3 ms·
Is something happening to the quality of this community lately? I opened up my username account here 1161 days ago, after lurking once in a while for at least
by tokenadult 15y ago
Is something happening to the quality of this community lately?
I opened up my username account here 1161 days ago, after lurking once in a while for at least several weeks beforehand. As far as I know, NO ONE has read every Hacker News comment exhaustively for years, although some members of the curating team and some of the high-karma participants may come pretty close to reading most of the most active threads. My general impression is that there have always been some instances of incivility here, and there has definitely been an increase in just-plain-dumb comments since the participation on HN greatly expanded, but on the whole HN still stays way ahead of most online communities in civility and in level of information on the part of the regular participants.
And if so, is there anything we can or should do about it?
What I have seen as most helpful is users who observe breaches of civility pointing that out to users who perform such gaffes. That reaffirms the forum culture and identifies which overt behaviors are not helpful here. I have to acknowledge that from time to time I have learned from other participants pointing out my less-than-ideal comments, and I appreciate people taking the effort to help me learn from my mistakes.
Here are some links to earlier discussion (initiated by pg) about efforts made beginning in March 2010 to improve comment quality on Hacker News:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403696 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403696
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2434333 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2434333
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2445039 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2445039
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2465271 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2465271
One way to get a reality check on how HN is doing is to look at the bestcomments view of the community
http://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments http://news.ycombinator.com/bestcomments
to see if all the most recently highly upvoted comments look like civil, informative comments or not.
- pg 15y agoWe read all comments that get sufficiently negative scores. So I have a decent handle on how bad that kind of bad comment is. What worries me more is bad (= mean and/or stupid) comments that actually get upvoted.
- redthrowaway 15y agoAre you most worried about snarky or rude comments occasionally getting upvoted, or the seeming proliferation of content-free comments? I ask because the rude/mean upvoted comments, though disturbing, are thankfully fairly rare. The content-free comments, on the other hand, seem to be becoming more frequent and less downvoted. Do you think the problems are distinct, or do they both follow from some other change in the community?
- tokenadult 15y agoWhat worries me more is bad (= mean and/or stupid) comments that actually get upvoted. Thanks for explaining what data points you and the curation team observe closely, and what trends you have noticed. You mentioned above about the goal of increasing comment quality that "There's a lot we already do about it, and probably other techniques that are yet undiscovered. This is somewhat uncharted territory." I'll renew a suggestion here that I think would be helpful. I've been a moderator one place or another online since 1993, and I've seen a lot of online discussion forums attempt to acculturate newbies to civil, thoughtful discussion. One of the most helpful practices that I have observed over the years is making sure that people who use factual assertions to back a position in a discussion are accountable for where one would look up the facts to verify them and ensure they are not made up. (A HUGE percentage of all real-world discourse about controversial issues is based on made-up factual premises.) With that in mind, I'm trying to encourage a culture here of asking people for sources when they make a factual assertion, and providing sources in a first comment when there sources on the issue. (I try to stud most of my comments with links to sources to exemplify this.) So any time any of us see a comment that is dumb, an essential thing to do is to ask the person who made the dumb comment what the basis for the comment is. ("Do you have a source for that?" or the more abrupt "[citation needed]" as occasion demands, or "What about [detail of assertion]?" if that is better for raising the quality of the discussion.) Another thing to do is to share the growing online literature about evaluating sources, such as my very favorite link for Hacker News discussions, http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html and links about constructive online participation. http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html A lot of stupid comments (and, alas, I have a particular user's example in mind) result from the convenience of reading blogs rather than reading serious scholarly literature. And the paywalls around serious scholarly articles only exacerbate this problem. So I routinely upvote any comment that points to a reliable source, and especially comments that teach other HN participants how to find and access reliable sources. In general, promoting an information-based culture here will have two effects that will help reduce the problem of dumb comments: (1) it will raise the karma and visibility of the better comments that include good information from reliable sources (or that ask for that as follow-ups to worse comments), and (2) it will be off-putting to people inclined to make it up when they are put to their proof for the things they say.