to work for all of their waking hours wouldn't partake in those things much. Even in nature, it seems most creatures have a lot of free time. For example, most birds seem to spend much of their time sitting in trees chirping, rather than hunting for worms/seeds. I could imagine that "I have free time to sing" is a big sexual selector - an individual who doesn't need to spend 24/7 hunting for food is a 'stronger' mate. I wonder if the same applies to humans?
- funcDropShadow 4y agoAlcoholic beverages were used for a long time as a more sanitary alternative to water not as an amusement.