2 ms·
...(neo-)classical economic theory has some flaws, in that it assumes prices will track supply/demand balance and maximize market participants' utility... No,
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
...(neo-)classical economic theory has some flaws, in that it assumes prices will track supply/demand balance and maximize market participants' utility...
No, classical economic theory doesn't assume this. It derives this as a conclusion under some specific assumptions: demand and supply are elastic, many non-colluding buyers and sellers, good information and low transaction costs. The conclusion of classical economic theory is that under the circumstances I described above, prices will stabilize near a price P satisfying supply(P)=demand(P), where "near" is bounded by the size of transaction costs.
The paper under discussion is also classical economic theory, it just makes different assumptions: it assumes perfectly inelastic demand (i.e., users have no choice but to buy) and poor information/high transaction costs (buyers can only switch sellers infrequently and can't switch arbitrarily). It also assumes that sellers only copy the pricing strategies of others, and never come up with their own (e.g., no aggressive price competition).
It's not a "flaw" in classical economic theory, it's just applying classical economic theory to a new circumstance. It seems like it might be a good model for certain markets - mandatory insurance for example (auto collision insurance or health insurance in MA), display both demand inelasticity (you are legally obligated to buy) and comparison is difficult.
- 1gor 15y agoAah, but (neo)classical economic theory is defined by its unrealistic assumptions about reality. Essentially, you are claiming that North Korea is also a democracy, only without free elections.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNeo-classical economics is merely an approach to economics based on game theory and utility maximization (as distinguished from, e.g., behavioral economics). The article we are discussing is a perfect example of neo-classical economics - it's pure game theory. If you want to argue that the assumptions made by the article are more accurate in general than the more common assumptions (good information, low transaction costs, elastic supply and demand), be my guest.