3 ms·
The problem is that systemd vs sysv-init is a false dichotomy. Systemd took over a ton of important non-init functionality, like DNS, logging, and interactive
by nine_k 4y ago
The problem is that systemd vs sysv-init is a false dichotomy.
Systemd took over a ton of important non-init functionality, like DNS, logging, and interactive sessions. That could be fine if systemd did so in a nice and rock-solid way, but it was unpleasantly bug-ridden for years after being thrust on mainstream distros via a hard Gnome dependency.
SysV-init sucks in many ways, it's well known, and I can personally attest to that. I don't want SysV-init to be perpetuated.
There were, and are, viable alternatives to both, which are a less radical rework of the well-established Unix approaches around the area, do not overreach well past the init system scope, and are sane and well-functioning. For examples, see [upstart], [openrc], [s6], [runit].
I think that the prevalence of systemd was mostly achieved not through its technical merits (which undeniably exist) but through Red Hat's strongarming, because Red Hat wants certain things work in a way convenient for their business, and they have a powerful battering ram under their control, the Gnome DE.
Fortunately Wayland is not being force-fed in such a way, because, much like systemd when it was introduced, it's still in many important regards not exactly ready. I, with my 25 years of running Linux on desktop, will gladly migrate to a better graphics architecture when in becomes adequate for my purposes, if the whole current Unix architecture is not obsoleted and replaced wholesale by that time.
[upstart]: https://upstart.ubuntu.com/ https://upstart.ubuntu.com/
[openrc]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenRC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenRC
[s6]: https://www.skarnet.org/software/s6-linux-init/ https://www.skarnet.org/software/s6-linux-init/
[runit]: https://www.skarnet.org/software/s6-linux-init/ https://www.skarnet.org/software/s6-linux-init/
- justinsaccount 4y agoupstart: a broken design and abandoned by its author and canonical https://lwn.net/Articles/581548/ https://lwn.net/Articles/581548/ openrc: I don't believe openrc had a process supervision story 8-9 years ago. from what I recall at the time openrc was just a slightly better sysvinit. runit: I have a lot of experience with runit, and while it works, it has many footguns and is hard to use correctly. s6: a better runit with better footguns A great thing that more people should read, is https://lwn.net/Articles/578210/ https://lwn.net/Articles/578210/ from one of the Debian developers who voted to switch to systemd. It touches on things like the lack of adoption of upstart, and openrc not solving the problems they had.
- nine_k 4y agoIs systemd footgun-free? I doubt it. (Runit worked reasonably fine for me for last few years, and it's way simpler and saner than SysV-init, at least.)
- ihatepython 4y agoI'd like to see Wayland be integrated as part of systemd. It would make things much cleaner