6 ms·
We’re using our streets wrong [video]
- kitkat_new 4y agoHow could it happen that we haven't thought of these problems before we turned everything into car infrastructure?
- kfarr 4y agoSometimes I think of cars as a classic prisoner's dilemma. If everyone has cars, everyone is worse off than if we all agreed not to have them. But individuals in isolation will always choose to have a car if they even slightly benefit. In most first-world countries now anyone of nearly any socioeconomic status can get access to a car, so we've hit maximum saturation which decreases quality of life for everyone. The negativity of car infra was very slow to appear and for a long time cars appeared to be a miracle. For some it's obvious in retrospect that we've over-invested in motor vehicle infrastructure, but for many the negative externalities are still not clear and/or ignored by the training of societal norms.
- oezi 4y ago> But individuals in isolation will always choose to have a car if they even slightly benefit. Car ownership is a terrible economic decision in many, many cases. It is just metal rusting motionless most of the time. They are a perfect example of irrational behavior. Many people would be financially better off to rent cars for long trips and rely on public transport otherwise (most rural settings aside).
- kfarr 4y agoYes it is a fact for most people when you run the numbers all inclusive (not just car payments but insurance, gas, tolls, tickets, repairs, parking, oil changes, etc) they just don't pencil out. In fact Uber and Lyft knew this and part of their "success" was in leveraging sunk cost fallacy that car owners want to "make extra money" with an underwater asset whose depreciation from making said "extra money" is not included in the calculation of most drivers.
- gruez 4y ago>Yes it is a fact for most people when you run the numbers all inclusive (not just car payments but insurance, gas, tolls, tickets, repairs, parking, oil changes, etc) they just don't pencil out. Can you define what "pencil out" exactly means? I searched around and it looks like the TCO for a car ranges around $1000-$1100/month if you're buying used. At average US hourly earnings[3] of $33.03/hour, that works out to a break-even of 31.8 hours/month. If you're single and don't do anything other than commute to work (30 min each way), I agree that this doesn't "pencil out", but as soon as you have kids or a partner (twice the amount of errands to run!), it easily becomes worth it. [1] https://www.caranddriver.com/auto-loans/a41545320/average-cost-of-owning-a-car/ https://www.caranddriver.com/auto-loans/a41545320/average-co... [2] https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/auto-loans/total-cost-owning-car https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/auto-loans/total-co... [3] https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t19.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t19.htm
- blowski 4y agoThis argument works less well for families living in less urban areas.
- hbrn 4y agoA slightly more accurate name for it is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
- dangoor 4y agoNot Just Bikes has a good series on this topic: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJp5q-R0lZ0_FCUbeVWK6OGLN69ehUTVa https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJp5q-R0lZ0_FCUbeVWK6... It ties into the whole suburban experiment. Lots of single family detached homes on their own pieces of land spread things out, raising the need for cars to get anywhere. Those homes were sold as "the American Dream". Of course, once people are in those homes, they not only need to drive to stores to buy stuff but also to work or to other activities happening in the city proper, thus requiring more roads to build up to get there. Plus the whole stroad thing rose up as well to meet the demands of people in suburbia. Not Just Bikes also covers interesting bits about how this whole thing is also on financially shaky footing given how much the infrastructure costs to get services out to spread out hoomes.
- bena 4y agoI imagine it's a problem of creep as well. In 40 years, we've added a touch over 3 billion people to the planet. That's nearly double the population in under one lifetime. Everyone alive then and born within the next 24 years of 1983 are all old enough to own and operate a motor vehicle today. Roughly 2/3 of the population is 16+. Just assuming that holds throughout history (and it probably doesn't, but for argument's sake let's pretend), there were about 3 billion potential vehicles then and 5 billion now. (Using 4.5b and 7.5b for the population counts for easier math. The real totals are a bit over). We've nearly doubled the number of potential cars on the road. But we didn't do that overnight. We did that over 40 years. And every 5 years or so, it may seem reasonable to make a few more adjustments for car infrastructure. Until we're here, today. And it's not until we look back that we see how much we've given over to car infrastructure at the expense of everything else.
- jeffbee 4y ago[flagged]
- groby_b 4y ago14% of Americans are black. Without debating that the US is full of systemic racism: Do you really think anybody believed "well, with 14% less cars, this works"? And this isn't even accounting for the fact that white people buy significantly more cars. We can add that 34% of black people use public transit, and only 14% of white people do. The problem really isn't black people having cars, or the missing assumption of black people having cars.
- throwawayacc5 4y ago"If you understand this delusional nonsense I just invented then it makes way more sense."
- dav_Oz 4y agoWell, one major player on shaping the streets was the emerging car industry itself. Not the only factor of course but nevertheless a very interesting story [0] to tell from that perspective where pedestrians not obeying the new strict rules began to be called jaywalkers. [0]https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oOttvpjJvAo https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=oOttvpjJvAo
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoIt made more sense to me watching historic footage of when freeway expansion was happening in the US in the 50s and 60s. Congestion was very low. If you're one of a small number of cars, where you never see traffic jams, there's always an empty parking space waiting for you, then it all looks quite pleasant. In other words, it was a luxury that couldn't scale to higher densities. And if you think like an anthropologist you see this same dynamic popping up in neighboring contexts. Why do we have houses with grassy yards? Because this echos the estates of aristocrats in centuries past, where only the wealthy could afford to have land maintained as purely aesthetic gardens rather than some practical agricultural purpose. Suburbia essentially offered everyone the chance to live like a royal of days past. Except because it doesn't scale, that offer ended up being a trap many places. Thinking of it like this, as status symbols that didn't scale, lots of things like the trend towards McMansions makes more straightforward sense. And to be clear, I'm not some sort of density zealot. I just think the options should be more diverse, rather than the current system in the US which prioritizes cars at the cost of everyone else, even in contexts where it clearly simply does not work.
- u801e 4y agoWe never turned everything into car infrastructure. Other than controlled access highways like interstates that are restricted to motor vehicles that can maintain a minimum speed, all other roads are shared infrastructure that can be legally used by those who are walking or are using vehicles other than cars. The fact that some people think we need to separate different modes of transportation is the reason why people aren't trying alternative modes of transportation like cycling. Legally, there's a single set of rules of movement that apply to all vehicle drivers: 1. Keep to the right side of the road 2. Yield to through traffic before entering a roadway 3. Yield to oncoming traffic when making a left turn 4. Make right turns from as close as practicable to the right edge of the roadway 5. Make left turns from as close as practicable to the center of the roadway 6. The vehicle in front has the right of way over the vehicle behind (first come, first served). Follow those rules no matter what vehicle you're using and there really aren't any issues. I've ridden tens of thousands of miles over nearly 20 years on roads and never had a problem by riding in a predictable manner, signaling my intentions in advance, and following those rules.
- Johnny555 4y agoall other roads are shared infrastructure that can be legally used by those who are walking or are using vehicles other than cars. Try walking on the road in any business district and see how long it is until you get a ticket for jaywalking or illegally walking in the road. And while a rural highway with little to no shoulder may be legally open to pedestrians and bikes, it's practically inaccessible since sharing a road with 50 mph traffic (which means real-life 60+ mph speeds) is risky.
- u801e 4y ago> Try walking on the road in any business district and see how long it is until you get a ticket for jaywalking or illegally walking in the road. What law are you referring to that makes it illegal for pedestrians to walk on the road facing traffic on a road in a business district. > since sharing a road with 50 mph traffic (which means real-life 60+ mph speeds) is risky. I've done it plenty of times and motorists simply change lanes to pass me. Most motorists are only comfortable going 60 mph of they're able to see at least 700 feet or more in front of them. That gives then at least 7 seconds to see a cyclist and the cyclist that much time to see them in their mirrors. That's enough time to tell whether the motorist is slowing down or changing lanes to pass. If they aren't, then you can ride off road to avoid a collision. In my years of experience riding on roads with 50 mph+ speeds, every motorist either changed lanes or slowed down well before they caught up with me based on what I could see in my mirrors.
- seadan83 4y agoIt was the way it was sold: - the American identity, "freedom" - auto industry pushing propaganda videos - a president impressed with the autobahn and the military justification for roads (it did used to take a car a week or more to go cross country) - "white flight" - years of lobbying for favorable laws. It used to be you could walk in streets. Then "Jay walking" became a thing and all sorts of car friendly laws - years of auto friendly ordinances that subsidize car ownership (free parking, requirements to build parking) The list goes on, but as the saying goes, you don't miss it until it's gone
- bigyikes 4y agoI’m a pro-car, pro-liberty kind of American, and I just arrived back from a few minutes ago from a trip to Amsterdam. God. Damn. They’re doing something right there. Didn’t use a car a single time, and was better off for it. I love my car and the open road, but I think I might prefer walkable cities… It feels like a more natural way to live. America feels very rigid and disconnected by comparison.
- dangoor 4y agoTotally agreed. I went to Copenhagen last summer and it was _really nice_.
- rexreed 4y agoThe closest you'll get to that European-style city in the US is Boston. It's very walkable, high density public transport, and quite a bit of charm in my opinion. Also cars are clearly an after-thought in Boston proper.
- jandrese 4y agoYou might want to take a look at biking again. Most people think "oh no, I live in a suburb it will be impossible", but once you really give it a shot you might be surprised at how many places you can reach on a bike. A 5 mile bike commute sounds like it will be impossible, but it only took me about a month to acclimate to it and I'm hardy a fitness nut. Now I only drive when the weather is particularly nasty or there is too much ice on the ground. Also, the selection of affordable e-Bikes has absolutely exploded over the past couple of years and they can seriously open up opportunities if you're willing to try. Just because people say that American suburbs require a car doesn't make it true.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y ago[flagged]
- dang 4y agoPlease don't do this here.
- CyberRabbi 4y agohi dang, sorry to be annoying but i have no other way to reach you. I've contacted you at hn@ycombinator.com over my account but haven't received a reply. Did you receive my email? if not, please email me at the address in my account at your earliest convenience. thank you.
- sublinear 4y agoThis is important to major metro areas in the USA, but I'm struggling to determine who watches this kind of video apart from those already convinced? The way this is presented is a bit tone deaf and stuck in the mid 2010s. No practical examples are ever given for the replacement of aging infrastructure or reuse of still perfectly good infrastructure. Costs are never broken down either nor are timelines given.
- pastage 4y agoOf course we have cost estimate and comparisons. What do you want to know? The biggest hurdle is that every car centric project will at least double the cost for other uses of the city/land. That is just for the investment in infra, but car infrastructure is also extremely expensive to maintain so there is less money available for other modes of transport.
- milkytron 4y agoIn addition to that, the land used for car infrastructure is no longer usable for tax generation purposes, it only consumes taxes. Replacing roads or streets to add dining space, small shops, homes, or any other type of purpose where taxes can be generated is better long term for municipal finances.
- Johnny555 4y agoNo practical examples are ever given for the replacement of aging infrastructure or reuse of still perfectly good infrastructure It did mention how things took a step forward with the uprising of parklets and on-street dining during the COVID pandemic. My town still has much of the on-street parking replaced by outdoor dining spaces, making an area that would have served a couple cars for the evening into an area enjoyed by a dozen people. Change is possible if we want to make the change.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- moving_sofa 4y agoThat "reset" word is going to trigger the conspiracy theorists
- ravagat 4y agoOk, I really dislike the overuse of jargon, like these are hilarious to hear: > user-generated urbanism > Infrastructure as a communications project I admire and liked my experience with using streets like Amsterdam and similar, something that has really irked me is the disregard/naivety for why this doesn't and wouldn't work here and why it works in Europe, for example. We have size here vs anywhere else