8 ms·
I've been blown away at the AI upscaling on the Nvidia Shield. On my fairly large 4K TV, the Shield can produce picture quality that looks incredible out of so
by freedomben 4y ago
I've been blown away at the AI upscaling on the Nvidia Shield. On my fairly large 4K TV, the Shield can produce picture quality that looks incredible out of source that isn't all that great. On that note, the Shield has been an unexpectedly great purchase over the years. Long life of support from Nvidia, runs Google TV, works incredibly as a gaming console for Steam Linking into my PC and/or playing compatible Android games, and hosting a Plex server (although I now use Jellyfin hosted on a raspberry pi). If Nvidia would open source their Linux driver (or at least drastically improve support), I'd be a huge fan. I highly recommend, despite the fact that I'm mad at them for the pain they cause me on Linux. Buy AMD cards if you run Linux).
- netruk44 4y agoI also have an Nvidia shield that now sits unused for the simple reason that Google forced ads onto the home screen. It used to be that the Shield was the one bastion away from ads on Android TV, then with one update that somehow manages to reinstall itself despite being completely disconnected from the internet, there are now permanently ads on my Nvidia Shield TV. I honestly don't know why it's such a big deal for me, but I basically never use it anymore. It's real shame, I got a lot of good use out of it, because as you mention the support has been going on for years now. But I will not subject myself to ads if I can help it. I pay for Youtube to avoid ads, I pay for Twitch to avoid ads. I can't pay to remove ads from my Android TV homescreen (that I didn't even have for the past like 5 years)
- verall 4y agoIt is possible to plug your shield into your PC and sideload a new launcher which doesn't have ads, it's not too difficult (tho installing adb is a hassle). I heard on reddit that if Nvidia even hints that this is possible, they violate the license agreements with Google, and then Google is allowed to yank the play store...
- freedomben 4y agoDo you know if it has to be plugged in to sideload a launcher? I sideload apps through wireless adb and it was pretty easy to get set up.
- verall 4y agoShould work but I haven't tried it
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoThat works. That's what I did
- doix 4y agoI was the same, really pissed off when they made the change. Luckily, it's android, so you can install a custom launcher. I remember I had to play around with adb a bit, but after that, it's smooth sailing. I use FLauncher[0], but there might be something better out there. [0] https://gitlab.com/flauncher/flauncher https://gitlab.com/flauncher/flauncher
- sushisource 4y agoThank you for this link! I, like a moron, kept looking on the play store for something and only saw garbage. Never thought to sideload. The nagging in the android launcher has got more and more obnoxious recently. Half the time I open an app it asks if I want to "add it to my discover" with the only options being "yes" or "later". Infuriating.
- barbazoo 4y agoAre you saying this works with a Shield TV?
- izacus 4y agoYes, I've switched out launcher on my Shield TV to one that only shows a few app buttons. It works fine.
- albrewer 4y agoOh wow, I was put off from getting one because of the ad update a few years ago. If this works well enough I'll probably actually get one now
- gtirloni 4y agoWhat kind of ads? I see recommendations for movies that I would have to purchase but not general ads in my Chromecast.
- kridsdale1 4y agoThose are ads.
- gtirloni 4y agoIt's not like they're showing you ads about shoes or kitchen utensils. It's a TV appliance so.. what else did you expect? A blank screen with just the Netflix icon? Are the Netflix recommendations ads too?
- Wolfbeta 4y agoThis is your brain on ads.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rolenthedeep 4y ago> what else did you expect? A blank screen with just the Netflix icon? Yes > Are the Netflix recommendations ads too? Yes
- ddtaylor 4y agoI've been a year or so using Sponsor block in addition to basic ad blocking. Now any device that doesn't offer both simply is a complete non starter for me.
- 411111111111111 4y agoyou mean something like that? https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTubeNext/ https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTubeNext/
- ddtaylor 4y agoI mostly stream to "dumb" devices connected directly to a display. I hate smart TVs. You can still use a remote and stuff by just opening `youtube.com/tv` in the browser and you can even use a remote/phone to control it. For mobile you can use ReVanced.
- midoridensha 4y agoThat app is a godsend.
- freedomben 4y agoInteresting I haven't seen any ads, although I do use the Dan Pollock hosts file on my router to block a lot of stuff: http://someonewhocares.org/hosts/ http://someonewhocares.org/hosts/
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoThe home screen ads are infuriating. I know it's Android, by Google, but I bought the freakin device. It wasn't cheap. And they added this retroactively. Shame on Google and shame on Nvidia for allowing it. I used a 3rd party launcher but there wasn't a way (at the time) to make it the default.
- midoridensha 4y agoPersonally, I don't see what the big deal is. I don't have an Nvidia device, but I do have an Android/Google TV. I really don't care about all the "recommended" crap on the home screen; I just ignore it all, and use my remove to skip down to the SmartTubeNext icon and open that app to watch YouTube videos ad-free (no sponsor messages either!). Or I use a different button that leaves the home screen and takes me to a file manager to view the files I've loaded on my USB stick so I can watch those (I decline to say where these files came from exactly). These are the only 2 things I need out of a TV.
- justinclift 4y ago> I pay for Youtube to avoid ads As Google clearly doesn't respect your boundaries, maybe stop giving them money? eg stop rewarding them for their current behaviour
- Bluecobra 4y agoI choose to pay for YouTube Premium to support the content creators. I doubt they will get paid if I used an ad blocker.
- justinclift 4y agoInteresting. Most of the content creators I tend to watch (not that many really) organise their own sponsorships. eg "This video brought to you by XYZ" For those, using an ad blocker won't make much difference. But I guess if the content creators important to you are relying on youtube's monetisation, they would indeed be affected. Not sure how else to send a signal to Youtube though, as they only seem to care about revenue. Seems like there's only that one lever that can be pulled. eg "ad blocker or not?"
- petepete 4y agoI was on the verge of buying a Shield but this has put me off.
- lfkdev 4y agoYes, another + from me for the shield. After ~ 5 years now, still running great. Using it for Kodi/SmartYoutube/Steam-streaming. Only had to remove the inner dust last year
- pjmlp 4y ago> Buy AMD cards if you run Linux). Experience shows that in practice they also aren't much better than Nvidia in regards to Linux.
- freedomben 4y agoYeah sadly agree, depending on what you want. If you want OpenCL, you're absolutely right. The AMD PRO driver is even worse than the Nvidia driver as it only supports old kernels and install process is terrible.
- mohaine 4y agoI recently switched back from AMD -> Nvidia and couldn't be happier. Other than some issues with an inadvertent install blocking the kernel module it has been pretty much flawless.
- krackpot 4y agoIs this true? I'm in the market for an AMD card just to switch over to linux. I'm on an old 1080. Most discussions centered around the various linux communities seem to parrot that AMD is the way to go now because of open source drivers etc. I always wonder how much of it is an echo chamber.
- mardifoufs 4y agoIt depends. If you are willing to download proprietary drivers from nvidia, it literally just works. Though I'd probably suggest not getting on a rolling release distro, or any distro that is focused on mostly sticking with libre/foss solutions. Ubuntu works great with non free drivers, out of the box, so just use that. Kernel updates might be tricky on some distros, so sticking with more stable releases is preferable in my experience (I have used AMD and NVIDIA cards, including a 4 GTX1070 cluster a few years back with mostly little issues on both. Also used GCN andRDNA1, and now I use nvidia on ubuntu for work and it just works.)
- freedomben 4y agoI run Linux on everything, and have a system with nvidia card and one with AMD, so speaking from real experience rather than echo chamber regurgitation (which is definitely a problem in this space so good to be aware of it). I will go AMD every time for gaming and general dual/triple screen monitors. I would only go Nvidia if I needed CUDA (such as for machine learning). If you need OpenCL or if you go Nvidia and need the proprietary driver, it will make distros like Fedora (my favorite), Arch, etc a lot more difficult as they stay very current on kernels (which is great for hardware compatibility). Nvidia is better than AMD in this regard if you need the AMD pro then you just won't be able to run Fedora. If you don't mind Ubuntu, then you'll be ok. It's well supported for Nvidia drivers and AMD Pro. I have been amazed at how well everything "just works" with AMD on Fedora, and for that reason AMD is my default.
- Gordonjcp 4y ago> Buy AMD cards if you run Linux They don't do CUDA, so they're useless.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kkielhofner 4y agoA generous translation: AMD GPUs are toys. As long as AMD drops the ball on ROCm, etc their cards will be relegated to gaming - quite literally a toy to many people.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoI know that from the DaVinci Resolve forums and subreddit, everyone using AMD has all sorts of pain-in-the-arse problems that just don't happen with NVidia, even on Windows.
- kkielhofner 4y agoYeah the downvotes are interesting. Many users who are happy with "I want a GPU to drive my display and maybe game" are pleased with the current state of AMD - and that's fine. However, that population rarely goes beyond "how many FPS am I getting?". That population regularly complains about the Nvidia closed-source/binary driver situation. A lot of that criticism (from their point of view) is fair - although I've never had issues with the binary driver and as seen in this thread I'm not alone. However, if they were to expect even just a little bit more - ML, reliable and usable hardware video encoding/decoding, etc they'd quickly realize what we have. The closed-source Nvidia driver is remarkable capable and consistent (from a functionality perspective) supporting every single feature and function of any and every card that says "Nvidia" on it across multiple platforms. From nearly decade-old laptop GPUs to the latest and greatest H100 datacenter GPU and everything in between. This is before you even get to the dozens of libraries Nvidia supports and provides (like cuDNN, TensorRT, etc) that have the same consistent, reliable, and cross-platform functionality. Again, I understand their perspective and I don't look down on them or their simple use case (gaming on desktop) but in 2023 that's an extremely low bar. There's also a lot of criticism of the Nvidia price point - but those of us who are making full utilization of our hardware and supported features balk at that criticism. What's also interesting is the more buggy and less supported also closed-source (to my knowledge) AMD Pro driver that's required to do anything more than game. So at this point you're still not going to please the open source community and the functionality and experience is worse in every aspect. My 4090s will not only beat AMD top of the line on just about every gaming benchmark, in seconds (or simultaneously) I can be training an ML model, encoding video, upscaling, doing realtime noise suppression, etc. The functionality fundamentally supported by that driver is amazing. When you look at it from that standpoint an Nvidia card being (at most) 3x the price point is perfectly reasonable. I'm thrilled to spend $1000 more if it means I can actually use the card for what I need and I save many, many hours of my time. In terms of total value it's not even close. The increase in value, utility, and time returned is astounding and (to many of us) more than justifies the driver situation and cost. I support competition and have tried several times over the years to get ROCm to perform the most basic ML tasks - it's a blackhole of wasted time, energy, and effort (starting with the AMDPro driver). AMD clearly just doesn't care - and even if they decided to throw everything they have at it Nvidia has a decade-plus head start. I truly wish the AMD software situation was better but I've been let down too many times to be hopeful I will be making anything approaching full use of any AMD GPU anytime in the near future.
- ModernMech 4y ago> the Shield can produce picture quality that looks incredible out of source that isn't all that great. So much for garbage in, garbage out.
- babypuncher 4y agoI like the hardware in the shield but Android TV kind of kills it for me. When I was still using my shield, the UI would frequently get updated, and each update made the home screen worse and worse. I wish they would just copy the Apple TV's home screen. All anyone needs is a grid of icons and NO ADVERTISEMENTS. There is no more room for innovation here. Stop trying to re-invent the wheel. Just admit someone else already perfected it and move on.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zamadatix 4y agoFor the newer GPUs nvidia's open kernel modules have created less hair pulling for me and are much more comparable to amdgpu than the traditional modules. Recently I was reading Nouveau is working on re-clocking support on newer GPUs via GSP support which is just starting to be upstreamed, that'll be even nicer if it materializes.
- freedomben 4y agocan the open kernel modules do CUDA? I read somewhere that they couldn't, but that could be out of date now and would be a game changer for me
- rektide 4y agoIt's good that there's at least some way to load the whole scmorgasboard of proprietary drivers/firmware now that doesnt constantly break, but this is still so far from great. Nvidia picks & chooses what to implement. If they deign do work at all. And actually open-source Nouveau is wonderful, but wow, they have like 1/20th the chip-maker resources to read-from/work-with & 1/20th the developer headcount of Intel or AMD open-source driver development. Phoronix is posting RADV stories every other week with cutting edge industry folk making this or that innovation, & Noveau shows up like quarterly maybe.
- zamadatix 4y agoThe dearth of Nouveau interest is largely to do with the last 4 generations of cards being limited to the power saving clock speed. The new method of using the GSP in the open driver will remove that limitation and allow work done on Nouveau to actually be usable again.
- anononaut 4y agoI have an Nvidia Shield pro and I have to say it's been a significant cause of frustration for me. 1-2 second audio drops on occasion, apps that have glaring bugs (such as freezes or inability to go forward/backwards) that I suspect is due to lack of adoption, adverts on the home screen. I haven't switched off of it, I guess, but I wish I had something better.
- freedomben 4y agoFascinating, thanks. I've been considering the Pro, but my current one still does everything I need it to and more so I can't justify the purchase, but this makes me a little more content with my status quo.
- adra 4y agoNo freezing or notable stuttering for me. I switched to wired internet for better consistently higher bandwidth videos as my wifi is super swampy. Some applications like Netflix would normally be able to lower you to a smaller sample rate to compensate for bad conditions, but most applications will just be inferior in studders, skips, etc
- slashtom 4y agoMy biggest issue with the Shield is that they still have not implemented refresh rate match across the OS, which all it will take is an update to the OS since google has implemented it.
- anotherman554 4y agoCould you give an example of a TV show that blew you away when processed with Nvidia Shield's upscaling? I tried the feature while streaming HBO's Sopranos, going from 1080p to 4k and it didn't look any better to me, just slightly different with occasional artifacts. I didn't understand the hype around this feature. I believe how good your TV's native upscaling will also be a factor in how improved the Shield's implementation looks.
- thawkth 4y agoI can: Star Trek DS9 (DVD rips). I actually had forgotten the Shield was supposed to be doing AI upscaling since a lot of what I watched for a while was current. I was midway through the series when I traveled somewhere else and used a Roku on a different TV - and it was instantly noticeable. When I got home, I plugged in a Chromecast Google TV to my TV (LG OLED) and watched parts of an episode. The Shield TV made DS9 look significantly better.
- freedomben 4y agoThis happened to me with TNG! I was blown away by the picture quality. That's not something my wife usually notices, but even she commented about how good it looked. I later watched it on a different device and the quality was noticeably worse.
- smcleod 4y agoTNG did have a massive amount of time put into remastering it though, DS9 sadly has not.
- robobub 4y agoOthers agree with you: > The Shield upscaler works, but if you have an eye for quality it is terrible. The sharpening it uses leaves a very noticeable sharpening ring around edges, most noticeable on animated content. It will also cause weird artifacts to pop up on live action content. https://www.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/11e7e2h/rtx_video_super_resolution_faq/jacx0qa/?context=1 https://www.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/11e7e2h/rtx_video_s...
- driscoll42 4y agoI'm tempted to get one, but it doesn't support HDR+ and some DV profiles, and AVI. Hopefully once the new Nintendo Switch comes out (as that's been the cadence for new Shields) an updated version will come out with updated support.
- barbazoo 4y agoHmm, doesn't seem to be scaling early seasons of Seinfeld to HD. I could use that!
- tristor 4y agoI had 5 Shields in my family I maintained/advised people to buy, they all went in the trash and got replaced by Apple TV as soon as Google callously and retroactively forced tracking and ads onto the Shield. I loved what the Shield was, but what it is now is utterly unacceptable.
- barbazoo 4y agohow wasteful. why not giving them away or selling them?
- girvo 4y agoThough the removal of Gamestream is a real pain, IMO. I'm still mad that Nvidia have done this, but am thankful that Sunshine exists.