11 ms·
The 15% Tax Rate
- jpdoctor 15y agoRequests for startups: Kill the IRS.
- MarkMc 15y agoIn the furore about Mitt Romney paying 15% tax I have not seen one comment which makes this point in his favour: The tax return does not show all taxes that a person pays, and so it's an inaccurate way to compare tax rates between two people. In particular: corporation taxes (effectively paid by shareholders) and sales taxes should be added to the mix when talking about tax rates.
- comicjk 15y agoTo his credit, I suspect he also makes large charitable donations to the Mormon church which reduce his taxable income.
- sunsu 15y agoI would much rather see a completely consumption based tax system. The mortgage interest and charity reductions could easily be left in.
- nkohari 15y agoIf you replaced all taxes with a simple sales tax, it'd be even more regressive, since a gallon of milk (for example) has a higher relative cost to someone who makes $20,000 than someone who makes $2,000,000. Also, it could have an unintentionally bad effect on our (now very consumer-driven) economy. You don't want to discourage people from spending money.
- mattgreenrocks 15y agoWhat if we special-cased the essential consumables a bit? Not very elegant, and probably a bit exploitable, but I can't think of any glaring holes (yet). As for your second objection, I don't see the issue. If they don't want to be taxed, they can forego buying something.
- icebraining 15y agoAs for your second objection, I don't see the issue. If they don't want to be taxed, they can forego buying something. That's parent's point: if I one buys less because of the tax, that's means someone or some company has lost a sale, which means they'll need to cut back on spending, etc. In a consumption based economy, you want money to be constantly re-injected into the economy to prevent stagnation.
- mattgreenrocks 15y agoThen perhaps it's time to move past a consumption based economy. We already have too much crap.
- icebraining 15y agoWell, consumption doesn't have to be physical stuff you buy. Paying for services or digital content is still consumption.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoOn the other hand, a consumption tax taxes people proportionally to the benefits they receive from society. It might be less progressive w.r.t. income than our current system, but it is arguably more fair. It's also hardly clear that the tax burden is even felt by the rich. Consider an investor with millions in investments who only consumes $50k/year. He would like to invest in his new venture, a medical search engine. But because of the taxation, he has less money for this investment. Think: who is forced to consume less as a result of taxation? The rich man continues to consume $50k/year. Instead, goods and services have been redistributed from the medical search engine to government uses. The real question about taxing investors: do we believe the government will spend the money better than Fred Wilson would? See also: http://www.thebigquestions.com/2011/04/18/the-man-who-cant-be-taxed/ http://www.thebigquestions.com/2011/04/18/the-man-who-cant-b...
- notahacker 15y agoThe ability to choose when to work and on what terms is a vastly greater benefit than mere consumption goods. Your link is really unhelpful to the idea of consumption taxes and I'm actually surprised to see you post a line of reasoning that suggests allocation of fiat money is zero sum in the medium term, especially in response to someone making a point about the economy being driven by consumption. The $84 million belonging to Mr Kendrick might have been invested in US businesses providing valuable services (although if his private wealth managers are competent, he'd have been better off investing in foreign companies or shorting the housing market in the last few years. Earlier on, maybe, or maybe he'd have done fine placing speculative bets on asset bubbles that create nothing except liquidity for malinvestment and problems afterwards). But given the existence of fiat money created by the fractional reserve system, taxing Mr Kendrick's wealth shouldn't result in a reduction in the supply of bank loans unless the banks are running low on reserves. The government has a whole host of non-fiscal policy instruments to encourage more loans if that's the problem. It's not a straight opportunity cost decision since the government isn't consuming the money out of existence, even if their spending is utterly devoid of foresight. Welfare check recipients and pointless bureaucrats consume much greater proportions of their income, which ultimately returns via a flows back into the hands of private investors via the mechanism of people actually buying products. Investors, especially passive ones apparently indifferent to returns, don't create profit; consumers buying things do. Shifting the burden from income to consumption taxes discourages that spending, especially if the government has to recoup the revenues Mr Kendrick's $84 million from people that actually get put off by higher prices. If consumers buy less, even Fred Wilson isn't going to get good returns from his investments.
- orangecat 15y agoThe mortgage interest and charity reductions could easily be left in. But shouldn't be. Especially mortgage interest; it should be painfully clear by now that blindly encouraging people to buy houses is not a good plan.
- veyron 15y agoAnother problem with how capital gains are taxed is that the social security and medicare taxes are not assessed.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoFred Wilson chooses non representative numbers to make his point: But there is a bigger issue here and that is whether it is good policy for someone of Mitt Romney's or my wealth to pay a lower tax rate than the average hard working american citizen. Mitt Romney and Fred Wilson are atypical cases. The bottom quintile pays 4.3% of income in tax, assuming they have any income. The middle quintile pays 14.2%, the nation as a whole pays 20.7%, and the top quintile pays 25.8%. The top 1% pays 31.2% [1]. The difference between the CBO and Fred Wilson's analysis is corporate income taxes. Suppose Fred Wilson buys 1 share of twitter worth $100. Twitter then makes $10 of profits, which it does not distributed as dividends [2]. This is taxed at the rate of 15-35%, so twitters balance sheet expands by $8.5/share, i.e. Fred Wilson's 1 share is now worth $108.5. He then sells, and pays 15% cap gains, earning back $107.22. To me that looks like a 27.8% tax rate. So yeah, go ahead and tax cap gains at individual income rates. But eliminate the corporate income tax while you are at it. [1] http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/100xx/doc10068/effective_tax_rates_2006.pdf http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/100xx/doc10068/effective_tax_rate... http://www.cbo.gov/publications/collections/tax/2010/graphics.cfm http://www.cbo.gov/publications/collections/tax/2010/graphic... (Graphs are for 2007 data, not 2006 data. Not much difference though.) [2] Dividends are taxed at individual income tax rates, except sometimes.
- gwillen 15y agohttp://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2003/03/08/ http://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2003/03/08/
- dexen 15y agoThe comic, however snarky and cute, manages only to obscure the point further. The (E) [in the comic] is different than other ones, because there's no exchange of goods nor services for the money between the company and its owner, the Shareholder. Let me put it my way: When a plumber puts his knowledge and tools to work, his revenue is taxed once, at personal level. When a shareholder puts his knowledge and money to work (along with other shareholders, in form of a company), his revenue is taxed at both company level and again at private level. Can you spot the double taxation now?
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoI think the key takeaway here is that complexity is a completely different thing than policy. We've had all sorts of politicians make all kinds of great speeches about various policies to implement with the tax code. All that got us was a complex mess. Inside that mess was a lot of corruption paid for by lobbiests. You can hide a lot of cronyism in a tax code. I think no matter what you want the tax system to do, as technologists we can ask you to make it do that in a very simple, understandable way. So I support a flat tax, but not because it's "fair." I care about structure, I don't care about fair. Make it understandable, and then we can all decide whether it's fair or not. We'll vote people in and out of office depending on whether it's fair or not. Make it complex and we're stuck just voting on tax code depending on how emotionally somebody's speech appeals to us. We've found that while this will work for a few decades, it's not scalable over longer periods of time.
- tzs 15y agoA flat tax is completely independent of whether or not the tax system is complicated. There are basically two issues when designing an income tax: 1. For a given taxable income, what is the tax? 2. What is taxable income? To make a flat tax you fiddle with item #1. This involves changing a page of the tax code. To make a less complicated tax, you fiddle with item #2. This involves changing the other 71000 pages of the code.
- ashconnor 15y agoThen make it simple like Estonia did. http://www.slideshare.net/rahamin/estonian-taxes-and-tax-structure-2010 http://www.slideshare.net/rahamin/estonian-taxes-and-tax-str...
- chrisbennet 15y agoThe ability to give tax breaks is one of the most powerful things a congressman can do. Take that away and the congressman will have a hard time justifying (or attracting) bribes/campaign donations. I really don't see congress voting to reduce their own power.
- llambda 15y ago> I've heard a number of arguments over the years against a flat tax. One is that a flat tax is regressive meaning that it penalizes lower income earners by taxing them at the same rate as higher earners. But I think we are all coming to realize that the current system may be even more regressive since most wealthy people find ways to pay lower tax rates. Let me preface this by saying, I don't necessarily disagree with the ideas presented in this article, however that quoted bit is a very weak argument. Essentially the author is arguing that because the current system is regressive that justifies moving to a flat tax rate. However this does not actually provide an argument for why a flat tax rate is less regressive, rather he only asserts that the current system is not ideal. If you're going to sell people on the idea, you've definitely got to come up with some strong arguments for your proposal and not just arguments against the current implementation. I think such arguments exist, but this isn't a great presentation of them.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jasonkester 15y agoWouldn't a flat tax with a nice high threshold be as non-regressive as you could get? Say X% of everything you make over $30k? Poor people pay roughly zero. Rich people like us pay almost exactly X%. Sorted. Extra points if the government looks at everybody's W-2s & 1099s, decides how much it needs and calculates an X accordingly for that year. Then sends me a bill.
- comicjk 15y agoThat's a nice way to carve out the middle class. Why not just have a graduated tax system with a clean base? It's not the tax brackets that make it complicated, it's the byzantine process of calculating "taxable income."
- bunderbunder 15y agoRealistically, the two are identical. Each is a bracketed, progressive income taxation system. The only thing that distinguishes them is the number of tax brackets. What's often presented as a "flat tax" actually has two brackets. The first, which starts at $0, has a 0% tax. The second, which starts at $X, has a Y% tax.
- dimitar 15y agoWhen a 10% corporate tax and 10% income taxes for individuals were introduced in Bulgaria, government ministries and agencies started increasing their indirect taxes to balance their budgets. Suddenly if you are running a business you'll have to pay weird registration fees and if you are fined the fine will be huge too. Also, If everyone paid 15% (in total) I doubt it would appear fair. Wealthier people may benefit more from government policy, why should they pay the same amount? A low flat tax rate isn't realistic. Maybe if it was higher it might have worked, but you'll have to have welfare spending to offset taxing people into poverty. Which practically the same as having a progressive tax rate in the end.
- bjornsing 15y ago> Also, If everyone paid 15% (in total) I doubt it would appear fair. Wealthier people may benefit more from government policy, why should they pay the same amount? They wouldn't pay the same amount. They would pay the same proportion of their income.
- meric 15y agoHow about replacing income tax with a consumption tax? The current tax system encourages speculative investment for capital gain and discourages investment for passive income due to lower tax rates on capital gain. Just look at the dismal amount of dividends paid out by companies in the US compared to Australia, where many companies pay out over 50% of their profits in dividends. A person who earns a $10m a year but only spends $20,000 pays close to the same tax as a person who earns $10m and spends all $10m. Both contributed lots to society to earn that $10m, but since the first person only spends $20,000 he only claims back a tiny amount from society resources due to him for his contribution. The second person claims back everything, equal in value to his contribution, resulting in no net gain to society. [correction: less net gain, because earning $10m would likely have provided several times that in benefits to society] Replacing income taxes with only consumption taxes will further increase incentive for production, while discouraging unnecessary consumption. You'd get more people like the first person than the second person, and society will reap more of the rewards of more productive individuals, who use up less resources. It'll be like society giving out pieces of paper that is put in a building called a bank in return for real goods and services, that are carefully allocated because no one wants to waste anything. An example of a consumption tax is the VAT.
- rdouble 15y agoA person who earns a $10m a year but only spends $20,000 pays close to the same tax as a person who earns $10m and spends all $10m. Only if you ignore sales tax and other taxes incurred when spending money (hotels, fuel).
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mseebach 15y agoFirst, there is already a sales tax, so the guy spending $10m would probably pay $500.000 (5%), or 25 times more than the other guy spend. Second, low income families spend all their money making ends meet, whereas high income families have a lot more latitude in adjusting their expenditure. Offsetting this with deductions will be a bureaucratic nightmare.
- mseebach 15y agoSo when an investor pays 15% "income" tax, it's on money that his company already paid 28% tax on (for a total of 39.8% tax). But as it's capital gains, there's a capital investment - money which again had to be earned, taxed and subjected to a risky investment. It seems to me that if the benchmark tax rate is 40% (AVC says his brothers pay 40-50% on their salaries), and the 15% rate is raised, it would be beneficial for the investors to simply take a salary and bonus instead?
- comicjk 15y agoAt least in the US, the average actual corporate tax rate is much lower than the statutory (by about half). Corporations get deductions far beyond what individuals do.
- mseebach 15y agoPresumably they get deductions for expenses? Money that's spend can't get paid out in dividends.
- gwillen 15y agohttp://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2003/03/08/ http://www.gocomics.com/tomthedancingbug/2003/03/08/
- pwg 15y ago> And then I often think of my two brothers who probably pay 40-50% of their income each year in federal, state, and local taxes. It just seems so unfair. If the author really thinks his 28% tax rate is very unfair in light of his two brothers paying 40-50% taxes, he could donate the difference between 28% and 40-50% for himself to the Treasury each year, and effectively be paying a 40-50% rate.
- Aloisius 15y agoIt isn't just unfair that he is paying a lower rate. It is unfair that everyone like him is paying a lower rate. Him donating money will have no effect on the unfairness, only on his guilt. That said, while I benefit personally from the low long term capital gains tax, carried interest is ridiculous.
- dmd149 15y agoIt seems as if people that consider the system unfair always want others to pay more. This includes wealthy people who want their own tax rates increased (Warren Buffett). They never willingly donate their own money to the government. In fact, I don't know anyone from any income group willing to donate money to the government. What is fundamentally unfair is that the government is terrible at 99% of things it tries to do. This affects everyone regardless of their tax rate.
- cnorgate 15y agoI love the idead of a flat tax. I think H&R Block might not be so excited by something like that though... imagine if we could all file our taxes in under 5 minutes??? The accounting industry would certainly take a hit... This is perhaps another reason there is such opposition to removing tax deductions and simplifying the code. There are tonnes of people who need a complex tax code to make their current jobs relevant. So much inertia holds us back from getting to a better place.
- ck2 15y agoIncome is income is income. If you make over six digits I don't care what the source is, no-one should get a special rate. Because once you hit that level, there is no way you could convince anyone you are "suffering" even if you decided to work 12 hours a day. At that level work is a choice, where the millions making 4 or 5 digits have no choice.
- adharmad 15y agoThe question is, how do you calculate income? What deductions are you allowed? A regular income-earning individual cannot take more than a fixed amount of deductions (in the sense his tax rate is fixed). However, a small business owner or self-employed invididual can deduct business expenses from his income. And there in lies the problem. How do you classify expenses? This creates an incentive to find creative ways of deducting your taxable income, so much that there is an entire industry formed around it.
- Jach 15y agoThe "money alone can't buy me any more happiness" line is somewhere around $60-$70k per year in the US. I don't agree with you that working is a choice at a mere 6 figures. Okay, maybe they can work one year and take five to ten years off unlike most people, but when their sabbatical is over they still have to work again. Or maybe it's easier than I thought to set up a $20k/yr passive income source. Maybe at 8 figures working for the next 20-40 years becomes optional, but even then that depends highly on your investments.
- orangecat 15y agoMid-upper 6 digits, maybe. There are lots of places where you'll have to strictly control your expenses to live on $100k/year.
- mahyarm 15y agoA person with a 6 figure income supporting a wife and children and the bills that come with supporting a household vs a single person is very different. Also the rent adjusted difference in places where you can make 6 figures can add 30'000 in before tax income needed to just break even between two regions.
- corin_ 15y ago"One is that a flat tax is regressive meaning that it penalizes lower income earners by taxing them at the same rate as higher earners. But I think we are all coming to realize that the current system may be even more regressive since most wealthy people find ways to pay lower tax rates." So change the current system to prevent wealthy people from paying lower rates, don't just move the goalposts and call it a goal. The fact that more money often means you can pay lower tax rates doesn't mean those people shouldn't be paying higher tax rates, just that the current laws aren't doing a good enough job at getting them to pay higher rates.
- Geekette 15y agoA good precursor to the tax discussion would be heightened transparency via public access to all tax returns. E.g. Since 2002, all Norwegian citizens' salaries and net worth has been accessible to all. Amongst other things, it would give a better picture of political candidates' motivations as they propose various tax "reforms".
- ifearthefeds 15y agoI think the FairTax is a better proposal, much as I dislike the name. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairTax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairTax
- crymer11 15y agoI'm a huge fan of the Fair Tax and am rather surprised at the lack of discussion about it.
- tomjohnson3 15y ago> The theory in taxing capital gains at a lower rate than ordinary income is that the wealth that was invested that produced the capital gains has already been taxed once when it was earned. Whenever someone argues this point (not fw, in this case) and alludes to being double-taxed, I like to remind them that only the gain (minus any loss) is taxed...so there is no double-tax. ...and why someone would invest in stocks or startups vs bonds is that the rate of return is potentially much greater. I don't think there needs to be an extra incentive (in the form of lower tax rates) for investors. ... That argument seems to be a smokescreen. On another note: I'd love to see a tax rate (or fair analysis) based on discretionary income. A progressive tax system addresses this a bit...and, in my opinion, this is why moving to a flat tax would benefit the rich and hurt the poor.
- Bricejm 15y agoThe argument that taxes on capital gains is a double tax is crazy. The original principal isn't taxed, just the gain - no double tax. There's no reason why capital gains shouldn't have a progressive marginal tax rate like ordinary income.
- waqf 15y agoThat's a reasonable point of view, but here are two (different, independent) possible rebuttals: 1. You ignored inflation. Your argument gives a justification for taxing the real gain, but current CGT taxes the nominal gain, which is generally greater. So the difference between the two is taxed twice. 2. Let's do some math. For simplicity let's consider a world with no CGT at all, only income tax. Say I earn $10k income and pay 40% income tax, leaving me with $6k. Then I invest it and gain 400% on my investment, so I have $30k. If I had not been subject to income tax, I would have taken home the entire $10k I earned; I would have invested it and gained 400%, leaving me with $50k. But in fact I only have $30k. Since, out of my total (admittedly hypothetical) tax-free profit of $50k, I have lost $20k owing to the imposition of a 40% income tax, how can you say my capital gains have not already been taxed?
- pacala 15y agoRe 2. You have not lost any money. You gained money proportional to the money you invested. Your capital gains have not been taxed. What is your point?
- waqf 15y agoMy point would be that since I already have 40% less money than I would have had in the absence of taxation, it seems that I have already endured my fair share of the tax burden. (For simplicity, forget about progressive taxation and assume that flat taxes are fair. Just compare me with the guy with a $50k salary who also gets to keep $30k of it.) As with everything, it comes down to an argument about what's "fair".
- cynicalkane 15y agoMost economists feel it's correct to tax consumption, not income. Taxing income has the effect of compound-taxing investment, which is A Bad Thing. This is why the capital gains tax rate is 15%, since capital gains usually come from money put down that was already taxed. So we get unfair situations, where a business founder is taxed once on his initial investment, again on his company's income tax, and finally on capital gains; whereas someone like Romney is taxed much less. One obvious way to fix this is to protect investment accounts. You know how a traditional IRA is tax deductible when you invest, and taxed when you withdraw? Open up more tax-advantaged investment accounts like that[1]. Money isn't taxed until it's withdrawn, presumably to be spent. With such a system in place it will also become reasonable to tax the rich at a very high rate, without inefficiencies like over-taxing transient income or "destroying jobs". The argument the author presents is strange to me. He says, essentially, that for economic reasons it's fine to tax capital gains at a lower rate. But then in the next paragraph he calls it "unfair". So... he proposes an unsustainably low flat tax rate, which he just implied would be bad, but feel fair... doesn't seem like sound economic thinking to me. [1] Greg Mankiw mentions this idea in a NYT op-ed: https://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/four-keys-to-a-better-tax-system-economic-view.html?_r=1 https://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/four-keys-to-a-b... . I've seen a few other economists also toss around this idea also.
- mgkimsal 15y ago"You know how a traditional IRA is tax deductible when you invest, and taxed when you withdraw? Just open that up. Money isn't taxed until it's withdrawn, presumably to be spent." Huh? You just wrote that money is taxed when withdrawn, then suggested taxing money when it's withdrawn. Roth IRAs allow you to deduct tax free, because you pay tax on the money before you invest it, generally a good deal for most people, as you don't know what tax policy will be in effect when you come to withdraw it later, but you do know today's tax policies.
- ceejayoz 15y ago> Roth IRAs allow you to deduct tax free, because you pay tax on the money before you invest it, generally a good deal for most people, as you don't know what tax policy will be in effect when you come to withdraw it later, but you do know today's tax policies. Is there really anything preventing them from changing the way Roth IRAs work, though?
- tzs 15y ago> And so lately I've been more and more attracted to the idea of a flat tax where everyone pays the same tax rate on income above a minimum amount That's not a flat tax. It is a progressive tax with two brackets. People who reach the second bracket pay a variable overall percentage that rises the more they make. I have never heard anyone make a convincing argument that this is better that a progressive tax with multiple brackets. In fact, a progressive rate with multiple brackets is what you get if you apply a two bracket "flat" tax serially. What I mean by that is suppose that for each major department or function of the government you had a separate tax specifically to fund that department or function, with a two bracket structure. You get a separate tax bill for each of these in some specified order, with the taxes on each being deductible when computing the taxes for the ones that follow. If you take this to a limit, imagining a separate small two bracket tax for every single thing the government does that needs money, and then replace the thousands of very small brackets with a smooth marginal tax rate curve, you'd get a monotonically increasing curve.
- tomjohnson3 15y agoFor those who think a flat tax is fair to all, I'm curious if they would still feel that way after playing this game: www.playspent.org A progressive tax system seems more fair to me (though not perfect) because there is some link to discretionary income.
- dmd149 15y agoHere is one head tax proposal (where everyone pays the same dollar amount). http://www.johntreed.com/headtax.html http://www.johntreed.com/headtax.html