5 ms·
> When you finance a car, the vehicle becomes collateral for a loan, but it belongs to you. The title stays with the lender until all the payments are made per
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> When you finance a car, the vehicle becomes collateral for a loan, but it belongs to you.
The title stays with the lender until all the payments are made per the loan agreement. I would not say the vehicle legally belongs to a borrower until they have possession of the title.
> The reason we have laws is so that people have recourse to principle, whereas when you implement something like this in hardware (a car), it's dystopian vigilantism.
The legal system is costly to use. Reducing the costs to repossess collateral would reduce borrowing costs, and ultimately help borrowers with lower borrowing costs because there is less expense towards repossession.
- JamesBarney 4y agoIf the cost of repossession is low it also means that riskier buyers are more likely to get financed.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoGood point!
- BoorishBears 4y agoThis is a pretty naive take if you're trying to paint it as enabling an even better outcome for "riskier buyers" This article is something like 5-10 years behind reality: Right now subprime auto loans are mostly enforced with GPS trackers that buyers are usually not made properly aware of, or even worse, tricked into paying for as an add-on pitched as being for their own benefit. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/19/business/dealbook/gps-devices-car-loans.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/19/business/dealbook/gps-dev... - There are entire businesses built on selling poor people cars at truly insane interest rates, on payments they clearly can't afford, repossessing the cars on the cheap with GPS trackers, then selling then to the next poor person with bad credit. This grift isn't new, but cheap GPS trackers and license scanners reduced the cost per repossession in a way that enabled these places to be signficantly more brazen about it. Unfortunately the two prevailing takes I see on this are "they're subprime for a reason" as if they deserve it, and "well at least someone is still giving them a chance, you need a car in this country" (and of course some well meaning but ill informed people think you can just take public transport in every part of the country) The reality is this is worse than nothing in many cases. Buy here, pay here have people pay more frequently so that they can repo a car within days not months of someone buying them. The process isn't free either, it's disruptive, and they'll continue to leech off the owner in collections. - Overall it feels like a classic case of short sightedness from society. Saying we should directly subsidized subprime people's access to affordable loans and cars would be a non-starter: It sounds like some bleeding heart charity case making the responsible pay for the irresponsible. But then we'll all indirectly fund a much worse version of that when subprime auto loans start to implode (like they're probably already starting to with the interest rate hikes...) and we're all paying to pick up the pieces in multiple ways. If the bottom falls out the car market, well right now even middle class families are taking loans with insane terms that leave them underwater in a good market. The pain will trickle up and out from just subprime lenders and cars specifically.
- bko 4y agoPeople who give out car loans want you to pay back the loan. They don't want to repossess the vehicle. There is a real cost associated with it and you can't just take the car and make a profit. You'd be able to recoup what was owed and some costs may not be coupable. Again, they're not in the business to lend out money to people they know that can't afford it. There may be fraud at the individual level but the system doesn't work like that. The recovery rates for subprime auto deals are historically around 50% https://www.fitchratings.com/research/structured-finance/soaring-vehicle-values-support-record-auto-abs-performance-14-07-2021 https://www.fitchratings.com/research/structured-finance/soa...
- BoorishBears 4y agoNot sure why you picked July 2021 on a monthly index... easily the most misleading month in the last decade: https://www.fitchratings.com/structured-finance/abs/auto-indices#u.s.-auto-indices https://www.fitchratings.com/structured-finance/abs/auto-ind... As soon as the government assistance I'm advocating dried back up we skyrocketed back to historical highs of subprime delinquency. And notice how when graphed together, right on the timeframe I describe of 5-10, you see a massive divergence between subprime and prime trends even in your own article. Recovery rates tell you percentages, not absolute scale. (graph is a stunning representation of our current K-shaped recovery btw) With cheaper repossessions the scale was what increased, and that's what Fitch is referring to with record performance. We gave more people than ever who couldn't afford loans loans, and so while the relative rate of recovery didn't change, delinquency went insane, and is gearing up to get even more insane with the interest rate hikes. > People who give out car loans want you to pay back the loan. I can't tell if this is just a naive or at least uninformed take. At a high enough level the financial system wants people to pay back loans... but that's not what's being discussed here. - There are dealers who want buyers to fail to pay. They're additionally enabled by both GPS trackers and license scanners to be even more efficient in their grift. Additionally, you accidentally exposed an amazing example of what I described in terms of "we will subsidize it either way" We don't provide a direct form of assistance specific to cars... but we did pay individuals to keep them afloat during the pandemic. They then had to take that money and pay subprime lenders to keep cars with exorbitant interest fees for longer, driving record profitability for the subprime market. Now interest rates are spiking, those people are losing their cars. They're in a more desperate situation than ever, with less assistance then when interest rates were better. Used car prices fell, but not enough to cover all the ground they gained during the heat of the pandemic. It's like this country just lets looming crisis walk up face to face without every trying to change course lest we seem like communists. To me this shouldn't even be a partisan issue, we can enable a smaller need for government intervention in the next economic slump by just not donating money to these lenders
- lostapathy 4y ago> The title stays with the lender until all the payments are made per the loan agreement. This varies a lot by state. A lot (most?) states the title absolutely goes to the purchaser but it has a lien attached that gives the lender rights of repossession.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoInteresting, I thought it was only sent to you after the final loan payment.
- lostapathy 4y agoJust because they hold the title for security doesn't mean it's not in your name.
- kube-system 4y agoIt's a pain in the ass, because you just hold a title that you can't do anything with. You have to physically get the lien signed off the physical title before you can sell it. That's why many states have switched to either electronic titling, or having the bank hold the title until they sign it off.
- bluGill 4y agoThey send you a lien release, but the title is goes to you from the beginning. The title has a note that there is a lien on it, so if you buy a car with such a title you need to ensure you get the lien release with it. You cannot transfer a title with a lien notice on it without the lien release (I assume there is a way to assume the loan as well, but I've never heard of it happening. Most loans wouldn't allow that, so it is probably a technicality that the government wouldn't know how to handle if you actually did attempt that)
- JohnFen 4y agoIn my state, they just send you a new copy of the title that omits the lien-holder rather than a lien release.
- GuB-42 4y ago> > When you finance a car, the vehicle becomes collateral for a loan, but it belongs to you. > The title stays with the lender until all the payments are made per the loan agreement. I would not say the vehicle legally belongs to a borrower until they have possession of the title. Maybe the confusion comes from the meaning of "owning". There are essentially three parts to ownership: the right to sell, to rent, and to use. A full owner has all three, but there are situation where they are distinct and the "owner" may be different depending on which aspect you consider. So when usage is considered, the borrower is the owner, the lender can't get into the car and drive, but when sales are considered, the lender can sell the car and get money from it, the borrower can't (at least not before the loan is fully paid).
- bloomingeek 4y agoTwo of my vehicles are Chrysler's. Both send me a monthly email telling how the car is doing: tire psi, oil change status, etc. Both are paid off, but I'll bet anything they can still disable them. So do I really own them?
- lmm 4y agoYou own them. Sure Chrysler can disable your car, but whether they do that by sending it a radio signal or by sending a guy round with a wrench is neither here nor there.
- chucksmash 4y ago> Reducing the costs to repossess collateral would reduce borrowing costs, and ultimately help borrowers with lower borrowing costs because there is less expense towards repossession. Costs to borrowers could be reduced, which sounds like a nice silver lining to what most people would consider an anti-feature, but there's nothing that says the savings will necessarily be passed on to borrowers versus retained by the lenders instead.
- kkielhofner 4y agoNot to mention the (current) alternative is an often shady/creative/aggressive repossession agent who in many cases[0] has the legal authority to go on your property to hook and tow the vehicle (often in the middle of the night). Even when they "don't" they often do anyway. In a country with very high firearm ownership it's actually dangerous[0]. From a quick Google search violence breaks out pretty often[2][3] in these circumstances. [0] - https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/car-repossession-laws-in-california.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/car-repossession-law... [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ti0NHC6oVnk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ti0NHC6oVnk [2] - https://www.jacksonville.com/story/news/crime/2011/03/02/repo-man-killed-1-more-shot-st-augustine/15912396007/ https://www.jacksonville.com/story/news/crime/2011/03/02/rep... [3] - https://www.fox4news.com/news/repo-man-shot-while-trying-to-repossess-car-arlington-police https://www.fox4news.com/news/repo-man-shot-while-trying-to-...
- ubermonkey 4y agoYou're on the title at purchase, but the lender has a lien on the title.
- neuralRiot 4y ago> Reducing the costs to repossess collateral would reduce borrowing costs, and ultimately help LENDERS WITH HIGHER PROFITS. FTFY.
- WheatMillington 4y agoPerhaps this is true in America where apparently you still have a paper title to indicate ownership?? But under commonwealth law "title" is a legal concept, not a physical document, and can't belong to anyone except the rightful owner. An asset can be used as security collateral without the ownership changing hands.
- JohnFen 4y agoI believe in most states (I know in mine), there is no longer any paper that you can hold that makes you the owner. The title is just a document showing that you are the owner registered with the motor vehicle department. It doesn't grant you ownership.