7 ms·
Fred Wilson chooses non representative numbers to make his point: But there is a bigger issue here and that is whether it is good policy for someone of Mitt Rom
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Fred Wilson chooses non representative numbers to make his point: But there is a bigger issue here and that is whether it is good policy for someone of Mitt Romney's or my wealth to pay a lower tax rate than the average hard working american citizen.
Mitt Romney and Fred Wilson are atypical cases.
The bottom quintile pays 4.3% of income in tax, assuming they have any income. The middle quintile pays 14.2%, the nation as a whole pays 20.7%, and the top quintile pays 25.8%. The top 1% pays 31.2% [1].
The difference between the CBO and Fred Wilson's analysis is corporate income taxes.
Suppose Fred Wilson buys 1 share of twitter worth $100. Twitter then makes $10 of profits, which it does not distributed as dividends [2]. This is taxed at the rate of 15-35%, so twitters balance sheet expands by $8.5/share, i.e. Fred Wilson's 1 share is now worth $108.5. He then sells, and pays 15% cap gains, earning back $107.22. To me that looks like a 27.8% tax rate.
So yeah, go ahead and tax cap gains at individual income rates. But eliminate the corporate income tax while you are at it.
[1] http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/100xx/doc10068/effective_tax_rates_2006.pdf http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/100xx/doc10068/effective_tax_rate...
http://www.cbo.gov/publications/collections/tax/2010/graphics.cfm http://www.cbo.gov/publications/collections/tax/2010/graphic... (Graphs are for 2007 data, not 2006 data. Not much difference though.)
[2] Dividends are taxed at individual income tax rates, except sometimes.
- gwillen 15y agohttp://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2003/03/08/ http://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2003/03/08/
- dexen 15y agoThe comic, however snarky and cute, manages only to obscure the point further. The (E) [in the comic] is different than other ones, because there's no exchange of goods nor services for the money between the company and its owner, the Shareholder. Let me put it my way: When a plumber puts his knowledge and tools to work, his revenue is taxed once, at personal level. When a shareholder puts his knowledge and money to work (along with other shareholders, in form of a company), his revenue is taxed at both company level and again at private level. Can you spot the double taxation now?
- lautis 15y agoThe corporation is a separate legal entity from it's owners, and thus is taxed separately. In step E the good being exchanged is money.
- thurn 15y agoThere are other "separate legal entities" like partnerships and S-corps that don't get double taxed. Only corporations have this double taxation. That's why it's unfair. The philosophy here is that you shouldn't get taxed on dividends because you're an owner... the money was already yours. The plumber didn't have to pay tax again to take his money out of his plumbing business (maybe a limited-liability partnership) and buy DVDs, but the shareholder did.
- cluda01 15y agoThis is interesting but the problem that I see with this argument is that you are ignoring transfer pricing agreements. Basically companies like Twitter (and google, facebook, etc.) use a bunch of complex tax structures in different countries to legally avoid paying corporate income tax. Google paid something like a 2.6% effective tax rate. Others like GE paid a negative percentage. So the issue here is that in the case of google or any major tech company investors + company only pay the 15% + marginal effective rate of 1 or 2% which is only 17%.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago...Twitter (and google, facebook, etc.) use a bunch of complex tax structures in different countries to legally avoid paying corporate income tax. Yes, many companies use complex tax structures to avoid paying US corporate income taxes on non-US profits. So what? They don't consume any US government services either, and Fred Wilson paid appropriate taxes to whatever nation Twitter Europe lives in. Similarly, my employees (all located here in India) don't pay any US income taxes. Is there some reason they should? GE paid a negative percentage of taxes because they lost money in prior years and used a loss carryforward. The loss carryforward is a necessary hack to the system to prevent taxation from penalizing businesses with volatile income streams. Consider two investments - one makes $10 with P=1. Another makes +$60 with P=0.5, $-40 with $P=0.5. Without the loss carryforward, the volatile company would pay an average tax rate of 45% (15% of $60 when they make money, 0% of -$40 when they lose money).
- onenine 15y agohttp://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2010/01/135105.htm http://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2010/01/135105.htm Google, and of course virtually every multi-national corporation based in the US, does make use of many US government capabilities. I don't think it makes any sense to say: >They don't consume any US government services either However, I do think the corporate income tax issue is a subtle one. It'd be interesting to compare what Larry and Sergey will pay in taxes versus government outlays for the things that have made Google possible.
- cluda01 15y ago
- cperciva 15y agoBut eliminate the corporate income tax while you are at it. Or switch to an integrated tax system like Canada has, where you get dividend tax credits (approximately) equal to the taxes the corporation paid on the revenues which resulted in those dividends.
- Retric 15y agoYour ignoring 1/2 of Social Security and Medicare taxes. And also not plotting the tax rate of the top 1% or 0.1% both of which are dramatically lower due to not paying Social Security on income over 120k or Medicare on investment income. The bottom quintile pays over 20% if they have a job. Medicare alone is 15.3%. Also, corporate income taxes only apply to US investments, which is rarely 100% of any sane persons investments. To top that off if you actually buy stock from a large company their tax rate is often below 5%.
- orangecat 15y agoYour ignoring 1/2 of Social Security and Medicare taxes. Well, defenders of the current SS and Medicare system keep insisting that they're not really taxes, they're "contributions" for "insurance" that everybody pays into for the purpose of receiving benefits later. I'm all for abolishing those taxes and funding means-testing benefits out of general revenues, but the left hates that idea because they don't want SS and Medicare to be thought of as welfare. The bottom quintile pays over 20% if they have a job. Medicare alone is 15.3%. That's Social Security, Medicare is only a few percent. But the rate is correct; "your employer pays half" is a legal fiction.
- anamax 15y ago> Well, defenders of the current SS and Medicare system keep insisting that they're not really taxes, they're "contributions" for "insurance" that everybody pays into for the purpose of receiving benefits later. Note that the benefits payouts are incredibly progressive. Folks who don't put much money into SS get a much better return on their money than folks who "contribute" the max each year.