3 ms·
Excellent. Is the EFF a reasonable organization to lead this fight? I am not a member of the EFF but sometimes I give them tiny bits of money when they do somet
by mark_l_watson 15y ago
Excellent. Is the EFF a reasonable organization to lead this fight? I am not a member of the EFF but sometimes I give them tiny bits of money when they do something that I particularly like.
I am not 100% sure about this, but isn't the "Internet economy" much, much larger than the "Entertainment economy?"
I don't hold out much hope of curing the corruption in our political system but I do hope that we can continue shining a bright light at corruption so more people know what is happening. Unfortunately it is the threat of a bright light of public accountability that causes attacks on Internet freedoms.
- Duff 15y agoI think the EFF is a great organization and advocate for individual rights. But their agenda is often at odds with the interests of the "industry".
- rabidsnail 15y agoThe EFF is a public interest organization with its own goals. We need an industry lobby. The closest things to that that we currently have are ACM and IEEE, both of which suck hard as lobbies.
- _delirium 15y agoThe ACM and IEEE probably suck even more than they need to, but I don't see much hope of the tech industry being a good lobbying force even with a better organization. Part of the problem is that it isn't really all on "our" side (if you read "our" to be the EFF side). We do have a fairly strong industry lobby of sorts already, the BSA, but it almost always takes the Hollywood side (and initially supported SOPA). I think, unfortunately, a lot of "our" companies just aren't on "our" side (Microsoft, Apple, Oracle, etc.), because of their MPAA-esque paranoia about piracy, jailbreaking, etc. If it would be possible to make a professional association like the ACM take a stronger and more visible stance, imo that'd be a better approach, because the tech industry's employees are often intelligent, but the tech industry's companies would imo be more likely to just lobby as a special interest, not in any sort of enlightened way. So it needs to be structured so the employees, not their employers, control the lobbying organization.
- rabidsnail 15y agoThe BSA is a lobby for the shrink-wrapped software industry, which is even more in competition with the internet services industry than the movie industry is.