7 ms·
Zynga 'losing $150 on every new paying customer'
- kellyreid 15y agois this what they mean by monetizable pain?
- slouch 15y agoZynga, whenever you are ready to charge me for an ad-free Words With Friends for Android, I am ready to buy.
- pg_bot 15y agoThe biggest problem I have with Zynga is that they do not have any creativity. The games they churn out are just another [insert random noun]'ville or a ripoff of a popular existing game (scrabble, hang man, poker, etc). A video game's shelf life doesn't usually last for more than 12 months, and if they can't come up with any unique new product that can capture the attention of a mass number of users they may be up a certain creek without a paddle.
- icegreentea 15y agoI think you (any many other commentors) have touched on part of a problem. It's not the lack of creativity per se, and not entirely related to the whole oh X is just Y with one new gimmick/game mechanic and different graphics. Rather, Zynga's game development is heavily metrics driven. They can tune their games to max out metrics, and make them stupidly addicting, and 'fun' and get their customers. But in general, you really cannot create 'new' or 'innovative', or at least in the way people like those words to mean by following the metrics. You can just create more and more polished and targeted variants of existing games.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- brador 15y agoYou can only milk people for intangibles/gimmicks for so long before they realize how useless a bitmap of a tomato plant really is. Once they do, they're not coming back. CF:Nintendo and the wii.
- kalid 15y agoThe wii is a great example of a system that everyone has and nobody plays. I can't count the number of times I've visited people's houses with the wii unused. All the casual gamers Nintendo attracted won't be buying another system again.
- georgemcbay 15y agoA lot of the "casual" households I know that were second-wave Wii adopters now have and use Xbox 360s with Kinect. So they did buy another system, one that in most ways delivered on the promise of the Wii interface better than the Wii did.
- damoncali 15y agoLittle kids love them.
- molmalo 15y agoI think their biggest problem is trying to act as an indie-like game developer, but growing like a turkey before thanksgiving day. I think people expect more from them.
- teej 15y agoThis is endemic of the games industry as a whole. SW:TOR is just World of Warcraft with lightsabers. Modern Warfare 3 is an expansion packaged as a sequel. Angry Birds is just Castle Crashers with a different firing mechanic. We've become so efficient at extracting money out of the hits, it becomes hard to truly innovate.
- Fargren 15y agoI think you are confusing Castle Crashers with some other game. Castle Crashers is and old-school beat them up with very nice art. Also, the problem you describe exists in all entertainment industries. I don't think we've innovated much in literature since Shakespeare or in cinema since Hitchcock. But there's always some work that stand above the rest in their originality. And then a lot of other works that improve on them or at least try. I don't think that's bad.
- Splines 15y agoCastle Crashers is and old-school beat them up with very nice art. Which is a derivative of Double Dragon (and probably something earlier), but it's a fantastic game nevertheless.
- ido 15y agoHe is thinking of Crush the Castle: http://armorgames.com/play/3614/crush-the-castle http://armorgames.com/play/3614/crush-the-castle
- reidmain 15y agoWhile I agree that there is a lack of major innovation in the video games industry and there is a problem with most gamers just waiting for the next AAA title from a major publisher, I think your examples are all flawed. SW:TOR is definitely World of Warcraft with a Star Wars skin. It also has the most voice acting of any game in history and it is the first MMOs that actually has a story for each player character that is worth following. Modern Warfare 3 as an expansion is now arguing semantics. What makes it an expansion? Two years of development where they didn't really innovate but they continued to tightly tune their well oiled machine and CoD Elite is a great platform that almost every game would benefit from. Is it simply price you are annoyed with because you don't perceive the incremental improvements to be worth it? Modern Warfare 3 is definitely not going to push the video games industry forward in any major ways but Modern Warfare 1 & 2 have already done that. As another poster has stated you're confusing Castle Crashers with something else. Castle Crashers is more like Battletoads or Double Dragon or River City Ransom. The "hardcare" video game industry is moving forward albeit slowly. The "social" video game industry seems to have stagnated already and is just rehashing their current game mechanics with new graphics.
- patio11 15y agoA video game's shelf life doesn't usually last for more than 12 months This compares rather favorably to the video game industry, where exponential sales decay sets in after 1 to 3 weeks for almost all titles, including ones which cost more to produce than every Zynga game produced to date combined. I don't love Zynga, but their model has a lot to recommend it over "Lets make another big-budget war movie/game with $10 million of programming, $80 million of art assets, and $120 million of launch marketing and then try to get it in front of every 18 ~ 30 year old male in America."
- TobiHeidi 15y agoObvious mistake made in the calculation. From "We also know that they had 3.4 million unique payers in the September quarter, which is up from 3 million at the end of December 2010." lead them to "In other words, they added 400,000 additional payers and they spent $120 million to acquire them.” This is an obvius mistake, as not all of the 3 Million from Dec 2010 continued to be a customer in Sept 2011. I roughly assume they lost 800.000 customers in that span (i think its more), then the newly aquired customers triple to 1.2 Million. Thus Zynga makes 50$ profit per customer.
- acgourley 15y agoExactly! I'd go farther, if players stick around 12-15 months historically, and they had 3M users, then in 9 months they could lose 60%-75% so 1.8M to 2.25M players! This of course depends on distribution of lifespans, and assumes that the 12-15 month figure remains accurate. If that's true, they're getting users for as cheap as $50 each, and making $100 on each.
- RuggeroAltair 15y agoOh, come on, guys... You all are over simplifying a complicated calculation. Have you considered that you don't know the distribution of the 3M players? How many of them had just joined compared to how many had been around already for a while? (this could push both ways) Also, have you considered how many new users they were expect to get just by word of mouth and no investment? What is the percentage of regeneration of users that quit in 12-15 months but maybe also brought in other users to play with them? Without knowing the details you can't say anything. I'm not saying that I agree or not with the article, but I assume that every person working as an analyst learns on their first day what you were suggesting above. So, it could be that the analysis is wrong (and it does look wrong), but the calculation that an analyst should do is much more complicated that you guys seemed to think from what you wrote (and two wrong analysis won't make a correct one). I would have spent at least part of those $120M in funding startups to develop new games (and later bring them in, in case...). I'm pretty positive the return might have been better...
- tatsuke95 15y ago
- acgourley 15y agoDo they really make $150 per acquired user, or just acquired user that opens their wallet at all? I'm curious if those numbers on acquisition cover free users at all.
- mpeg 15y agothey make $150 per paying user, most likely because I can assure you conversion costs on FB games are way less than $300/user
- extension 15y agoOur concern is [whether or not it's worth] spending $300 to get these customers when people are spending $150 Good god. My concern would be whether they will still be able to milk people for $150 after there are 12 step programs and "just say no to Zynga" PSAs.
- yahelc 15y agoThat headline may be the only thing that could actually persuade me to become a paying customer of Zynga's.
- X-Istence 15y agoHow about the free users that are simply playing the games but aren't making them any money. I personally play Words with Friends, it's kind of fun and addicting, but I use the free version of their app, I don't ever click their ads nor do I care to (and when I am on my home network those ad servers are blocked =)). I use resources in that they have to spend server time to keep track of my moves to send them to my opponents. Where is the win in that?
- kevinh 15y agoAd networks generally pay mobile developers for impressions, not for clickthroughs, so you are making them money. I have to say that I'm very disappointed that you block ads. Certainly it wouldn't hurt to simply ignore the ads, given that you're using their service.
- X-Istence 15y agoI block ads because I hate being bombarded by random crap I am never going to consider buying. You can hate me for it (hell, I monetize some of my own sites with ads) but I really don't care. For a lot of services whose ads I block it is mainly because I am already paying a fee to get access and yet I still have to be bombarded with ads. Hulu is the worst offender in that department.
- bermanoid 15y agoThe amount of money that you cost them for server time is negligible - when using WWF, you're sending a small handful of web requests for every move you make, at a very slow rate, and over the course of a day an average user of Hacker News probably puts more stress on these servers than a person does on Zynga's by using WWF. I'd guess that the expected monetary value of the increased engagement of your friends due to your presence more than makes up for the cost to provide the game to you, probably by a factor of 100 or more.
- vladd 15y agoBusinesses cannot predict the future, so they must use probabilistic models, especially for budgeting. If you could build a magic crystal ball telling you if the following gamer who signs up is going to end up: a) spending $1000 in virtual currency over the next 3 years OR b) tell to his network of 20+ friends about the game OR c) use tons of resources, no payments and no promotion..., THEN lots of companies would be in your debt. The behavior that you described has been put into a basket by Zynga and mixed with the statistical behavior of average gamers in order to create their business model, where they assume that X millions of advertising and Y millions in R&D and SysOps bring Z millions in revenue, preferably with Z > X + Y. 90% of gamers are non-paying and probably do little in terms of word of mouth promotion, so they just pull these averages downwards. But, as long as, on average, Z > X + Y, everything is ok for Zynga. Because it's the only way in which they can operate without a crystal ball.
- nostromo 15y agoAnyone know where Zynga spends its marketing dollars? Is it mostly Facebook? $13mm a month stikes me as huge considering I don't think I've ever seen one of their ads.
- gergles 15y agoThey have long-term rentals of at least 2 large billboards along the 101... though I doubt those cost $13M a month, even in SF.
- gojomo 15y ago..and those might be billed to 'recruiting' rather than 'customer acquisition'.
- gergles 15y agoThe one near the Oyster Point exit (going North) always just advertises the latest game, so that's definitely a customer acquisition one. The other one I've seen has bounced between recruiting and the latest VilleVille.
- patio11 15y agoPrimarily Facebook (they're FB's #1 advertiser IIRC), but they also had big-budget offline promotions with the likes of 7Eleven, where you could (bastardizing the heck out of this) buy a bag of branded chips and get a free thing of special potato seeds in-game.
- trotsky 15y agoDon't forget paying Alec Baldwin to get kicked off a plane while informing everyone who listened that he just couldn't put down words with friends.
- bmaeser 15y ago[quote]“That's our math; that's not what the company says,” [/quote] sounds like crystal gazing to me.
- jamesredman 15y agoThe only thing that can save Zynga and demand its current valuation is online poker.
- joering1 15y agoagreed but for how long? further, playing poker for cash is slightly different than feeding your cows and selling sunflowers. I am sure not everyone will switch.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jamesredman 15y agoThe only thing that can save Zynga and demand its current valuation is the legalization off online poker.