4 ms·
I'm getting down voted to oblivion for this... Even in the year 2012, after all these years, Americans still need to hear stories that directly outline why com
by grecy 15y ago
I'm getting down voted to oblivion for this...
Even in the year 2012, after all these years, Americans still need to hear stories that directly outline why communism doesn't work, and good old competitive capitalism is the way of the future.
I wonder how many of you reading this in America even stopped to think about the message you're being fed.
I wonder how many of you reading this in America have absolutely no clue the rest of the developed world does not feed this kind of thing to it's citizens.
Stay clear of those evil commies...
- coryl 15y agoWhat? So you think this is nothing more than propaganda?
- tnuc 15y agoPretty much everything written by one country's media about another country is propaganda. There is just as much propaganda in American media as there is in Chinese Media. Does Rupert Murdoch support SOPA or is it the fine informed editors at the Wall Street Journal? Rupert wouldn't use his media as a propaganda network for his own benefit would he? There is no propaganda in American Media, none at all. It's only the evil commies that have propaganda.
- pyre 15y ago> Pretty much everything written by one country's media > about another country is propaganda. You say this, yet you only attack American media for propaganda. Would you say the same thing about a BBC article on Iraq? A French article on Spain?
- tnuc 15y agoIn general, yes I would say the same thing. I am certain a German article on the economic situation in Greece is going to be quite different to an article in a Greek newspaper. My intent wasn't to attack Americans or American media so much as to outline an example as to how Rupert Murdoch (and others) uses the media for his own gain. This is by no means limited to the US. He has a multinational media network. People like Kim Jong-un also write propaganda but are limited by the reach of their media network. My apologies if I offended any anyone, this was certainly not my intent.
- reuven 15y agoI'm not sure how you can say this with a straight face, given the incredible diversity of opinion in the American media. Sure, the US government engages in propaganda. But if you're only listening to the what the government says, or to one take on it, then you're purposely restricting the depth and breadth of opinions that exist.
- ryannielsen 15y agoYou'd be down voted to oblivion because you make baseless statements without any factual backing. Are we really being fed a message in this article? Perhaps. The message I got from this article? Straight communism doesn't work. (Which is fairly well established from past "communist" governments – they're either not communist or they quickly transmute into some other form of government.) But this article also doesn't espouse the benefits of pure capitalism. Instead, it highlights how a mix of communism and capitalism – a mix of group and personal interests – was actually quite successful. Individuals have incentives to help the group, because after helping the group they help themselves. That's definitely not pure capitalism. Nor is it pure communism. It's something much more rich and powerful. I think that's something from which we all could derive a very powerful message: absolute black/white polarizations are rarely correct or beneficial. Instead what's often required is a blending of opinions and ideas.
- xiaoma 15y ago>Even in the year 2012, after all these years, Americans still need to hear stories that directly outline why communism doesn't work, and good old competitive capitalism is the way of the future. Making sweeping generalizations about Americans contributes nothing good to this discussion. It's needlessly incendiary, and it's more likely to lead to an argument than an interesting discussion. Please have a look at the first, third and final sections of the HN commenting guidelines. http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- maxvu 15y agoWoah woah woah. You have a downvote button?
- pizza 15y agoThe threshold is 500 karma.
- reuven 15y agoI have been listening to Planet Money since it first started, several years ago. While the quality and freshness has dropped off somewhat in the last year or so, it remains a great source of insight and reporting into economics. I don't think that the reporters on this piece were trying to give us any sort of message, other than that China realized that communism -- that is, government ownership and regulation of production, and equal pay no matter how hard you work -- was a failure, and that they had to somehow escape from that system and move toward a more capitalistic one. How that happened is an interesting story, and an important one. If you think that Planet Money is against communism and in favor of capitalism, then that's probably a safe assumption. But if you think that they're all rah-rah-USA! in their opinions, then you need to listen to the podcast more regularly. They've done some excellent shows on Denmark (and particularly, now Danes are generally OK with taxes that are beyond the pale for all but the most extreme Americans) and education (and how the US isn't attacking that problem, particularly at the preschool level, an intelligent way). Oh, and their reporting on the American banking system, and the ways in which the US housing crisis occurred, were very well done. It's something of a cliche to say that reporters tend to be left-of-center, but I definitely get the feeling that this is where the Planet Money is located on the political-economic spectrum. But they're also generally trying to explore topics in greater depth than you'll get elsewhere, and from angles that I definitely don't hear in other places. For that, and for their clear explanations (and willingness to be silly and funny), I give them a huge amount of credit.