3 ms·
That's 300 dollars per acre in SaaS fees, and assuming it's standard apples, that runs out to a cent per apple tree (edit)
by bombcar 4y ago
That's 300 dollars per acre in SaaS fees, and assuming it's standard apples, that runs out to a cent per apple tree (edit)
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoThis might make sense if each additional acre added high costs to the SaaS service but I question that. I wonder how much of this $60k/yr is just rent seeking to extract as much value from the land as possible.
- bombcar 4y agoYou'd have to know the "value add" and what it is saving, which I'm sure farmers have done. But it's not the case that you get zero apples (or whatever) without it, but maybe it increases yield or prevents total crop loss.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoOh clearly the farmer thinks this is worth it, but then when the mob demands protection money that is worth it too. My question is, how much is this business twisting the farmer's arm, or more directly, how much of this cost is profit-seeking and how much of this is actual costs incurred. Because I am always curious what the opportunity for open source alternatives would be. If enough farms pay $5k/yr to developers to make stable software, and another $5k/yr to someone doing data management, perhaps they could save $50k per year in money going to some VC firm. I just don't like the way investment firms will design products specifically to extract profits from farmers (or anyone), and I am interested in the concept of software that has minimal overhead costs, so all possible profits flow to the users rather than up to the top of some hierarchy.
- ilyt 4y agoWell, it' niche (you don't have that many customers compared to normal software) that is also highly specialized, and that is never cheap. And it's not "a piece of software for 60k" but likely "a bunch of specialized pieces of software"
- TaylorAlexander 4y ago> And it's not "a piece of software for 60k" but likely "a bunch of specialized pieces of software" Right but my question still stands, which is that I wonder how much of that total, summed from all the pieces, is rent seeking or profit extraction. AKA what is the markup on this and how much of it is going to pay high returns to VC firms. I say this because I work in open source farming automation and I am particularly interested in lowering costs through open source.
- credit_guy 4y agoYou probably mean one cent per apple tree, not per apple.
- bombcar 4y agoTrue, it's one hundredth of a cent per apple.
- legitster 4y agoMostly cherries in this case. For him, newer trees and varietals, so he was expecting to get something like $10k - $15k per acre. It was actually impressive - for every tech product he used, he knew exactly how much ROI it gave him. Most recently he was excited about an anti-pest system he had just acquired that would detect certain species of bugs in a field and only spray when needed. $10/mo/acre and he was expecting to save ~$10k on pesticide + ~$30k on labor.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, farmers (the successful ones!) are really really good at tracking ROI in ways you wouldn't expect, and they know what is worth it and what isn't.
- hef19898 4y agoAnd if it is, they are willing, and able, to pay. After all, developing solutions for farmers is a good market frol ehat I hear. Trying to replace traditional farming so was only ever a way to blow away VC millions.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, it's one of those markets where you really do have to have the numbers when the treads hit the mud, if your thing costs a million bucks a year but results in even a small amount of profit that covers the cost, they'll be all there. But even if it's cheap, if it doesn't have that ROI you ain't gonna be selling it. I feel a lot of software/Silicon Valley types do NOT expect that at all, given how hard it is to measure ROI normally.
- bluGill 4y agoThere are a lot of farmers and they talk to each other. When something new comes out and they are not sure if this is an ROI a few of the farmers in the area will try it on a few of their fields. They will then have numbers. Running experiments is easy, all farmers do at least a little: it is easy to plant one bag of seed somewhere and then in fall compare that bag to what they plant elsewhere. It only slightly more difficult to do that in a proper controlled scientific way. The only hard part is there are may months between starting the experiment and seeing results. When something shows good results farmers tell each other. Not always, but they at least tell friends and things spread.
- supermatt 4y ago30,000 apple trees per acre?