3 ms·
This was your original thesis: > Microsoft for example could have spent unlimited money on IE and the justice department wouldn’t have cared as long as it was
by scarface_74 4y ago
This was your original thesis:
> Microsoft for example could have spent unlimited money on IE and the justice department wouldn’t have cared as long as it was treated as a business investment. However, leveraging the ability to change windows was seen as problematic.
There is no confusion. Nothing came out of the DOJ case with respect to MS bundling IE.
Intel has never had a monopoly when it came to x86. IBM insisted from day one that were two suppliers for x86 before it even agreed to use the first chip.
- Retric 4y agoI said “leveraging the ability to change windows” which is not limited to bundling. Making it more difficult to install competitors is “leveraging the ability to change windows.” They very much lost in large part because of a video shown in court of how difficult to install a competitor. They even lied about it by editing their own video which skipped steps showing they knew that behavior was problematic. As to Intel’s x86 monopoly. Intel paid 1.6 billion in response to a monopoly lawsuit, and the EU fined them $1.45 billion and ordered it to end its customer rebate program. So they where definitely treated like a monopoly.
- scarface_74 4y agoDid you ever install Navigator back in the day? It was not difficult to install another browser.
- Retric 4y agoYes. It wasn’t always difficult, but at various points there were extra hoops you needed to jump through. Again I will point out Microsoft editing a video to skip steps they clearly wouldn’t have done so if the process was reasonable. They have even swapped peoples browsers with security updates before. Though more recent examples like KB 3135173 seem like a simple mistake, it’s more provocative when such things were common.
- scarface_74 4y agoThere were never any extra hoops. You downloaded Netscape and you clicked on install like you did any other application.
- Retric 4y agoNot only is this false it was demonstrated as false in court. “Microsoft later submitted a second inaccurate videotape into evidence. The issue was how easy or difficult it was for America Online users to download and install Netscape Navigator onto a Windows PC. Microsoft's videotape showed the process as being quick and easy, resulting in the Netscape icon appearing on the user's desktop. The government produced its own videotape of the same process, revealing that Microsoft's videotape had conveniently removed a long and complex part of the procedure and that the Netscape icon was not placed on the desktop, requiring a user to search for it. Brad Chase, a Microsoft vice president, verified the government's tape and conceded that Microsoft's own tape was falsified.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor.... Also I had forgotten about this bit: “Later, Allchin re-ran the demonstration and provided a new videotape, but in so doing Microsoft dropped the claim that Windows is slowed down when IE is removed.”
- barneygale 4y agoWhy are you continuing to argue when you clearly don't understand antitrust?
- scarface_74 4y agoWell, in that case neither does the justice department for the last three decades since none of them have agreed with HN lawyers theories...
- saurik 4y agoYou seem to keep ignoring, though, that Microsoft lost :/. Like: Microsoft was charged, the case was heard, and Microsoft lost. The judge even ruled that Microsoft be broke into two companies! So, no: you are just wasting everyone's time here by insisting something that is 100% absolutely incorrect. https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/management/microsoft-antitrust-case/ https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/management/m... FWIW, the reason you might be a bit confused--though I do not think this excuses the time you're spending here--is that Microsoft did not end up broken into two because they appealed that part of the ruling and "won"... but that court of appeals actually re-affirmed that Microsoft's actions were illegal! https://www.computerworld.com/article/2582620/appeals-court-reverses-microsoft-breakup-order.amp.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2582620/appeals-court-... > The appeals court, in its decision, specifically rejected Jackson's order that Microsoft be split. "We vacate the judgment on remedies, because the trial judge engaged in impermissible ex parte contacts by holding secret interviews with members of the media and made numerous offensive comments about Microsoft officials in public statements outside of the courtroom, giving rise to an appearance of partiality," the decision said in part. This is essentially akin to someone being convicted of something and then appealing the decision to an appeals court that decides "OK, the defendant clearly is guilty, but the chain of evidence used by the district attorney was compromised and so none of it is admissible; thereby, you cannot send them to jail, even though we know they are guilty". (edit: Also, there were, in fact, serious ramifications on Microsoft for this loss... Bill Gates largely had to step down as CEO due to having gotten the courts so mad at Microsoft that it was almost broken apart, the IE team had a difficult time hiring anyone due to the shame and Internet Explorer ended up on life support <- this is often blamed in Microsoft "not caring as they were a monopoly" but that is far from the truth, and the resulting chaos for Microsoft really allowed Apple an entrance with Steve Jobs back at the helm to retake a large market segment. I did a talk about The Fall of the Roman Empire that covered some of these issues, but more detail on IE is likely a nonsequitur.) https://vimeo.com/310654342 https://vimeo.com/310654342
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Nothing came out of the DOJ case with respect to MS bundling IE. In the sense that there was ultimately a comparative slap on the wrist remedy, in part because of a favorable-to-Microsoft change in administration between the findings of fact on antitrust violation (in which bundling IE was a factor, but far from the sole factor) and the imposition of a remedy for those violations, yes, nothing much came out of it.
- scarface_74 4y agoThe original poster was originally focused on bundling. If DOJ had said Bill Gates kicked a dog while dressing up as clippy it would have meant nothing since there was no proposed remedy or anything that came out of the consent decree that BG had to stop cosplaying as Clippy and kicking dogs.
- Retric 4y agoNo, I didn’t mention bundling you did. Also, U.S. vs Microsoft wasn’t limited to Netscape vs IE several other companies were involved. The first Prohibited Conduct was in terms of OEMs: “ A. Microsoft shall not retaliate against an OEM by altering Microsoft's commercial relations with that OEM, or by withholding newly introduced forms of non-monetary Consideration (including but not limited to new versions of existing forms of non-monetary Consideration) from that OEM, because it is known to Microsoft that the OEM is or is contemplating:” … “B. Microsoft's provision of Windows Operating System Products to Covered OEMs shall be pursuant to uniform license agreements with uniform terms and conditions. Without limiting the foregoing, Microsoft shall charge each Covered OEM the applicable royalty for Windows Operating System Products as set forth on a schedule, to be established by Microsoft and published on a web site accessible to the Plaintiffs and all Covered OEMs, that provides for uniform royalties for Windows Operating System Products, except that:” Etc https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2001/11/28/01-29498/united-states-v-microsoft-corporation-revised-proposed-final-judgment-and-competitive-impact https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2001/11/28/01-2949...
- scarface74 4y ago