11 ms·
Has anyone seen someone use a great algorithm for layout selection that actually accounts for the more complete range of user typing? For example, everyone mak
by eviks 4y ago
Has anyone seen someone use a great algorithm for layout selection that actually accounts for the more complete range of user typing?
For example, everyone makes typos and corrects them with a backspace or mod+backspace for the whole word, but this is never accounted for, so a very frequent Backspace key is very far away. Using a post-typo text corpus ignores this reality
Or allowing home row mods in a layout, what would be the algorithmic maximum across all the typing metrics?
Or allowing numbers to be in play as well, maybe hiding then behind a modifier, but in the home row or aligned in a numpad-like way on under your right hand
Or would it be better to type capitalized letters with a one-tap Shift or with a home row mod Shift? Or maybe a quick double tap on the same letter is more efficient?
Given the complexity of switching to a new layout, there is no great reason to keep all the non-alpha mistakes of the old qwerty design, the algorithms should run free from those limitations to get us to the future perfection
- makiaea 4y agore: backspace etc. i've recently used dvorak+karabiner+goku on a mac to make homerow mod keys, based on gabriel-gardner's template. others have used QMK keyboards, or kmonad etc. on linux and windows
- eviks 4y agoSure, all good ideas in the meantime (and you could use right-thumb cmd/alt modifier or holdSpace as a vim-like cursor mod with the home keys as cursor and with H as backspace and G and delete and I as Enter to free your pinky (qwerty-layout)) But then dvorak is obviously not the best layout for this since it wasn't designed with all of that in mind. And neither were the home row mods themselves, for example, maybe only Shift is useful in the home row, and the others aren't used frequently enough (or maybe it's better to have numpad-mod key on the home row instead of the Windows key). So I guess the focus of the layout collaboration effort could be on improving the algo/data, but instead we get a bunch of new layouts that only tackle a small(er)(and different) part of the problem without much of an improvement over he previous solutions (and, more importantly, with no good way to compare them). That would only leave you with the black magic of tweaking algo weights in the end :-) P.S. There is also https://github.com/jtroo/kanata https://github.com/jtroo/kanata alternative to kmonad And re. homerow mod keys, it seems that there is an even better approach not relying on timings (which I think are impossible to resolve with full accuracy, though with per-key timings you can get pretty close), but that's not implementable within Karabiner, so someone had a homebrew Swift solution I haven't tried
- dkersten 4y agoAt least for backspace, Colemak puts it where caps lock is.
- eviks 4y agoBut it's a pinky lateral stretch, maybe AltGr+H (win/qwerty) that use your much stronger thumb+index fingers and also allow to put Delete conveniently close is better? What would the algo say? Maybe it's also not great since it's a lateral stretch, so a better alternative would be something else where you lift your fingers?
- shanebellone 4y agoLeft alt button would be my preference.
- wussboy 4y agoThis is Colemak’s killer feature. Changed my life
- enriquto 4y ago> everyone makes typos and corrects them with a backspace or mod+backspace for the whole word, but this is never accounted for, so a very frequent Backspace key is very far away. This! I use a variant of the classic typematrix layout [0], where there are two huge backspace keys right in the middle of the keyboard, one for each index finger. Below them, huge enter and tab keys (that one, mapped to ESC inside vim). [0] https://www.google.com/search?q=typematrix+2020&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=typematrix+2020&tbm=isch
- 3np 4y agoA common thing in split layouts is putting backspace on a thumb key or two.
- xupybd 4y agoOn the Kinesis advantage back space is a thumb key. So easy to hit.
- ecliptik 4y agoI used key combos [1] in QMK to map various keys to home and top row combos [2]. For example in QWERTY the combo of SD together is backspace, DF is tab, WE is escape, etc. I also make the spacebar and key to the right of the spacebar (usually Alt) to a switch layers when held down with a thumb. This turns the left side of the board into a number [3] and symbol [4] like pad. Advantage I find is it's much less motion and finger stress and is easily replicated on any keyboard that supports QMK while not QWERTY specific. 1. https://qmk.github.io/qmk_mkdocs/master/en/feature_combo/ https://qmk.github.io/qmk_mkdocs/master/en/feature_combo/ 2. https://github.com/ecliptik/qmk_firmware/blob/d79931185c2315ea151ef7f97accfe3eb93e1884/keyboards/ymdk/yd60mq/keymaps/ecliptik/keymap.c#L94 https://github.com/ecliptik/qmk_firmware/blob/d79931185c2315... 3. https://github.com/ecliptik/qmk_firmware/blob/d79931185c2315ea151ef7f97accfe3eb93e1884/keyboards/ymdk/yd60mq/keymaps/ecliptik/keymap.c#L141 https://github.com/ecliptik/qmk_firmware/blob/d79931185c2315... 4. https://github.com/ecliptik/qmk_firmware/blob/d79931185c2315ea151ef7f97accfe3eb93e1884/keyboards/ymdk/yd60mq/keymaps/ecliptik/keymap.c#L163 https://github.com/ecliptik/qmk_firmware/blob/d79931185c2315...