7 ms·
New research shows trolls don’t just enjoy hurting, they also feel good about it
- coldtea 4y agoNot just trolls. Everybody peddling some kind of mob justice too
- dingusdew 4y agoThe existence of mob justice has more to do with the failures of the legal system. Many times in history, when the populace feels that they are not getting "justice" from the legal systems in place, the populace turns to mob justice because the systems they rely on fail to mete out justice in any comparable way. When cops can kill with impunity and are never subject to the laws they enforce, you have people wanting mob justice. When politicians can lie with impunity and hide behind free speech and keep their jobs, their benefits, and all, you have people wanting mob justice. When corporations can send bomb trains into your city, poison everyone within hundreds of miles, and then walk away with bonuses for covering their asses, you have people wanting mob justice. These are wildly different things. Trolls are doing it because they want to hurt others, a lot of people are doing it because they want to stop being hurt by a system that has decided they don't deserve justice.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KarlKemp 4y agoEverybody peddling some kind of mob justice also has high self-esteem?
- coldtea 4y agoAlso enjoys inflecting pain on others (who "deserve it") from their high horse
- PaulHoule 4y agoBack in the day Freud noted that sadists felt that their victims deserved to suffer and felt that they were doing God's work in bringing them to justice. In the online space it's easy to imagine that people with the wrong politics or that are drawn to NFTs and ChatGPT like moths to a flame out of ignorance and sloth are pissing in the pool and need to be brought to justice too.
- latency-guy2 4y agoI guess I'm a sadist and a troll, I have no problem punishing ignorance when there should be none. I set standards for myself, and I don't think it's unfair to expect a similar level of standards for other people, sometimes the standards aren't even high, say complaining about not being taught how to do taxes yet you're 20 years old and never held a job. My state of mind there is what the hell have you been doing for the last 20 years? I don't think taxes are difficult, in fact the fillable forms themselves literally tell you what to do, and for the vast majority of people, your taxes are no more complicated than putting the same numbers from your W2 form directly into your 1040. At some point, there has to be no coddling and babying for people. My opinion is that coddling should stop generally around 10 - 14, and consequences should become gradually harsher by the time you are legally declared an adult, in my country this is 18, but my opinion would be the same if we somehow drop that down to 16. I also believe in the idea that people are not robots. If you live your life that way, I feel explicit contempt for you, and I do generally think your life is rather pointless. Some things are truly intuitive, like not putting flammable objects on top of your stove. I also have no problem feeling contempt for people who do dangerous things, and then die, because they force people to clean up after them. Unfortunately, my sadism these days only goes as far as rejecting job applications, doing write ups, and in the end being a part of the firing process. Though, sometimes I am able to suspend which leads to a firing within the next 2 weeks which I guess is good enough.
- Ekaros 4y agoAnd on the other side. I don't see that society should reward or even fix the bad decisions people make. All of the information is available and has been for long time. So why should society pay things like student loans of people who chose themselves non marketable degree? Enough information is out there and can be found to make many relevant decisions.
- qumpis 4y agoSince when does a troll stand for someone who harasses others?
- CharlesW 4y ago> Since when does a troll stand for someone who harasses others? For decades now. The sort of extremely gentle, early-Usenet-style teasing/provocation you're thinking of didn't last long.
- PaulHoule 4y agoDidn't it used to be someone big and ugly who lived under a bridge and would whack you with a club if you didn't pay?
- swatcoder 4y agoThe author notes that they’ve personally expanded the definition as part of their own research. Like you, I think that’s unhelpful and tries to analyze dissimilar things and apply conclusions to them indiscriminantly. But I suspect it’s more interesting to them this way, and easier to pursue funding when your thesis includes more socially impactful stuff like harassment and harm instead of just provocation and ideological derision. Institutional bureaucracy gonna bureaucrat.
- beebmam 4y agoIn an online world of echo chambers, often just posting a different opinion can be considered trolling. "Trolling" can be used to describe such a wide range of behavior that it is barely meaningful anymore. It mostly means "undesired behavior" now. I see it very similar to the word "woke", which also has such an absurdly wide definition that it becomes almost meaningless.
- vuln 4y agoTrolling, woke, racist, nazi, gaslighting Have all lost their meaning due to the abundant incorrect usage over the last few years.
- xpe 4y agoI know what you mean. The words do have (more or less) historically clear meanings.* If we clarify what we mean, we can still use them. It makes it harder, which I think is largely your point. * Subsequent changes in meaning, as used by some people, can tell us a lot about those people.
- drewcoo 4y agoToxic, fascist, it goes on . . .
- anigbrowl 4y agoTrue, but self-identified trolls mean it very much in the context of strategic misrepresentation, as in these graphical demonstrations by 3angledblue: https://wiki.bibanon.org/Three_Angled_Blue#/media/File:Nobody_is_Right_By_3Angled_Blue.png https://wiki.bibanon.org/Three_Angled_Blue#/media/File:Nobod... and https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/003/140/trollexploitable2.png https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/003/140/tro... Misrepresentation can extend even to the point of accusing wholly sincere but irritated people of 'trolling' in order to further annoy them. But when the term is used in the social sciences it's typically tightly defined. It doesn't really matter how dilute the popular understanding is; if it becomes so dilute that the association is meaningless than the behavior can just be given some other designation, such as reflexive control.
- 4y ago
- labrador 4y ago[flagged]
- totalZero 4y agoNB: There may be cases where a troll is also harassing others online.
- labrador 4y agoThere's no art in that, so I don't consider that trolling, but I accept that's what the public thinks
- totalZero 4y agoYou are under the mistaken impressions that: 1. All things created by artists are art, and 2. There is art in divisive and hurtful manipulation.
- labrador 4y ago> 1. All things created by artists are art This surprised me because I don't feel that way, never said this and believe artists can fail in their creations and produce junk > 2. There is art in divisive and hurtful manipulation Trolling can be harmless, along the lines of pranks and jokes. April Fools day type stuff. MTG is trolling, but it's not very artful and it's mostly harmless. You may consider this "divisive and hurtful manipulation" but I don't. It's what people do on Twitter to amplify their Tweets. Both sides of any argument do it. There are some who consider divisive and hurtful behavior can be artful, such as composer Karlheinz Stockhausen who said 9/11 was the "the greatest work of art imaginable for the whole cosmos" and was widely condemned for it. "the composer formally apologized for his remarks, explaining that he simply wanted to remind people of the role of destruction in art" http://www.osborne-conant.org/documentation_stockhausen.htm http://www.osborne-conant.org/documentation_stockhausen.htm
- swatcoder 4y agoTo make your good point less team-tinted and downvotable, I would say that most of the highest profile Millenial-and-younger politicians with social media presence know how to troll and make use of it regularly. For better or worse, it’s part of the PR game for people who grew up with online life and want them retweets. Some older politicians have committed to it to. Obviously.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI don't care too much for correlates with self-report scales (a limitation noted in the study itself in the Further Work section). Game theory offers an alternative approach of measuring a sample population's behavior in a suite of games with varying payoffs. The study below suggests most people's behavior patterns fall into just 4 major groups, with a 5th group (~20%) that seems to just make random choices. Even more surprisingly, these patterns seem to be established early in life and to be independent of socio economic factors. In that study, the largest cohort was found to be willing to experience a loss as long as the counterparty suffered a greater loss, and I suspect that would probably correlate well with the 'sadistic' cohort mentioned in OP's study. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.1600451 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.1600451
- Hyption 4y agoI have a behavior pattern from my father: I'm initially 'happy' if someone is getting hurt (not Bad). Like someone is dropping something or whatever. I realized that's not the reaction I want to have and have a core memory of a woman asking a man who drove into the wall (with the back of a truck) if everything was okay with him before even checking the damage to the truck and her house wall. I want my first reaction to be like that. My older cousin told me on e that our grandpa was also like my father. It's an unlogical trained behavior. Nothing more. And unfortunately that also means there is no reason for people being like that than 'they learned it. Germans have the word schadenfreude. Is it even a cultural pattern and my family just pushed the goal post further than others?
- anigbrowl 4y agoI don't know enough to say to what degree it's changeable; you can certainly train yourself in other directions, but reflexes learned in early life aren't easily overcome. I don't think it's necessarily unlogical, eg it's adaptive if you are engaged in hunting or combat for survival. Perhaps you need to explore contexts in which the payoff for successful cooperation significantly exceeds that for defection.
- 4y ago
- draw_down 4y ago[dead]
- bilsbie 4y agoIsn’t everyone a troll sometimes? Isnt it actually a good thing to encourage people to see dogmatic issues in new perspectives.
- coldblues 4y agoUnfortunately the term "troll" has indeed been muddled. Often times I see people use them so incorrectly. You speak to someone calmly and someone suddenly throws the world "troll" at you. Like "Yeah, ok, you're trolling." I don't get it. How do you come to that conclusion? People with a different set of opinions than yourself would go out of their way to have a conversation with you, construct a neat and tidy identity, just to make you angry? And this is not even in political conversation, sometimes it's just that you have different preferences. In what communities is it so common to have people so obsessed that they construct fictional identities and weaponize a constructed set of beliefs they don't even associate with, just to piss someone off?
- etherael 4y agoBecause a very large amount of modern people believe that the consensus they've had constructed for them is the objective truth and if you say anything that calls that into question the only possibility is that you're trolling. And it's articles like this one that largely cause this. They leave no room for the possibility that someone is genuinely provoking a response that mocks their view by the very absurdity of those views. Instead it's just oh no the ministry of truth signed off on those views and you're perfectly sensible to hold them and if anybody calls them into question they're hostile sadistic psychopathic trolls.
- lapcat 4y agoThe research in the article is actually based on the self-reports of volunteers.
- swatcoder 4y agoI think those “false positives” (to put them most charitably) come from the cultural bubbles we all live with and have always lived with. Whether it’s because of your class, your friends, your region, or now your online circles, you have some natural sense of the world and the range of familiar sincere beliefs — even the ones you disagree with. But sometimes when you encounter someone new, they’re perspective is do alien that you can’t integrate it at all. A first reaction is to just assume they’re being insincere and provocative, and because trolls (and “bots” and “shills”) are a foundational archetype of online life, you can’t help but wonder if you’ve encountered one. It’s going to happen. The responsible next step is to be attentive to that possibility without becoming strictly convinced and accusatory. But that can be hard.
- ldehaan 4y ago[flagged]
- lapcat 4y agoA lot of people here in the comments are getting hung up on semantics, the definition of "troll", but the article author addresses this directly: > Trolling can refer to a variety of online behaviour. In some circumstances, the intent of the trolling behaviour may even be to amuse and entertain. However, in my research, I have explored trolling as a malevolent behaviour, where the troll wants to hurt their online victim. You can argue that "troll" isn't the right term, but then what is the right term for this? I think it's reasonable to use and adapt the term for this purpose, for lack of another more specific term. The article is describing a subset of trolls.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoCyberbully?
- CM30 4y agoYeah, this seems like the correct term for what the paper is describing. Or heck, just 'bully' in general, since that's what it'd be referred to if offline. As much as the meaning seems to have drifted, trolling and bullying are two different issues, not different names for the same one.
- lapcat 4y agoI interpret cyberbullying as more targeted harassment, where you single out someone specifically, likely someone known by the harasser, whereas trolling would be more untargeted harassment involving strangers. It's like trolling for fish is just trying to catch some fish but not any specific fish a la Moby-Dick (which admittedly is not a fish but rather a mammal, of course).
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI welcome authors who lay out their assumptions and definitions before they construct their argument. We see exactly the same in mathematics and we're obligated to generalize the same standard and flexibility to other sciences. I can't count the number of times I've read a math paper which says to the effect, "If the axiom of choice is true then such and such follows." In some ways math has even greater liberty in terms of conjectures - statements assumed true until proven. All I'm asking is for logical consistency where math and other sciences are held to the same standards regardless of what they are.
- spaceguillotine 4y agoJK Rowling sure seems to fit this description.
- anon23432343 4y agoJust looking at the people who justify "trolling" "LoLCows" and why they are doing it you can see this a lot. They think they can teach the person a lesson but the only thing they are doing is either trolling or even worse abusing the person. When you look what people have done to "Chris Chan" then you wonder who really is the "Monster" here.
- logicalmonster 4y agoBe cautious about articles like this. The article does say that "trolling" describes a particularly wide range of behaviors, but then analyzes it only through a particularly negative and extreme worldview. I don't know if this author's definition of trolling is really the same as everybody else's. In my opinion though, in countries without freedom of speech protections, politicians have been increasingly trying to use edicts against "harassment" or "cyberbullying" or "online trolling" to label many kinds of criticisms of them as illegal and to try and get social media networks or the law to shut them down. Certainly, we should all acknowledge that trying to cyberbully some girl that was flirting with your boyfriend into suicide is an entirely different class of behavior than even the harshest repeated non-violent criticism of politicians. Does anybody disagree with that?
- xpe 4y agoRe: the last paragraph above: Politicians, in the U.S. at least, are treated differently because they are public figures in areas of the law around slander and libel.* From Wikipedia's entry on public figure: > A public figure is a person who has achieved notoriety, prominence or fame within a society, whether through achievement, luck, action, or in some cases through no purposeful action of their own. > In the context of defamation actions (libel and slander) as well as invasion of privacy, a public figure cannot succeed in a lawsuit on incorrect harmful statements in the United States unless there is proof that the writer or publisher acted with actual malice by knowing the falsity or by reckless disregard for the truth. The legal burden of proof in defamation actions is thus higher in the case of a public figure than in the case of an ordinary person.
- logicalmonster 4y agoThat's a fair point to add, but note that I specifically mentioned that this is a problem for countries without freedom of speech protections. In the US, we're semi-protected from government interference with this level of free speech that is critical of public figures, though technology firms have the capability of deciding what content is allowed on their platforms and can still provide some form of censorship if they choose to for various real or artificial reasons.
- bastard_op 4y agoThis feels like the guide for youngins that haven't experienced internet chat of any form for the past 30 years before this bit of enlightening investigative journalism. People enjoy each other's misery, duh, just look at reality television. Even sitting at a restaurant for dinner last night, others and I were watching on a wall ChiveTV, which is a constant loop of human failures in people crashing, biffing, wrecking, in general epically screwing up, and one can't help but laugh and be memorized by it just waiting for some poor sucker to fail miserably for my entertainment. Trolling comes from precipitating purposefully the same sort of trainwreck of human behavior for one's entertainment, particularly when good at it. Some otherwise call this politics.
- swatcoder 4y agoTraditional trolling is a response to self-seriousness that tries to undermine and debase it. And it didn’t start online. It’s the fast-talkers way to disarm people who are being overtly “smart” or authoritative. It’s a kind of disrespect and rhetoric, and it can be offensive, embarrassing, distracting, etc etc in ways that feel harmful but its not sadistic. It’s a part of a dialog. This researcher, explicitly, but probably not alone, has expanded that language to also include any kind of harassment and bullying that happens online. It’s too bad, because having different words for different things is usually handy.
- pjc50 4y agoI feel that people have been trying and failing to make this distinction for decades, and failing. Just like "hacking". Possibly because it depends on motivation which can't be reliably percieved by bystanders. Meanwhile it's expanded into fairly mainstream politics.
- xpe 4y agoI've not thought of trolling in this way, and I've been around since the BBS days. Maybe I missed it, and/or maybe I have a more accurate/common idea. I don't know. All in all, it is fascinating to see all the definitions of trolling. Generally, early on, I thought of trolling as an intentional derailment of an on-topic discussion. I also noticed people doing it ironically, which seemed funny at times, but it became hard to tell the difference around intentions. Over time, I've started to expand the meaning include an intention to cause strife to people. As such, it is not just a waste of time but also an attempt to degrade people. Generally, I tend to think of trolling as one manifestation of some nasty parts of the human condition.
- coldblues 4y agoI have to mention that there is also another form, or it may be different from trolling altogether, although it's not purely destructive in nature and it's more of a test, and I think an explanation will best describe what I mean. There are online groups that will try to provoke people into giving them a reaction. You call people derogatory words and make them feel uncomfortable. If you can easily provoke a reaction out of them, they are outsiders unfit for the group you want them to partake in. If they react by "correctly" responding to those provocations either by insulting back in a joking manner, or directly referencing something regarding those words, you know that they're fit to be in your group. I really hope there's other people in this thread who know about this practice.
- xpe 4y agoAs described, this is a form of hazing. Endure some {pain, embarrassment, temporary lower status, insults, etc} in order to gain membership in a club and then later inflict the same on others. This is an unfortunate part of human behavior. At times only annoying (but perhaps useful for bonding if done within humane constraints), but often worse.
- coldblues 4y agoNot exactly what I was referring to. The form I describe is more so to test if you are easily offended by those insults and are easily provoked. If you can find humor or bonding with those words, you can be part of the group, essentially differentiating them from those who are too emotional, easily provoked and quick to react negatively.
- Loveaway 4y agoI used to enjoy typing “ggez” at the end of multiplayer matches. Especially if it was an even game or close victory. Some people would just explode in anger at the sight of it, it’s unbelievable. Someone once messaged me after that for a solid hour just venting like a mad man. Well who do you think is the one with the issues here, I’m just a random stranger throwing out a 4 letter bait. What is the point of getting upset? Literally zero benefit whatsoever. It’s like people loosing their mind in traffic, who exactly are you yelling at inside your car? Of course not talking about things like bullying, stalking, plain mean people. But genuine trolls are good people! Provoking strong emotional reactions with basically zero effort is just holding a mirror in front of people. I always hoped it would eventually lead people to self-reflect. ------ edit: ok I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to offend. Don’t take life so serious. I’m not a sociopath or having delusions of helping people, thanks for suggesting the diagnosis though. In the future I’ll do my best to not stir up any unnecessary negative emotions!
- pjc50 4y ago> Provoking strong emotional reactions with basically zero effort This is just a justification to yourself of sociopathy. Of course there are lots of easy things you can do to upset people. Your job as a citizen is to learn not to do that and apologize.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mock-possum 4y agoGenerally we don’t like to think of ourselves as hurting others to make us feel good - we’ll come up with all kinds of excuses: we’re only trying to help, they shouldn’t have been hurt anyway, they deserved it, I didn’t mean it that way, yadda yadda yadda. Ultimately they’re all just excuses. The truth is, it feels good to hurt other people, that truth makes most people deeply uncomfortable, and will concoct nearly any excuse to cope with that cognitive dissonance. Nobody likes to think of themself as a bad guy.
- xpe 4y ago
- pjc50 4y agohttps://www.goodreads.com/quotes/7870768-never-believe-that-anti-semites-are-completely-unaware-of-the-absurdity https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/7870768-never-believe-that-... "Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past" See also https://newrepublic.com/article/139004/ironic-nazis-still-nazis https://newrepublic.com/article/139004/ironic-nazis-still-na... (2016)
- landoftheice 4y ago[dead]
- logicalmonster 4y ago1) This article has very little to do with anti-Semitism, other than arguably pointing out that a subset of trolls are also anti-Semites. That doesn't distinguish trolls from any other population group however. Additionally, posting a random quote with no context or argument doesn't really bring much of anything to a discussion. 2) Are Semites above criticism? Quotes like this seem to shut down even the possibility of criticism of a large collection of valid commentary.
- pjc50 4y agore: 2, criticism based purely on ethnicity is off limits. You have to stick to either individual malfeasance with evidence, or specific criticism of actions of the government of Israel. This is important to get right if you have valid criticisms of Zionism that you don't want to have dismissed as mere racism.
- 4y ago
- xpe 4y agoSo far, a vast majority of replies here on HN comment on the paper's definition of trolling but do not engage with the author's subsequent recommendations. I'd like to offer this comment as a placeholder for us to do more of the latter.
- xpe 4y ago> Don’t fight fire with fire. Respond with outward indifference and strict no tolerance. Let’s work together to dismantle the power of the troll and take back the internet from their influence. Society and legal standards have a long history about zero tolerance responses. I find it problematic to see zero tolerance recommended. Why? First, some interpretation must happen before a comment gets categorized as trolling.* Second, this interpretation ranges from clear-cut to murky. Third, in cases of clear trolling, the troll might range from being (a) a first timer to a long-time troller; and (b) unwilling or unwilling to change. I'd suggest that any interventions around trolling account for these variations above. Zero tolerance has a way of also being "one size fits all" which can create additional unnecessary problems. For example, if unfairly used, it can become a convenient blunt attack for a wide range of interpersonal disagreements. * As mentioned at the top of this thread, I'm taking the author's definition of trolling.
- ghstcode 4y agoThis is true, can confirm