4 ms·
I think this discussion rather gets to the bottom of the objection to UBI: nobody objects quite so strenuously to wasted work as they do to "idleness". In the v
by pjc50 4y ago
I think this discussion rather gets to the bottom of the objection to UBI: nobody objects quite so strenuously to wasted work as they do to "idleness". In the view of these people, it is morally superior to pay people to dig holes and fill them up, or the white collar equivalent of digging holes in spreadsheets and filling them up again, than it is to just give them money with no strings attached.
The important thing is that people are prevented from enjoying themselves for at least eight hours a day.
- catiopatio 4y agoNo, not at all. The important thing is that the person making poor choices bears enough of the cost of those choices. Otherwise, they will not grow. True UBI would create the largest, most indolent, and most socioeconomically isolated consumption class the world has ever seen — until it collapses under its own weight.
- geysersam 4y agoThe people "making good choices" here being the unproductive office workers?
- catiopatio 4y agoNo, the people making poor choices are the managers wasting the work output of their office workers.
- pjc50 4y agoThey're not usually bearing the cost, though? In a lot of places it's better to have hundreds of unproductive staff than a few productive ones, it inflates your standing and pay. It's ultimately the investors who bear the cost, but they also deem it not worth their time to try to manage the managers.
- leothecool 4y agoSorry to just jump in here, but growth isn't for everyone. If some people don't want to work, I'd rather pay them to get out of the way than risk the chance of them adding negative net value.
- catiopatio 4y agoThat’s the other major issue of UBI — it’s an ideal tool for ghettoization, if those in power decide it’s more profitable to give “undesirables” just enough that they’ll get out of the way — and stay there, quietly. The wealth and culture gap would become nearly insurmountable for anyone otherwise capable of upward mobility out of the UBI class.