3 ms·
I deeply disagree. If you have a team of quality people but they're all running around in their own direction doing their uncoordinated thing, they add up to b
by crazygringo 4y ago
I deeply disagree.
If you have a team of quality people but they're all running around in their own direction doing their uncoordinated thing, they add up to basically zero. While if they're all working towards the same thing in the same direction, their efforts reinforce each other so the whole is much greater than the sum of its parts.
The expertise of people on a team provides a ceiling for what they can accomplish, that's true. And so you need to make sure that if you've got a task to achieve by a certain date, that it's below their ceiling. The best manager can't raise that ceiling.
But you still absolutely need to manage them in order for them to get anywhere even close to that ceiling. And to go back to your sports metaphor, when an amazing coach replaces a terrible one on a sports team, it's astonishing the difference it makes -- you almost can't believe it's the same team. It's astonishing what happens when a sports team plays "as one" instead of each player doing their own thing no matter how great they are. But that simply doesn't happen organically. It requires a coach, the same as a great team of employees doesn't get there without a great manager.
So ultimately it's not that either matters more than the other. You need both individual expertise and management. Think of the total resulting effectiveness as a multiplication of those two values.
- mattbuilds 4y agoI actually agree with you a good amount. I was never saying that you don't need management, just that first you need quality people. I do think you can have a good team with poor managers that still preforms, but I can't think of any examples of great managers with bad teams that excel. Well first I would say that a team of quality people wouldn't all run in their own direction. They would know they need to coordinate to achieve a goal. Quality doesn't just mean being good at programming, it means the whole process of delivering software. The sports metaphor is starting to break down, but just to have a one more go. Sports is different because the top teams all have top 1000 players in the world. This won't really happen in software. So with software it's more about putting together the right team. One where people enhance the whole, and that's what I think the biggest role of management is about. It's helping coordinate quality people. The thing I was speaking out against was that you could have a good manager with a good process and not great people. The idea that the process can hide the problems of the team is something I don't believe. It doesn't matter how you organize if thats the case, nothing of real value will get made. I do like the idea that the total result is a multiplayer of the two values. I just think the team quality is a little more of a multiplier than the other :)
- ghaff 4y ago>Well first I would say that a team of quality people wouldn't all run in their own direction. They would know they need to coordinate to achieve a goal. Quality doesn't just mean being good at programming, it means the whole process of delivering software. That's probably an optimistic view of even quality people. They're not magically going to know what their goal--presumably aligning with business interests--is. They may not know company priorities. They may personally be more invested in some aspects of the process than others. As far as sports analogies, it probably varies by sport. Coaches are important in general but, if you put a really good basketball team with one or two superstars on the court, they'll probably play a given game pretty well on their own. The same is almost certainly not true of even the Superbowl-winning football team.
- canes123456 4y agoI agree with you but the sports metaphor undersells your point. Coaches usually don't matter all that much unless you are going from a truly terrible one. Bad management isn't like not a great coach, it like having a team where all the players are playing different sports, there is no score board, and people get paid based on how much the coach likes them.
- baby 4y agoYou should watch "the playbook" on Netflix, I think coaches matter much much more than what you think, at least that's what I realized watching the documentary.
- baby 4y agoI don't think you're negating what GP is saying. I like how managing engineers seem to be associated with coaching competitive players in sport. I think it makes a lot of sense, you get the same kind of personalities (team players, solo players, etc.), you have to deal with the different people temperaments, life, etc. If I learned anything watching "the playbook" on Netflix, is that great coaches don't seem to follow any kind of playbook at all. They're flexible, and managed to create strong relationships with their managees over time, while forcing them to be team players.
- waynesonfire 4y ago> I deeply disagree. Wow, really? You must have never been part of a strong, productive team.