2 ms·
How can "low confidence" and "higher confidence than all other theories combined" jive? Does it require "all other theories" to not include "we don't have a clu
by zamadatix 4y ago
How can "low confidence" and "higher confidence than all other theories combined" jive? Does it require "all other theories" to not include "we don't have a clue" which is the most likely of all or am I missing something else?
- gjsman-1000 4y agoImagine if it's a curve like this: - No idea for either solution and we'll never know - 70% chance - Lab leak - 20% chance - Occurred in nature - 10% chance In that case, you could say that the most likely answer is "lab leak" if you must have an answer, but it's very "low confidence." I don't know what the actual odds are, it's just made up for demonstration.
- kilgnad 4y agoImagine you have a bunch of crappy and unrealistic theories about why something occured. What those phrases mean is that the lab leak is simply the least crappy theory.
- Godel_unicode 4y ago“We don’t know” is by definition not a theory though, it’s a lack of a theory.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yakubin 4y ago"we don't have a clue" is not a theory about the origin. It's a theory about your knowledge of the origin. It's not in the pool of competing theories you're considering in this context.
- zamadatix 4y agoTrue, in this case “nature” is basically the catch all “not lab” theory already including the probabilities the source is "not lab but we haven't named the source".
- than3 4y agoCheck out the video I linked above about Survival Heuristics and Avoding Intelligence Traps. Its fairly standard SOP. If you don't know what it means that video explains it fairly well.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DoughnutHole 4y agoWell say you have one theory you reckon has a 40% chance of being correct, one theory with a 5% chance, and one theory with a 55% chance. One theory is more likely than the rest put together, but is still almost as likely to be incorrect as not. Plus "none of the above" is always an option. You could have 3 theories that all have very little supporting evidence - one of those theories could be the most likely of all the actual theories, but "none of the above" could be even more likely if the best theory is still weak. It sounds like it's just semantics but there's a world of difference between saying a theory is very likely correct and saying that it's the most likely of competing theories.