3 ms·
tl;dr: waffle waffle waffle romantic nostalgia waffle waffle highlighter waffle waffle DRM waffle waffle. The "store it on a 5.25 inch floppy" strawman was par
by kstenerud 15y ago
tl;dr: waffle waffle waffle romantic nostalgia waffle waffle highlighter waffle waffle DRM waffle waffle.
The "store it on a 5.25 inch floppy" strawman was particularly pathetic. If you care about saving something, you'll keep up with the times in terms of storage. Furthermore, the more people who have a copy, the less likely the work is to be lost.
- DRM will fail eventually, like it did with music.
- Storage formats will evolve, but there will always be programs to convert to the latest format.
- Resale will become less of an issue as price comes down. We're seeing the same thing with video games and music.
- Rare works won't slowly disappear over time like they do with paper books.
With the advent of ebooks, distribution of knowledge is becoming less and less restricted. There will, however, be those who cling to the old technology out of nostalgia. They'll be forgotten in a generation or two; it was the same way with scrolls.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdkucf6wxU4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pdkucf6wxU4
- dkarl 15y agoI don't think you understand the point of his post. You certainly missed the last section, titled "Ebooks are inevitable," where he admits that e-books are already better in many ways and are very far from fulfilling their potential. With ebooks, we're still looking at the equivalent of the day after Gutenberg printed his first Bible. His "spec" comparison (like most spec comparisons) is meant to point out where e-readers are deficient, because he wants e-reader development to focus on those deficiencies. We need to decide which paper book "specs" are important and ensure that they get recreated in our new digital world. The "store it on a 5.25 inch floppy" strawman was particularly pathetic. If you care about saving something, you'll keep up with the times in terms of storage. By the "long view" he's talking about world history, not rereading a book he bought twenty years ago. Most of the texts we have from over a millennium ago had to survive through centuries when nobody cared about them. Also, I don't want to be rude, but when you follow "tl;dr" with a putative summary, it means you've read the whole thing yourself and want to save other people the trouble of reading it. If you decide something isn't worth reading straight through and just skim it instead, say "tl;dr" and leave the summarizing to people who actually read it.