4 ms·
The wage-price spiral theory of inflation is bunk. Inflation is caused by the devaluation of excessive printing of money.
by WalterBright 4y ago
The wage-price spiral theory of inflation is bunk. Inflation is caused by the devaluation of excessive printing of money.
- Nursie 4y agoNope. That’s well known bunk from alt-economics. Convenient to Austrians and Libertarians who get to blame the government (again), but wrong. Money supply is only one factor in a complex system.
- brutusborn 4y agoMaybe it’s not the only factor but surely it’s the major factor right now? Sure, we had a supply shock, but then we printed the most currency in history and got soaring inflation.
- notahacker 4y agoWe also "printed the most currency in history" in years we didn't get soaring inflation...
- brutusborn 4y agoWhich years were those? I couldn’t find an equivalent graph for Aus, but this graph suggests there is some fairly strong correlation. https://www.longtermtrends.net/m2-money-supply-vs-inflation/ https://www.longtermtrends.net/m2-money-supply-vs-inflation/
- notahacker 4y agoThat's a graph of growth, so every year it's above zero there's "the most money in history"! That graph is actually a neat indication that the correlation isn't particularly strong for two variables with an established causal relationship, and that inflation (high by recent standards; normal for most of the 20th century) actually kicked in properly as the money supply started to fall, at the time we were subjected to a supply shock. Australia's money supply curve represents a much smoother upward trend compared with the US, but their recent inflation spike mirrors that of the US
- Nursie 4y agoNope, doesn’t seem that way, the world is reeling from a variety of economic shocks right now, from covid to the Ukraine war and resource-prices fallout. “Printed the most money in history” is also one of those talking points that hides a massively complicated truth and doesn’t mean what people think it means. Soundbite economics (really soundbite anything) should be considered harmful.
- brutusborn 4y agoWhat does it actually mean?
- refurb 4y agoCalling expansion of the monetary supply and the resulting inflation "bunk" is hilarious. There are so many examples of inflation driven by monetary policy (Germany in the 1930's, Argentina, Venezuela, Vietnam) that denying the impact of money supply is just burying your head in the sand.
- bmer 4y agoAs far as I can see, the post in question isn't saying <expansion of monetary supply -> inflation> is bunk, they're saying <wage-price spiral -> inflation is bunk> bunk?
- Nursie 4y agoWho’s denying the impact? The post I replied to said it was the only reason, which is a load of bull. I explicitly said it’s a factor in a complex system.
- refurb 4y agoThe wage-price spiral is a mechanism for inflation. But the cause of inflation in the first place is the monetary expansion. You can't have a wage-price spiral without excess money to drive the higher prices and wages. It's the difference between the source of the fire (fuel + ignition source) versus the propagation of the fire (combination of oxygen + fuel).
- Nursie 4y agoYeah nah, there’s that alt economics we were talking about. There are multiple causes, money supply is only one of the factors at play. Using your fire example, there are three factors, miss any one of them, no fire. Choosing then to blame a single factor is … well it’s just wrong. And that’s if we grant your fire analogy as valid in the first place. Regardless of the above - conflating monetary supply inflation with general inflation is a favourite meme among the Austrians, they aren’t the same thing. Austrian economics (usually beloved of libertarians) is an idealogical, rather than descriptive, school of thought.
- pmontra 4y agoCentral banks have been printing money for years (quantitative easing, "whatever it takes" , etc) and there was no inflation.
- Manuel_D 4y agoBut the money supply was kept roughly in line with the growth of the economy. Inflation only occurs if the total money supply grows faster than the economy. There's some nuance over how much money is actively being spent vs sitting in savings, but the broad strokes of it is economic output divided by money supply.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoOnly because money velocity fell off a cliff, money velocity is one of the multipliers that goes into the apparent quantity of money as the same dollar is used more often. Given the asset bubbles due the printing people are incentivized to invest into it so long as the bubble continues to grow (or at least not shrink) people are incentivized to keep holding. So you can keep printing money without seeing inflation so long as asset bubbles can soak it up and money velocity drops. Now when the reverse happens, which will happen eventually even if it takes a very long time, that is when you get inflation. So paradoxically increasing the base money supply enough to generate asset bubbles has a deflationary effect.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoThe 'excess' money was soaked up into asset bubbles not measured by most inflation indexes, or at least under weighted. Which is fine until people sell those assets and spend the money which they have to do eventually.
- rightbyte 4y agoTrickle down economy you know. Of all these house millionaires you need to sell your house and move somewhere cheaper to actually benefit. It takes time until enough people cashes out to move the needle.
- refurb 4y ago
- vkou 4y agoEvery time your local bank issues a loan, it creates money out of thin air.
- geoduck14 4y agoThe banks are only allowed to loan a certain amount. The department that prints mone6 is the same department that regulates how much can be lent by all banks (in the US), so it is the same type of "creating money" as printing money is. And is accounted for when calculating "how much money is in circulation"
- cjbgkagh 4y agoIt's called a reserve requirement ratio (RRR), the bank must hold a certain percentage of loans as cash. It's mostly a closed loop due to rehypothecation so money supply is proportional to RRR. It keeps getting cut and it's one of those expansionary policies you tend not to hear much about. It's been a long time since I paid attention to it but I think there was talk of using cash equivalents instead of just cash at which point given the fraudulent incompetence of rating agencies you might as well not have a RRR.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoAustralia hasn’t had a reserve requirement since the late 80s. They’re largely been phased out globally in favour of capital requirements and open-market operations.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoHuh, indeed. I found this on the RBA website. "The Reserve Bank’s reserve requirements are not a Required Reserve Ratio (they are not set as a percent of the financial institution’s liabilities). The Reserve Bank’s reserve requirements are set annually as an AUD amount per financial institution with the aim of ensuring that each institution has sufficient funds to settle AUD transactions after business hours. The amount is set taking into account the historical pattern of each institution’s AUD transactions." Is there any information on what those figures are because it's kind of important when calculating money supply? If not the RBA could 'print' large amounts of money and not tell anyone.
- andrekandre 4y ago> The wage-price spiral theory of inflation is bunk. Inflation is caused by the devaluation of excessive printing of money. is that the only possible cause?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> is that the only possible cause? No, its is a definitional axiom of certain “economic” religious sects, like the Austrian school. In a sense, since prices are a product of a number of factors including money supply, you can always construct a hypothetical alternative monetary policy which would prevent inflation, so any inflation can dogmatically be constructed to be a consequence of too-loose monetary policy.
- WalterBright 4y agoReligion? You'll have to do better than that. Meanwhile, what's your take on the historical fact that gold rushes (when money was backed by gold) resulted in inflation? What's your take on the fact that the US had net zero inflation from 1800 to 1914, and endemic inflation ever since (except for a brief period during the Depression)? And why are oil price hikes always blamed for inflation, but when oil prices fall there's no deflation? Let's face it. Inflation is the result of the Fed policy of "spend all you want - we'll just print more!"
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Religion? You’ll have to do better than that. The Austrian school is expressly, overtly, an unashamedly ideologically normative rather than empirically descriptive, which is why they are the example I cited. > Meanwhile, what’s your take on the historical fact that gold rushes (when money was backed by gold) resulted in inflation? That money supply changes can cause inflation is not the same as all inflation being the fault of money supply changes. > What’s your take on the fact that the US had net zero inflation from 1800 to 1914, and endemic inflation ever since (except for a brief period during the Depression)? Well, that its false, there have been brief deflationary periods far more recently than the Great Depression (the most notable recent one, though not actually the most recent, being during the Great Recession.) > And why are oil price hikes always blamed for inflation, but when oil prices fall there’s no deflation? Oil price falls can lead to deflation (IIRC, that was the main cause of the brief, slight 2015 deflation). > Let’s face it. Inflation is the result of the Fed policy of “spend all you want - we’ll just print more!” A baseline bias to low inflation is a deliberate policy goal of the Fed (and basically every central bank, its not something unique about the Fed); that doesn’t mean every instance of actual inflation is accurately solely attributable to monetary policy as the cause. There are some inflation spikes that are due to factors like exogenous supply issues, there are others that are due to monetary policy miscalibration. The latter are more easily resolved, as demonstrated by the intense–but brief–post-COVID-recession inflation spike. (Which was, while there were other factors which contributed to it, largely caused by the failure to sufficiently-quickly dial back monetary stimulus in the rebound from the brief-but-sharp COVID recession.)