3 ms·
It will be interesting to see how the courts interpret the various DMCA requirements and whether or not they're able to clarify matters. For example, just what
by Natsu 15y ago
It will be interesting to see how the courts interpret the various DMCA requirements and whether or not they're able to clarify matters. For example, just what part of the DMCA requires them to deal with repeat infringers? There are allegations concerning that, but many of the allegations do not cite what law they think is being broken. I seem to recall that it has been considered by Congress, so is it really the court's place to decide those rules in their place? They sure don't mind deferring to Congress everywhere else, so I would tend to say no. But who knows just what they might read into the "red flag" requirement?
Honestly, that's probably the biggest thing to watch. If they come up with some particular rule, a lot of people will have to scramble to implement something. And it will be even worse if they just say that people need one without giving any guidance.
I hope to see remarks from grellas on this one.
EDIT: Note that they do mention the repeat infringers bit the "conspiracy" section of the indictment, but that doesn't really make things very clear. I note that they also claim a link to ninjavideo (whose owner was taken down for criminal infringement) at the very start, then leave it out when talking about the "conspiracy." Weird.