10 ms·
Rare insect found at Arkansas Walmart
- jschveibinz 4y agoEntomologist: “ah, a rare insect! I will kill it and mount it in my insect collection! And then, I will write about how I discovered it. Brilliant!”
- ceejayoz 4y agoTo be fair... > Skvarla found the specimen in 2012, but misidentified it and only discovered its true identity after teaching an online course based on his personal insect collection in 2020.
- galleywest200 4y agoStill odd one's reaction to seeing a neat living creature is to immediately kill it and mount it.
- toss1 4y agoYes, especially these days when we are driving the 6th mass extinction event, and we have all kinds of other options for documentation. It was one thing a century and a half ago when wildlife was still close to plentiful. Now, take some photos and videos, log the location & conditions, and let it live... Killing & mounting isn't science anymore, it's a snuff fetish. EDIT: Yes, I get it, it was one insect and in this case he didn't even realize it was rare until years later, and often getting hand-on DNA helps, and overlighting, pollution, habitat destruction are far larger drivers. But teaching the habit of collecting and mounting bugs goes far beyond the handfuls of PhD entomologists. I remember being taught about it and encouraged in something like 6th grade. It's not harmless like collecting stamps and, unless you're going to actually do DNA analysis on that sample, still seems to me like more of a cargo-cult/fetish activity, so I'd hope we could get beyond it.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Now, take some photos and videos, log the location & conditions, and let it live... From the article, a microscope and DNA testing were required to confirm: > "We were watching what Dr. Skvarla saw under his microscope and he's talking about the features and then just kinda stops," said Codey Mathis, a doctoral candidate in entomology at Penn State. "We all realized together that the insect was not what it was labeled and was in fact a super-rare giant lacewing. I still remember the feeling. It was so gratifying to know that the excitement doesn't dim, the wonder isn't lost. Here we were making a true discovery in the middle of an online lab course." > For additional confirmation, Skvarla and his colleagues performed molecular DNA analyses on the specimen. Since confirming its true identity, Skvarla has deposited the insect safely in the collections of the Frost Entomological Museum at Penn State, where scientists and students will have access to it for further research.
- adrianN 4y agoI bet there are a lot of sciency things you can do to a specimen that you can't do to a photograph of a specimen. And it's not like a few thousand specimens in museums are driving mass extinction. It's habitat destruction and climate change.
- atkailash 4y ago[dead]
- AlexandrB 4y agoWhen it comes to insects, I think your anger is misplaced. Capturing and mounting a specimen hardly makes a dent compared to how many die on car windshields, due to pesticide use, or from loss of habitat. Adult insects also tend to have a short life - for many species only one season. And in this case the collection was done for a valid scientific purpose, not just for funsies.
- reaperducer 4y agoCapturing and mounting a specimen hardly makes a dent compared to how many die on car windshields Well, the point here is that this was a "rare" insect. Comparing the number of a particular rare insect to the number of common mosquitoes doesn't make sense.
- sliken 4y agoHeh, well driving a car at 60 mph during on the wrong day on the wrong road would kill 100x more bugs than a entomologist does in their entire career.
- stevenwoo 4y agoReminds me of the guy killing the oldest extant tree specimen to get their core sampler out. https://www.radiolab.org/episodes/91722-be-careful-what-you-plan-for https://www.radiolab.org/episodes/91722-be-careful-what-you-...
- subsubzero 4y agoAs an aspiring entomologist (when I was younger) its very common. I would have put it in a jar when I got home and observed it but you have to know that insects have very short lives and one in a polluted urban setting would not live long anyways. I think people conflate insects lifespans with mammals(which can be as long or longer than humans).
- Cpoll 4y agoWell, what else do you do with it? Insects aren't pandas, there's no world where killing one will have an ecological effect.
- he_is_legend 4y agoYou could say the same for humans, yet for some reason its a crime.
- unixgoddess 4y agoit's the opposite actually. Insects are incomparably more important than highly complex highly specialized animals when it comes to biodiversity.
- ceejayoz 4y agoInsects as a whole, yes. A single insect, generally not. If an endangered insect species is down to a population where single individuals matter, it's already a goner.
- atkailash 4y ago[dead]
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThe Lord Howe Island Stick Insect bounced back from a remnant population of 24 individuals once rediscovered and taken to a larger habitat free from the predation that extirpated them from their original island.
- ceejayoz 4y agoMaybe. https://lhimuseum.com/learn/phasmids/ https://lhimuseum.com/learn/phasmids/ > In 2014, an unauthorised climbing team sighted live stick insects near the summit of Ball’s Pyramid, in a thicket of sedge plants rooted in very thin soils at an altitude of 500 metres, suggesting that the insect’s range on the island is more widespread than previously thought, and that its food preferences are not limited to Melaleuca howeana. That species likely was a goner, barring the human breeding program. Successful reintroduction is going to require humans to finish wiping out the rat population on Lord Howe Island (which wiped the insects out there in just two years after their 1918 introduction).
- reborned 4y agoThe insect was on the exterior wall of a Walmart - it was likely not long for this world. That's the nature of science though. The story does remind me of a documentary I saw on a researcher of rare lizards in the Australian outback. Over 30 years he collected thousands of specimens. The interviewer asked if he might be harming the population of the various lizard species he was studying. The researcher thought about it for a second and said he used to believe the populations were large enough that it did not matter, but then admitted he isn't so sure now.
- bell-cot 4y agoIs there any indication that the insect was alive and reproductively relevant when he plucked it off the side of the building? I've lived in areas where swarms of dead & dying mayflies (aka fish flies) appear on the sides of buildings every year.
- korroziya 4y agoI assure you, entomologists have done more to help insect welfare than you ever will.
- jschveibinz 4y agoThat could be true, if you knew anything about me. But the fact is that like all science, there are ethical considerations to be considered. Here is an article that attempts to address this issue: https://faunalytics.org/entomology-and-the-ethical-treatment-of-insects/ https://faunalytics.org/entomology-and-the-ethical-treatment...
- korroziya 4y agoYou made a cheap glib remark about an entire scientific group and now you want to try and backtrack with a link as though you weren't acting like a pretentious teenager. Just take the loss and move on.
- jschveibinz 4y agoFair enough. Your comment made me giggle a bit, but I will take your wisdom and move on.
- pvaldes 4y agoYup, professional entomologists study insects all the time. Is what they do. And to identify it they need to look at things that aren't visible in a photo. Moreover, photos are not a valid proof of anything anymore because they are easily falsifiable. Individuals are not important, we protect populations. And to detect valuable populations we need to take samples.
- Natsu 4y agoThere aren't that many insects that live longer than a year because they're sensitive to cold and most overwinter as eggs or pupae of some kind. This one in particular would've been dead in a few days. Anyhow, if you study these, and I have done so, then yes, you absolutely will notice any unusual insects around you, to the point where I can remember pretty much every time I ever saw a Buckeye butterfly, any sort of giant silk moth, mole cricket or Queen.
- toss1 4y ago>>Scientists hypothesize the insect's disappearance could be due to the ever-increasing amount of artificial light and pollution of urbanization; Although this has not been established as the cause of demise of this specific species, over-lighting is a huge problem. It is expensive cargo-culting, and the fact that LED lighting is so much more efficient to run, just makes the cargo-culting of lighting up everything all the time that much worse. We really need to stop it, it screws with the lifecycle of almost every plant & animal including us. Dark skies aren't just for stargazers. Whenever you get the chance, advocate for minimizing and shielding lighting.
- Nifty3929 4y agoI think that, in general, people will agree with you and would prefer not too have so much ambient light at night. So assuming that, I think it's a good idea to ask the question: If people general prefer a dark sky at night, why do we have so much lighting? There are probably a lot of benefits that people get from lighting that would be lost with less of it. If we don't understand what those are, it's hard to weigh the pros and cons.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> If people general prefer a dark sky at night, why do we have so much lighting? Because it's been too gradual of a thing for most folks to really notice. Take someone to a dark sky site and they'll likely have their mind blown. I was in Freycinet National Park in Tasmania last year, and you could step out of a lit room with no time for eyes to adjust and still see the Milky Way laid out in the sky.
- edhelas 4y agoFrom what I read from it, it is driven by the "fear of the dark" in a lot of cases. Also, what could prevent us to have lights that are turned of when there is no-one around and for the other cases, have our own source of light (like for example... a mobile phone or a head-light) ? Big optimization.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> If people general prefer a dark sky at night, why do we have so much lighting? At the risk of stating the obvious, it is because your assumption is incorrect. Or perhaps more specifically, it is too narrowly focused. People may generally prefer a dark sky, but clearly they don't generally prefer it over having a well lit landscape.
- joelfried 4y agoAn Augmented Reality Walmart? We're there already? Ohhhhh, that kind of AR!
- cptcobalt 4y agohaha, I thought along the same lines, but more like it was a "Walmart" (used a colloquial term) for digitally scanned assets that can be used in AR projects
- stuff4ben 4y agoMy biggest takeaway from this article was how excited the processor and his students were, when during the Zoom online lab, they discovered that it was an extremely rare specimen. That giddiness and excitement of discovery and just nerding-out resonates with me.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoWalmart was a red herring. Most interesting was how disrupting life via the lockdown led to a more mindful examination of what you’ve collected while careening through normal life led to a discovery a decade after collection.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoIt probably came in on a truck
- TacticalCoder 4y agoNot that that long ago (10 years? 15 years? Phones with camera were already common), a very rare brazilian wandering spider bit someone in a supermarket in the UK. It then looked ultra aggressive, which is uncommon for spiders, so someone took a picture with its phone. If I remember correctly it's thanks to showing the picture to the doctor, which had it sent to a zoo (!), that they realized how dangerous it was and thankfully another zoo (?) had the serum. My memory is fussy but it happened, in the UK. Turns out the spider traveled all the way from Brazil into... Bananas. Another common name for the brazilian wandering spider is the "banana spider" : ) Too lazy too google it so I posted what I remember ; ) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoneutria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phoneutria
- Rebelgecko 4y agoFrom the wiki article, "Phoneutria venom is potentially medically significant to humans". I feel like that sentence gives very little actual information while giving readers' imaginations the opportunity to run amok.
- TacticalCoder 4y agoOh it's seriously bad I think: "The spider's name means "murderess" in Greek, which is appropriate for the deadly arachnid. And it's no wonder why — it's one of the most venomous spiders on Earth. Its bite, which delivers neurotoxic venom, can be deadly to humans, especially children, although antivenom makes death unlikely." https://www.livescience.com/41591-brazilian-wandering-spiders.html https://www.livescience.com/41591-brazilian-wandering-spider...
- undersuit 4y agoAnd the citation points to a news article that doesn't even make the claim.
- zamnos 4y agoIs this it? http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/somerset/4489033.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/somerset/4489033....
- flandish 4y agoI love the app “seek” by iNaturalist for finding out more about bugs and plants and such. https://www.inaturalist.org/pages/seek_app https://www.inaturalist.org/pages/seek_app
- daveslash 4y agoI am completely addicted to iNaturalist. I haven't discovered any new species, but I've learned a lot. Not too long ago there was some news about some high school kids having used it to discover two new species of scorpion. It claims to be a social network, but it's user interface isn't engineered to keep your attention like others do - so there's a little bit of a learning curve to really figure out how to get the most out of it, but I'm a total addict now. [0] https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/these-california-teens-discovered-two-new-scorpion-species-180980827/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/these-california-t...
- flandish 4y agoI totally agree! I use both of their apps and sometimes the bird apps by Cornell. iNaturalist claims “seek” uses on device “ai” to help find species.
- daveslash 4y agoI have the app on mobile, but I really don't use it... I shoot all my photos with a traditional camera and upload them to the website. It might sound silly, but I'm approaching it like Pokemon - gotta catch em all! I'll identify some taxon and then try to go get as many species as possible. For example, I'm now aware of at least 5 species of Sea Urchin local to me - I've got 3 on iNat. I've seen the other 2, but didn't get a photo, but I know how to find them so I'm headed back out. I didn't even know there were at least 5 here, let alone be able to name them. It's intellectually really addicting.... Something that surprised me is how many subspecies there are of checks notes everything! It almost seems like in the narrowest sense, almost everything is endangered (if you're considering subspecies and phenotype). Very interesting stuff. I promise I'm not a paid promoter!
- manv1 4y agoTraditionally new/old animal species are discovered in the meat markets in Asia, so this is a step up. I suppose someone need to scour those backwoods for new species. In fact, they could probably publish an app and have kids in the area scour the woods for insects and take pictures of them. I'm sure lots of them would do that for some robux.
- Ancapistani 4y ago> I suppose someone need to scour those backwoods for new species. Backwoods? Fayetteville is part of "NWA" - Northwest Arkansas. Between Washington County (including Fayetteville) and Benton County to the north (including Bentonville, home of Walmart) there are >500k people living there. The Ozarks as a whole is less populated, but most of that is to the east. > In fact, they could probably publish an app and have kids in the area scour the woods for insects and take pictures of them. I'm sure lots of them would do that for some robux. Most of the relatively untouched areas of the Ozarks Plateau don't have consistent cell reception, unfortunately. That said... I'm going to do some thinking about that. There might be a way to work with the federal agencies that manage those areas to market something like that. At least in theory, building out the app wouldn't be terribly difficult. Organizing, curating, and getting the resultant dataset to the right people would be harder.
- achandlerwhite 4y agoReminds me of this recent reddit thread wherein a person found an extremely rare velvet worm in their potting soil: https://www.reddit.com/r/whatsthisbug/comments/1180uq8/comment/j9fogx6/?web_redirect=true https://www.reddit.com/r/whatsthisbug/comments/1180uq8/comme...
- doodlebugging 4y agoBack in about 1998 I lived northwest of the asshole of the universe, Houston, Texas. We had a screen door on our house and no porch light. I was heading into the house from the driveway when I saw a cockroach fly up and onto the screen, evidently attracted to the lights from inside the house and intent on getting inside. I grabbed a baby food jar from an outbuilding and went back to the screen door where I found the cockroach, still pondering the issue of how to gain entry. Cockroaches usually don't seek out the light but this one did so that was interesting enough for me to want to capture this insect. After capturing the cockroach and sealing it in the jar I noticed that it was light to medium green colored. It was clearly a cockroach but all the ones I had ever seen were various shades of brown to red. I dialed in to my internet at the time, probably AOL, and searched for cockroach pictures hoping to identify it. I finally found a photo and write-up about this insect. It was a Cuban cockroach. Evidently they had only been noted in the United States in a few places in Florida, probably brought in during one of the refugee waves of the past few decades. They were not common at all and had never been found on the Texas Gulf Coast. There probably had been a lot of Florida men moving to the Houston area and they carried their insect bros with them, probably inadvertently, though you never really know. I contacted the University of Houston entomology department and reported it. They were interested but not enough to need to see it. I ended up keeping that cockroach inside that sealed jar until it died since I didn't want it to spread. After more than 30 days alive inside, a large collection of dots appeared on the inside of the jar. I wondered what the heck those things were since they were not excreta as the insect had run out of that a while earlier. Eventually the question was answered as the jar suddenly filled with activity from dozens of small cockroach kids, each looking for a way out of their predicament. The adult died shortly after the little ones hatched. After more than 3 months, the last one of the baby cockroaches died. I eventually threw the jar out, I think. It may still be in a box of crap I have hauled around for unknown reasons though. People in southeast Texas living near the sweltering bunghole of the state and the universe can thank me for the small contribution that I made to preventing the spread of an invasive species. The last thing we need is a cockroach that loves to mix and mingle in a well-lit kitchen.
- ubermonkey 4y ago7 million people appear to disagree with you about Houston. I've lived here -- by choice! -- for 28 years. It's true we have no scenic vistas, and our summers are notoriously hot and muggy, but - You can afford to live here. Real estate is attainable, even fairly close in. - The arts here are on par with our status as the 4th largest city in the country. - The people are awesome -- friendly, helpful, and generally from all over the damn place. That leads to ... - The food is RIDICULOUS. There's a great meal to be had in this town at any price point you care to name. - It's immensely un-snooty. Unlike lots of nerds, I don't mind putting on a suit, but in Houston there's almost nowhere that polices dress codes beyond "no jeans, collared shirt". And even that's rare. Superficial snobbiness is just not much of a Thing here (vs., say, big parts of Dallas, or Atlanta). - The flip side of the summer is that it's almost NEVER cold enough to deter outdoor activities. You don't store your bike for the winter here. You just keep riding. - Finally, if you're a traveling sort of person, being centrally located makes hitting either coast possible pretty quickly. This has been handy for me in both business and personal contexts for sure. So yeah, step off. Houston's awesome. It might not've been YOUR favorite place, but maybe crapping all over it in your post about a roach wasn't the best move.
- euroderf 4y agoA friend brought back a big potted leafy-tropical plant from Ikea and it yielded a big centipede, about 4"/10cm. AFAIK large centipedes tend to be fairly poisonous, so yeah we did not adopt it as a pet.
- pvaldes 4y agoAn adult antlion. They have (probably) short lives as adults adding a lot of difficulty to watch them There are like "four or five people in town" with the skills, bibliography and interest to identify them at species level and resist the urge to smash them so, rarely seen. It toke eight years to identify correctly this specimen.
- neilv 4y agoHow strong is the "chain of custody" or traceability, with the specimen that was supposedly misidentified originally? It sounds like they had an extraordinary finding in 2020, and it depends on the specimen having been misidentified in 2012. Rather than any other explanation for how this could've happened over the 8 years and various people who handled it. For example, could the labeling have been mixed up at some point during maintenance of a collection and its storage? Could a drunk student have pulled a prank, but it got out of hand as soon as the professor told others, and now there's no way the student is going to tell anyone? I'd guess it's legit, but would be nice to understand how researchers in that field can have the apparent level of confidence.
- compiler-guy 4y agoIt was in a personal collection and never changed hands.
- ericmathison 4y agoIt's theoretically possible for the basic collection details to get mixed up but quite unlikely. The three basic collection details (location, date, and collector name) are pinned on a card beneath the insect and rarely taken off.
- illwrks 4y agoIn my university job I worked in the fruit and veg section of a large grocery store. Every other month we had spiders or scorpions in the fresh boxes of bananas. The whole area has to be cleared of customers and we had to catch the thing and sent it to the head office...