8 ms·
Excess weight, obesity more deadly than previously believed
- exfatloss 4y agoPreviously believed by whom? Pretty sure we've been aware that obesity is a huge problem for a generation now. I mean we literally talk about an obesity epidemic. Next, science is going to find out that water is wet.
- saurik 4y agoThe "science" has been saying for a long time now that there's might even be a health benefit from being a bit overweight, and that --as this article carefully explained (which means I guess you didn't read it)-- there is a "U-shaped" distribution of outcomes; in contrast, this study claims all that prior work is wrong, and that there is a "straight upward line".
- dkarl 4y agoThe U-shaped distribution of outcomes has been discussed for many, many years, and I've never seen it mentioned without the caveat that most doctors and scientists suspect that it's a misleading statistic attributable to serious illnesses that cause weight loss. This definitely isn't the first study to support that interpretation, either. In other words, the longstanding conventional wisdom (at least as presented in the media) is exactly what this study set out to vindicate, not the opposite, like the press release claims. It's possible that this study is a significant step up in quality from existing ones, and it's possible that their method of considering past BMI is new and interesting, but the framing of it as the first to challenge conventional wisdom is pure marketing hype.
- exfatloss 4y agoThis. The U (or typically J as I've heard it described) shape comes mostly from the fact that very many very unhealthy people lose a ton of weight and end up with a super low BMI.
- sundvor 4y agoSprinkled with a coating of "body positivity" perhaps? I use quotes, because I personally only believe in body positivity for matters that are beyond control - eg disfigurements related to genetics or trauma. No-one should shame anyone - or feel shame - for things they have no say on. Matters within scope of control should be addressed, however. At the very least not lied about and promoted as healthy, more importantly.
- exfatloss 4y agoYea. I think a lot of it is cope/helplessness. Clearly "we" as a society don't know how to stay lean or get lean, and it's not fun constantly being reminded of something that you feel you have no control over. Or being told that it's unhealthy.
- netrus 4y agoThe point is not that its deadly, but more deadly then previously thought (as indicated by the title).
- Someone1234 4y ago> Previously believed by whom? The previous data/methodology. The whole point of the study was to look at three untracked externalities[0] in BMI-outcome research. They used historical NHANES data combined 2015 data on mortality data. > (1) confounding bias from heterogeneity in body shape; (2) positive survival bias in high-BMI samples due to recent weight gain; and (3) negative survival bias in low-BMI samples due to recent weight loss. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00324728.2023.2168035?journalCode=rpst20 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00324728.2023.21...
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agohttps://asdah.org/health-at-every-size-haes-approach/ https://asdah.org/health-at-every-size-haes-approach/ - and similar efforts have sprouted like wildfire these last several years in the name of inclusivity. Claiming or hinting that obesity is bad for one's health is considered highly gauche in polite company.
- vanilla_nut 4y agoI don't believe this myself, but I do know a lot of people who believe being overweight is unfairly demonized and not as harmful as TPTB would have us believe. Many point to BMI as an inaccurate gauge of healthiness (there's a fair point there about eating disorders and ethnic predispositions towards higher BMIs) and unhealthy obsessions with thinness (as opposed to fitness). Look up "Fat Acceptance" if you'd like to know more. Personally, I don't think we should view fatness as a moral failing; some people do naturally tend towards higher weights, especially as they get older. But I also feel that fatness is really dangerous and unhealthy and the "Fat Acceptance" movement makes me a bit uncomfortable because, much like smoking cigarettes, some people need a bit of a push to kick bad habits like overeating. Obesity is very expensive, both in money and lives, so if we can reduce it, we should.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> I do know a lot of people who believe being overweight is unfairly demonized Because it is. As you yourself allude to later... > I don't think we should view fatness as a moral failing It clearly is not. I suspect the only people who believe that are the folks 'born on third base' as it were. > some people need a bit of a push to kick bad habits like overeating Some people? The vast majority of people are overweight. Anyone who isn't fit & trim has no business commenting on anyone else's bad habits and moral failings. None. Got a little bit of a spare tire? Shush. Got some love handles? Shush. Skinny fat? Shush again! > if we can reduce it, we should 100% agree. Edit: Downvote all you want, guys, most of you pushing that downvote button need to lose weight just as much as I do.
- tekla 4y ago> Because it is. As you yourself allude to later... No its not. Its nowhere near demonized as it should be. > It clearly is not. I suspect the only people who believe that are the folks 'born on third base' as it were. It's a failure of self control. > Some people? The vast majority of people are overweight. Anyone who isn't fit & trim has no business commenting on anyone else's bad habits and moral failings. None. Got a little bit of a spare tire? Shush. Got some love handles? Shush. Skinny fat? Shush again! Untrue. The vast majority of people in rich countries are overweight.
- gnicholas 4y ago> Masters pointed out that a lifetime carrying excess weight can lead to illnesses that, paradoxically, lead to rapid weight loss. If BMI data is captured during this time, it can skew study results. “I would argue that we have been artificially inflating the mortality risk in the low-BMI category by including those who had been high BMI and had just lost weight recently,” he said. It's like the teetotaling bias — a chunk of people who teetotal do so because they have an illness that makes drinking very unwise (or would conflict with medication).
- cscurmudgeon 4y agoReminds of the parachute study that was shared here recently: https://healthjournalism.org/blog/2019/02/breakthrough-research-reveals-parachutes-dont-prevent-death-when-jumping-from-a-plane/ https://healthjournalism.org/blog/2019/02/breakthrough-resea...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HPsquared 4y agoI love the meta irony of this article, taking the (somewhat satirical) journal article and playing along as an example of overblown science journalism with the headline "Breakthrough research reveals parachutes don’t prevent death when jumping from a plane". It's beautiful....
- exfatloss 4y agoDid they even use a control group?! And was it double blinded?
- sundvor 4y ago“We think that everyone might benefit if the most radical protagonists of evidence-based medicine organized and participated in a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled, crossover trial of the parachute.” I'm still crying. :)
- 4y ago
- ehPReth 4y agoMan, food is so addictive and not like you can just stop eating it like you can quit drinking booze or quit smoking!
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoWhat's unique about food is that unlike smoking, drugs or booze, a human will always have to go back to eating, it's essential for day-to-day life unlike Jameson, Marlboro and meth. If you have a healthy relationship with food then you're fine, otherwise every day you're faced with willpower checks that you might struggle to consistently pass.
- exfatloss 4y agoI don't think willpower has anything to do with it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ManuelKiessling 4y agoHow come that you think this?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoOzempic and Wegovy. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/31/opinion/ozempic-weight-loss-drugs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/31/opinion/ozempic-weight-lo... https://archive.is/rnTGB https://archive.is/rnTGB https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2023/01/30/1152039799/ozempic-wegovy-weight-loss-drugs https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2023/01/30/1152039...
- exfatloss 4y agoI wouldn't try these until they've been studied further: https://peterattiamd.com/the-downside-of-glp-1-receptor-agonists/ https://peterattiamd.com/the-downside-of-glp-1-receptor-agon...
- newaccount2021 4y ago[dead]
- WalterBright 4y ago> Excess weight or obesity boosts risk of death by anywhere from 22% to 91% A strange statistic, as the actual risk of death is 100% for all of us.
- paulpauper 4y agoI am guessing they mean premature death.
- inglor_cz 4y agoCould this be meant as "risk of death at certain age"?
- exfatloss 4y agoObviously that's what they mean. It's just funny :)
- qup 4y agoSo far.
- tshaddox 4y agoStrange in the same way it's strange that people might say that playing Russian roulette increases risk of death by an easily-calculable amount.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago"I intend to live forever, or die trying." - Groucho Marx
- exfatloss 4y agoWhat if you eat a lot of vegetables though
- cassianoleal 4y agoWould that make you immortal? If not, still 100%.
- thriftwy 4y agoThere was an article[1] about two gene mutations which cause (a) lose fat, lose muscle, and (b) lose fat, gain muscule. If you could build a selector between these three modes (normal human, (a), (b)), you could solve HALF OF HUMANITY PROBLEMS. For real. That's not a joke. I see a lot of people around whose lifes are crippled by the fact they're not in the body mass which would be most productive/healthy for them. People are losing a decade of life and another decade of productivity due to this. A lot of interpersonal problems are also due to this, more than you can imagine. Half of world's perceived social injustice go away once you fix BMI. We do not even realize the amount of self-humiliation humanity suffers by not being able to control something so fundamental. Disclaimer: My own body weight is normal, though I would perhaps accept additional muscle; but it pains me seeing people who suffer from this every day, people who are better than me in most other respects. 1. https://davidepstein.substack.com/p/the-diy-scientist-and-the-olympian https://davidepstein.substack.com/p/the-diy-scientist-and-th...
- Someone1234 4y agoThis seems useful. However, some people, both inside and outside medicine, believe that negative consequences' education can be a solution to the overweight/obesity issue, even though after 40 years we've seen near no positive correlation. We've seen some positive outcomes from interventions (e.g. mental health treatments, actionable plans, etc.) but the funding/resources for those continue to be scarce. So the trend keeps falling back to education in the professional setting or bullying in the social one as a "solution" because it is free, ignoring the lack of efficacy. I actually think our "personal moral failing" thinking is a large impediment to actionable solutions for society, because instead of looking at WHY even 18-year-olds have gone from below 20 BMI in 1879 to over 26 BMI in 2022[0] we just go around and around in circles about how it is a personal responsibility issue not a systemic one, while the data continues to show that it is across all of society. We continue to subsidize sugar substitutes (corn turned into HFCS) at the production side but sugar taxes to offset the subsidies are seen as "attacks on freedom." The US's overproduction of HFCS has even lowered the international price of sugar indirectly. Because sugar is so cheap, and so addicting, in our capitalist system the manufacturer willing to exchange other ingredients (e.g. fats, proteins, etc) for sugars may be both cheaper AND taste better, even if ultimately it isn't satiating. So we have a bunch of foods which are high in sugar relative to historical norms or that simply never existed because they exist to act as a "sugar delivery system" (e.g. soda). After the UK introduced a soda tax (SDIL), we can see that due to both manufacturers reformulating their drinks AND changes in consumer behavior it resulted in lower calorie intakes that they did NOT make up by buying alternative sources of sugar (e.g., candy)[1] [0] https://www.calciumhealth.com/the-american-obesity-epidemic-how-did-we-get-here/ https://www.calciumhealth.com/the-american-obesity-epidemic-... [1] https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/article/explainer/sugar-tax https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/article/explainer/...
- exfatloss 4y ago> I actually think our "personal moral failing" thinking is a large impediment to actionable solutions for society 100%. We have no clue how to fix it, so we "do something" to feel in control as a society.
- JamesBarney 4y ago
- uptownfunk 4y agoFor those struggling, controlling your diet is the single most effective thing you can do to make progress on obesity. Much easier to say no to a 300 cal donut than to run 30 minutes. Cutting out the daily donut for two weeks is about a pound of fat. Maybe we need a “just say no” to junk food campaign like we had in the 90s. Lean meat, tofu, tempeh, seitan, veggies, low calorie sauces, limited fruits, protein smoothies (watching the sugar/fat) Do a few pushups, a light run, increase slowly. Make it sustainable, not a flash crash.
- taeric 4y agoTrue, but don't feel like you have to run for 30 minutes. Walking for that long will go a long way for a lot of folks. Really, walking should probably be looked at far more closely for many folks.
- WillPostForFood 4y agoWalking for 30 minutes will go a long way to promote general health, but it's not a lot of calories burned.
- exfatloss 4y agoIn my experiments wearing a glucose monitor, even 5 minutes of walking has a massive effect on blood sugar. Might not make you slim, but might prevent your diabetes if you're borderline. I counted the steps. Under 600 steps. Not even around the block, and a ~20mg/dL reduction in blood glucose.
- Fricken 4y agoOn a day to day basis it usually isn't a lot of excess calories eaten either, but over a year or 10 those small discrepencies can add up.
- taeric 4y agoThis is an area where calories is scary misleading. The 30 minutes walking is indeed low in the direct impact. For some reason, it punches well above expectations, though. Probably something about base metabolism and such, but whatever it is, you will lose more weight from walking than you'd expect. Similarly, people probably walk way way less than you would expect. It is kind of scary to see how few steps I can get on a standard day.
- smm11 4y agoI believe 80 percent of all health issues faced by US citizens are caused by or at least exacerbated by dietary choices. I also believe that cutting carb intake to 30-35g daily would be a night/day change for national health.
- exfatloss 4y agoPlus probably PUFAs
- nostromo123 4y ago[flagged]
- outside1234 4y agoStill beautiful, but will die...
- rdl 4y agoMaking GLP-1 agonists and related drugs (ozempic, mounjaro) cheaply/widely available seems like it would be excellent public policy.
- exfatloss 4y agoIt seems that they also make you lose tons of lean mass. Normal diets you lose 25% of the lost weight in lean, these seem more like 40%. https://peterattiamd.com/the-downside-of-glp-1-receptor-agonists/ https://peterattiamd.com/the-downside-of-glp-1-receptor-agon...
- aantix 4y ago“Lean mass loss was 2.6% versus 10.9%. Those on tirzepatide had about a threefold greater reduction in fat mass than lean mass, resulting in an overall improvement in body composition. Fat mass as a proportion of overall body mass decreased from 46.8% to 44.7% with placebo, compared with 46.2% to 38.5% with tirzepatide. Similarly, lean mass as a proportion of body mass increased from 50.7% to 52.4% with placebo, compared with 51.0% to 58.1% with tirzepatide. Fat-to-lean mass ratio improved more with tirzepatide than placebo, with greater improvements observed in patients who lost more body weight.” https://www.practiceupdate.com/content/easd-2022-substantial-weight-reduction-with-tirzepatide-produces-multiple-beneficial-metabolic-effects/142614#:~:text=Those%20on%20tirzepatide%20had%20about,%25%20to%2038.5%25%20with%20tirzepatide https://www.practiceupdate.com/content/easd-2022-substantial....
- exfatloss 4y agoYea, their overall composition still improved of course, because they lost more than 50% in fat. But they lost more lean mass than people who lose that weight in other ways, is my understanding.
- JamesBarney 4y agoIn an apples to apples study it showed similar effects to canagliflozin which works through an entirely different pathway. So it's probably not related to GLP-1 but to the speed and effectiveness of weightloss which will most likely be faster than a typical diet. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31897524/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31897524/
- paulpauper 4y agoThe health effects of obesity are well advertised yet people continue to eat a lot. You see it on social media: people dining out with friends at restaurants with large plates of food, huge Superbowl parties, etc. evidently these people are not concerned. There are three ways of looking at this: these people are obvious to the risk, do not care, or the risks of obesity or being overweight are overblown. If the NYTs cares about stopping obesity, they should get rid of their food section, as food is the main contributor to obesity.
- exfatloss 4y agoYou're getting the causation reversed. These people are overeating because they're obese, not the other way around.
- josephcsible 4y agoDoes lung cancer make people start smoking too?
- exfatloss 4y agoProbably not, but also not sure how that's related?
- britch 4y agoThis is a joke, right? Indulging in a Superbowl party or birthday dinner will not make you obese. Overeating or eating poorly over a long period of time will. Cooking can be a great way to have healthy tasty food affordably
- rtev 4y agoIt’s very weird that out of 95 comments in this thread (at the time of writing), practically half of them are one person.
- hirvi74 4y agoThe topic of obesity somewhat reminds me of a joke I once heard from a stand-up comedian whom I cannot remember the name of, but it went something along the lines of, "People always ask you why you quit drinking, but you know... People never ask you why you drank in the first place." I do not believe that there is a significant portion of the human population that wakes up each day and decides to actively diminish their long-term health by overeating sheerly because he or she lacks the willpower/motivation to improve themselves. I feel that the minor, medium, and major stressors in life are what subconsciously steer one down this path. It's not like people who abuse substances[1] are completely oblivious or ignorant to the negative consequences of the substance. I think most people understand living an active lifestyle and eating a healthy diet is beneficial, but it's just not plausible for many. Be it time, money, or energy -- I do not think the average person has enough of all three at the end of any given day. Educating people on how to better take care of themselves is not enough. Obesity is a symptom not a disease in my eyes. I am starting to believe onus of responsibility is less on the individual than we might think for when many of the rats in this rat race are dropping like flies, then perhaps the issue the with the race and not the rats? [1] I consider food, especially junk food, to be a substance which can be abused.
- uptownfunk 4y agoThis seems to try and give people a way out which is the exact opposite of what is needed to deal with this. There has to be a commitment and a no-way-out approach. It quite literally can be life or death. If individuals are not responsible for their own health then who is? How hard is it to eat chicken/tofu + veggies for one meal a day and cut out pizza/pasta/rice/wheat?
- hirvi74 4y ago> If individuals are not responsible for their own health then who is? I view the issue much like burnout. Who's fault is it for burnout? The employee or the employer? To be honest, just like obesity, it's probably a bit of both (not claiming employers are causing obesity). > How hard is it to eat chicken/tofu + veggies for one meal a day and cut out pizza/pasta/rice/wheat? It depends on how much one earns. It's a lot easier for someone making a HS salary than minimum wage which in my state, is still $7.25/hr. I am not saying individuals are not responsible, but I do not agree that individuals are solely responsible. There are other factors at play. I think we have a societal issue -- people are overworked and overstressed on average. Hell, depending on the source of information, around 20%-25% of Americans are prescribed psychiatric medication. That signals we are facing systemic issue within our society. Why are people so depressed, anxious, and or flying off the rails? Another issue is that our society has become more sedentary as a whole -- especially in the work place. I imagine there were much less sitting/standing at a desk all day in 1923 than there is in 2023 on average. I think a lot of people were able to fulfill their minimum exercise needs without much effort -- be it factory work, more walkable cities, etc.. Is the increase in sedentary jobs, lack of walkable cities, etc.. an individual's fault or society's? Maybe I am just talking out of my ass, but I would like to see any kind of research, if it even exists, on if there is a correlation between hours worked in a sedentary job and obesity.
- tomcam 4y ago> Masters pointed out that a lifetime carrying excess weight can lead to illnesses that, paradoxically, lead to rapid weight loss. Well I mastered the first part