3 ms·
The code signing project I worked on was formally verified. The whole time they were verifying it I found horrible bugs that needed fixing. One even made it pas
by hinkley 4y ago
The code signing project I worked on was formally verified. The whole time they were verifying it I found horrible bugs that needed fixing. One even made it past soft launch. So great job boys but this doesn’t help me.
- jraph 4y agoWhat is a bug in the spec? Or in a part that was not formally verified?
- hinkley 4y agoThere are a couple of presentations out there about how challenging it is to use XML-Sig correctly. The XML part introduces a whole raft of ambiguities. Chief amongst them is document.getElementByID() and element.getElementByID() can return different answers. Compression file formats have similar ambiguities you need to work out to avoid doppelgängers, and then also avoid overwriting system files via canonical path bugs. Essentially the answer depends on who you ask. For my part I would say both.