3 ms·
Political speech isn’t a problem, but I object to people spreading objectively false information. Convincing people to take alternative medicine for serious di
by Retric 4y ago
Political speech isn’t a problem, but I object to people spreading objectively false information. Convincing people to take alternative medicine for serious diseases is just as harmful as yelling fire in a theater or hate speech the victims are simply the believers and their dependents.
This isn’t a new problem, it’s been illegal to pretend to be a doctor for decades. The difference is simply the reach we are giving charlatans.
PS: I can’t wait until a flat earthers start defunding GPS because it’s spreading lies…
- redeeman 4y ago> but I object to people spreading objectively false information. "But they couldnt have known back then, the facts only came out later".... This sounds good in theory, unfortunately people lie, and one mans objectively false information is another mans truth. If there was a magic 8ball that could say "true/false" to any such information, i'd agree, but there isnt.
- Retric 4y agoThere is information you can quantify as false. Ronald Macdonald was never president of the United States. Many things aren’t known and plenty of things might be true, but a great deal of what gets passed around on social media isn’t ambiguous it’s just wrong.
- nottathrowaway3 4y ago> but I object to people spreading objectively false information UFOs, MKUltra, involvement in various coups, PRISM, etc. used to be "objectively false information"... until it wasn't. > This isn’t a new problem, it’s been illegal to pretend to be a doctor for decades. The difference is simply the reach we are giving charlatans. Thalidomide is the famous counterexample. Just to be clear, I don't like people who give bad medical advice. But I am much more tempered when it comes to the rights of ordinary citizens to hold and discuss their personal views about industrialized medicine.
- Retric 4y agoThank you for providing a perfect example of my point. I am not saying people need to be silenced, rather that which amplifies misinformation is problematic.
- nottathrowaway3 4y ago[flagged]
- nottathrowaway3 4y ago> Thank you for providing a perfect example of my point. Thalidomide scandal is a counterexample, not an example, to your point for the following reason. You said > Convincing people to take alternative medicine for serious diseases is just as harmful as yelling fire in a theater or hate speech the victims... I can’t wait until a flat earthers start defunding GPS because it’s spreading lies. But here, the medical/pharma industry was wrong and the pregnant women whose children were born with birth defects would have been better off using alternative medicine (read "placebo") or no medicine at all. There are plenty of other examples of drugs where the prescribing/usage trend has changed because of newly discovered risks: barbiturates, ipecac syrup, opioids. > rather that which amplifies misinformation is problematic It's problematic only if the "misinformation" indeed turns out to be false. Which can never be known at the time. And -- given the historical context -- healthy skepticism of the medical/pharma industry is somewhat warranted. So I disagree that online platforms should discriminate via the currently accepted status of the content being "info" or "misinfo". Online platforms should amplify in an impartial and evidence-based way and -- in particular -- stay out of arbitrating medical industry vs. the individual's right to be skeptical.
- Retric 4y ago> women whose children where born with birth defects would have been better off using alternative medicine (read "placebo") or no medicine at all. That’s a common misconception, some of those women would have died without it. Inflammation of the brain is as severe as it gets, unfortunately it was sold over the counter so people where taking it for less severe issues. It took 4 years for the drug to be pulled from the market in Europe, but today it’s on the World Health Organization's List of Essential Medicines and regularly prescribed in Europe. Thus the reality and perception of this drug are different. Of course it shouldn’t have been sold over the counter, that was a mistake, but 10,000 birth defects is hardly the only thing it did. And in fact most pregnant women who took it didn’t have such side effects.
- eertami 4y ago> The difference is simply the reach we are giving charlatans. This is the key thing people miss in the free speech debates. The reach is because it is profitable to give people that reach and host them, even if they are spreading misinformation and lies. Ban them from social media/youtube/whereever and they still have freedom of speech. In the past, their audience would always be limited to a local network, only people they could interact with in person. It didn't make money to spread their nonsense, but now it does, and tech companies have no incentive to ban or remove profitable users.