3 ms·
Sometimes you can distinguish between primary and secondary sources easily, e.g. if you talk about a book this book is the primary source and everything else is
by jonathanstrange 4y ago
Sometimes you can distinguish between primary and secondary sources easily, e.g. if you talk about a book this book is the primary source and everything else is not. Sometimes it's harder to get to primary sources, but it's generally not hard to get close enough. If you analyze who copied what from where you can find out fairly easily which sources are close to what is reported and which ones are remote and part of the "whisper game." In my experience, almost everyone who criticizes media tends to offer no reasonable substitute for e.g. news agencies who have reporters on the ground. Mostly they refer sources that are far removed from the action reported (e.g. blogs, commentators, etc.) and therefore unreliable. It's not bad advice to seek primary sources in this looser sense, such as sources with reporters in direct contact with eye witnesses.
On a side note, reporting biases are normal and not a substantive problem as long as people can recognize the reporting of alleged facts and distinguish these from opinions and comments. You can test this ability.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y ago> if you talk about a book this book is the primary source and everything else is not Just to add here - it's a primary source if you're talking about the book and it's discussing a new idea of some sort or events they themselves saw - if it's a history book and you're using the book to understand the events it's describing which the author is interpreting by their having read other sources (e.g. first hand accounts of the event), the books itself isn't a primary source. Otherwise I agree with what you're saying.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoThat's a good point and important. My background is philosophy so I wasn't thinking about books describing historical events.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoYeah, my background is history so that explains the difference in how we're considering things.