5 ms·
Disgust comes very quickly in economic history after sweatshops, though. Major industrialization along the lines described here, with mass-scale factories and a
by _delirium 15y ago
Disgust comes very quickly in economic history after sweatshops, though. Major industrialization along the lines described here, with mass-scale factories and a "company town" where employees live/work/sleep there, happened in the United States in the 1880s. And that whole decade was immediately full of labor unrest, most famously the Haymarket riot, but including thousands of strikes, protests, and other "labor disturbances" across the country, due to a feeling that industrialists were getting rich by treating their employees as quasi indentured servants. The backlash was severe enough that by 1900 both major parties were attacking the industrialists, with Democrats having ties to the unions, and the Republicans led by trust-busting Teddy Roosevelt. (I'm guessing the Chinese authorities are keenly aware of all that history.)
- learc83 15y agoI recently read an article about Foxconn workers threatening mass suicide if conditions don't improve, so it's happening there too. Eventually they will run out of their supply of peasants fresh off the farm and things will change. Or robots will take over, which happens first is anyone's bet.
- chlee 15y agoThere are a few issues at play here. 1) Many of the companies are with working with low profit margins, i.e. the profit margin is <5%. With rising costs in both raw supplies and worker wages + low demand from abroad, many of these companies are being driven out of business due to their decreasing profit margin. 2) Since rising costs are eating into companies' profit margins, many companies are looking at relocating their manufacturing base from China to countries with [even] cheaper manual labor. For example, Foxconn has recently inked a multi-billion w/ Brazilian gov't to produce ipads and apple related products there. Other companies are looking to relocate their manufacturing base to SE asian countries like Vietnam where cheap labor and gov't wiling to bend the rules for FDI are still aplenty. Like you said. We'll see what happens.
- hazov 15y agoA Brazilian worker earning the minimum wage[1] every month, and considering that there's a whole set of taxes that an employer has to pay for every employee in Brazil, mainly for social security, that probably will turn every Brazilian employee worth almost 2 to 3 Chinese doing the same job. So that's probably not the case for Foxconn as well. [1]: Which according to Wikipedia is more in US dollars than what a typical Chinese worker in Shenzen earns in a month, US$ 390.93 versus US$ 208.32
- JumpCrisscross 15y agoNot arguing with your general point, but I think the Brazil rule was to get around tariffs (35% on 100% imported goods for the Mercosur bloc). http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/04/13/us-brazil-foxconn-idUSTRE73B6BD20110413 http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/04/13/us-brazil-foxconn-...
- _delirium 15y agoIf that's the real reason, it seems that Brazil's protectionist tariffs are having their desired effect (forcing more manufacturing to be relocated to Brazil). No idea if they're a net positive for Brazil's economy, but this move will probably be taken as a vindication.
- nandemo 15y agoIn my opinion there are some positive effects but overall it's really bad. As you can see in the link in the sibling comment, the overhead of employing people in Brazil is quite big. Besides, there's also additional overhead due to a myriad of non-labour-related taxes, and living cost and the minimum wage are significantly higher than in China and SE Asia. So while we do have a large industrial base, it's not like we have factories for every kind of product just because of protectionist tariffs. That results in the curious situation of having to pay (say) U$1000 in Brazil for some Chinese-made product that can be had for U$500 in the US.
- JumpCrisscross 15y agoNo doubt that's how it shall be taken, but it is not having the desired effect. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/10/30/foxconns-brazil-ipad_n_1066304.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/10/30/foxconns-brazil-ipa...
- DanBC 15y ago> Disgust comes very quickly in economic history after sweatshops, though. Major industrialization along the lines described here, with mass-scale factories and a "company town" where employees live/work/sleep there, happened in the United States in the 1880s. ...and yet most people are still not sure if their clothing / food / gadget / jewellery was produced ethically. For sure, there's stuff like fair trade, and "Ethical Consumer", but these are still niche products. It seems many people are happy to offload those dirty low paid over worked unsafe jobs to other countries.
- forensic 15y agoEconomic development doesn't end slavery, enlightenment values do. It was the intellectual enlightenment that modernized Europe. Slavery is not a transitory "stage" it typically lasts for thousands of years.