2 ms·
"You know how a traditional IRA is tax deductible when you invest, and taxed when you withdraw? Just open that up. Money isn't taxed until it's withdrawn, presu
by mgkimsal 15y ago
"You know how a traditional IRA is tax deductible when you invest, and taxed when you withdraw? Just open that up. Money isn't taxed until it's withdrawn, presumably to be spent."
Huh?
You just wrote that money is taxed when withdrawn, then suggested taxing money when it's withdrawn.
Roth IRAs allow you to deduct tax free, because you pay tax on the money before you invest it, generally a good deal for most people, as you don't know what tax policy will be in effect when you come to withdraw it later, but you do know today's tax policies.
- ceejayoz 15y ago> Roth IRAs allow you to deduct tax free, because you pay tax on the money before you invest it, generally a good deal for most people, as you don't know what tax policy will be in effect when you come to withdraw it later, but you do know today's tax policies. Is there really anything preventing them from changing the way Roth IRAs work, though?
- mgkimsal 15y agoTechnically no. I suspect it's been around long enough that it may be 'untouchable' like mortgage interest deduction, but I wouldn't be surprised if there's some change in the future which re-taxes x% over your initial base contributions.
- cynicalkane 15y agoRoth IRAs and 'traditional' IRAs work differently. Roth IRAs are neither taxed or tax-deductible. Traditional IRAs give you a deduction when you invest, deferring the taxes until you withdraw.