4 ms·
We need to study what amounts of 1:1 tutoring have positive outcomes. If society can’t afford 1:1 tutoring for everyone, all the time, can we afford 20% of the
by hinkley 4y ago
We need to study what amounts of 1:1 tutoring have positive outcomes. If society can’t afford 1:1 tutoring for everyone, all the time, can we afford 20% of the time?
- 082349872349872 4y agoMy understanding is that the knee of the curve is ~10-12 students. Much cheaper than 1:1 or 1:2, but still more expensive than the 30+ classrooms of my youth.
- zozbot234 4y agoYou can teach large classes efficiently, but it requires a very direct, rote, scripted approach that's exactly what most teachers don't want to use - because fancy education schools have told them that it "demeans" the profession, and they've drunk the Kool-Aid. A key component is to come up with memorable text that the students must be able to repeat word for word when prompted - both as a group and individually. (Problem solving similarly starts with trivial cases that the students must answer on the spot; difficulty is very gradually increased, and there's a lot of retracing and review of earlier steps.) This is as close as you can get to "mastery learning" in a large classroom; keep all students on lockstep and highly engaged, trying to ensure that no one falls through the cracks.
- andrewflnr 4y ago"As close as you can get" may be true, but it still doesn't sound very close. In fact the memorization part sounds profoundly miserable. "A lot of retracing" of stuff that, frankly, I probably understood the first couple times also sounds miserable, and inefficient. So, uh, the kool aid is pretty tasty I guess.
- zozbot234 4y agoIt's not "miserable" if the lesson scripts are designed for it. In fact, the challenge of gradually memorizing "the lesson" until you know it word for word can be playful and engaging.
- post-it 4y agoA man crawls on his hands and knees in the middle of the street, searching for something. A driver pulls over and asks him what he's looking for. "My contact lens, I dropped it on the sidewalk." "Then why are you searching for it out in the street?" "The light is better out here." --- Likewise, sure, your way may be successful in getting children to memorize text. But that's worthless.
- zozbot234 4y agoThe college students who are using Anki to cram incredibly complex material in the form of text would surely disagree with your assessment that memorizing text is "worthless".
- TchoBeer 4y agoAre tests which gauge a college students ability to regurgitate text verbatim useful? Are these college students getting what we think is worthwhile learning out of these cramming sessions?
- post-it 4y agoMemorizing text is extremely useful for acing exams that test your ability to memorize text.
- hgsgm 4y agoThat's why schools should not waste time in lecture. Students should read/listen/watch and at home and bring questions to school
- ramraj07 4y agoI’d think you can get away with 5:1, a single good teacher can give a ton of individual attention to 5 kids studying completely different things on their own.
- flask_manager 4y agoHN tends to filter for people who are more academically inclined; people for who mastering a topic is a goal, and believe that education systems should support that. Taking a wider view, this is not really something that society wants in a widespread system; mandatory education systems do two things: They provide a minimum skill level; and they filter people into groups based on whether or not they can pass some bar. Better outcomes for more spending only really becomes a topic where the minimum bar is not being met. Education systems/techniques set up for effectiveness first do exist, but typically in spaces where there is a need for an individual to obtain a specific skill (military education, employer training in high demand and skill areas, private tutoring).
- zozbot234 4y ago> Better outcomes for more spending only really becomes a topic where the minimum bar is not being met. Usually we just get calls for more spending, without the better outcomes. It's all about throwing good money after bad, into a failing system that's already among the most expensive in the world.