4 ms·
Similar approaches for license plate concealment aren't working out. Newer systems flag vehicles without plates for additional attention. Some recognize make, m
by Animats 4y ago
Similar approaches for license plate concealment aren't working out. Newer systems flag vehicles without plates for additional attention. Some recognize make, model, color, accessories, etc.[1][2]
[1] https://platerecognizer.com/alpr-for-vehicles-without-license-plates/ https://platerecognizer.com/alpr-for-vehicles-without-licens...
[2] https://www.dahuasecurity.com/asset/upload/uploads/soft/20211008/DHI-ITC415-PW6M-IZ-BH_Datasheet_20210625.pdf https://www.dahuasecurity.com/asset/upload/uploads/soft/2021...
- mattnewton 4y agoPlaying devil’s advocate, wouldn’t sufficient adoption making additional attention expensive solve this problem here?
- deet 4y agoOr sufficient adoption will make governments adopt a quite cheap (and even potentially profitable) solution: make obfuscation through such means illegal and subject to fine. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if a liberal reading of existing laws in many US states might over this already.
- lolinder 4y agoYep. It's similar to people who count on crypto to solve government interference in finance. You can't solve a culture of pervasive government surveillance by inventing new tech, because that tech will just be outlawed or regulated to death (see the UK online safety bill). You have to change the culture that makes governments think they have the right to see everything.
- trieste92 4y ago> You can't solve a culture of pervasive government surveillance by inventing new tech, because that tech will just be outlawed or regulated to death I call bs. New regulation moves slower that the rate at which people can find workarounds
- tetha 4y agoRegulation can be made very broad and up to interpretation by judges though. You could setup something like "Circumvention of facial recognition using dedicated technical devices at demonstrations is considered disguising at a demonstration and follows the same laws" in germany. And sure, this would result in a lot of lawsuits, discussions, escalations through different courts while the regulation is being tested - and it might be struck down entirely - but it would stand for a while and strike down _all_ workarounds.
- lolinder 4y agoSure, a few people will always do that, skirting the borders of the law. But I don't want a situation where 99% of the population is constantly surveilled while 1% finds workarounds. I want to solve the problem, I want surveillance to die in the mainstream, and in this space new regulation moves faster than mainstream adoption of new tech.
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y ago"If regulation can stop the tech, it's the wrong tech." —DYIWEH
- beached_whale 4y agoIt is illegal for license plates in some places. But I cannot see a free country doing that for people walking or even people inside vehicals.
- bondant 4y agoWell I don't know if you would consider France a free country or not, but it is illegal to hide your face in public space in France (unless it's for medical reasons or for a special event and so on). So I guess hiding your face from the face recognition system would be also illegal. https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F21613 https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F21613
- t0bia_s 4y agoI wasn't long time ago wearing a mask mandatory on many places. So I guess it would be fine to cover face "because of fear from covid"?
- beached_whale 4y agoI would say it’s a law that violates what is generally a freedom of expression.
- jeron 4y agobet they cant identify something like this: https://www.arnesantics.com/projects/current-cannonball-run-record-holder-audi-s6/ https://www.arnesantics.com/projects/current-cannonball-run-...
- pickovven 4y agoPeople who obscure their license plates should have their cars impounded and licenses revoked. If you don't think traffic enforcement applies to you, you're welcome to use transit, walk or bike.
- moremetadata 4y ago> People who obscure their license plates should have their cars impounded and licenses revoked People pay tax on the fuel, pay tax on the car, pay tax on the parts and servicing, yet you want the state to be able to identify the vehicles? How many deaths and injuries do the vehicles cause in comparison to other deaths and injuries? Take the NRA and shooter deaths and injuries, or even knife crime, those people dont have to walk around with identification tattoos, and anyone can get a uniform to impersonate people of authority. The state employees, namely the Police give you all the privacy you can afford, you wont find this online, but I've been reliably told, that the 13/14yr old son of this bloke [1], took one of the family limousines and crashed it in Kent, UK. When the Police attending the RTA realised who he was, the UK Police gave him an hour or two to clear up the mess or face being arrested. Naturally someone this rich can pull strings, so the mess was cleared up and now nothing exists online. I dont think most people realise how life is crime free for the rich who donate to charitable causes and employ large numbers of people! So why do we need our privacy stolen especially considering mobile phones can triangulate and locate people under the guise of cell tower traffic management and most cars now have trackers built into them to remote shut them down called telematics, also used to monitor the driving of the insured and car manufacturers[2] are proposing vehicles that can even reposses themselves. You can learn alot from this [3] if Hollywood isnt trolling the poor whilst virtual signalling for profits! Now watch how quickly this discussion gets pushed down onto subsequent pages of HN to protect the Rich! Position 11 @ 10:38 UTC 20230228. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Maktoum#Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Maktoum#Controversy [2] https://www.thedrive.com/news/future-fords-could-repossess-themselves-and-drive-away-if-you-miss-payments https://www.thedrive.com/news/future-fords-could-repossess-t... [3] https://youtu.be/wXf_eaQcSdM?t=51 https://youtu.be/wXf_eaQcSdM?t=51
- pickovven 4y ago