5 ms·
The monopoly practice in this case is subsidizing a business with by leveraging a monopoly. Aka YouTube isn’t paying market prices on unused compute therefore
by Retric 4y ago
The monopoly practice in this case is subsidizing a business with by leveraging a monopoly. Aka YouTube isn’t paying market prices on unused compute therefore Google is leverage its search monopoly to expand into another business.
Historically the concern was that railroads might get into say coal mining by charging competitors more to move coal than they charged themselves.
- scarface_74 4y agoIn that case are you saying it should be illegal for any company to leverage its resources to get into a new business? Should Netflix not been allowed to leverage profits it was making in shipping DVDs to enter streaming?
- Retric 4y agoNo, it’s not a question of money but of resources. If Google offers up their compute at market rates and YouTube is treated as any other customer on that compute then it’s not a problem. Microsoft for example could have spent unlimited money on IE and the justice department wouldn’t have cared as long as it was treated as a business investment. However, leveraging the ability to change windows was seen as problematic. Long term subsidies can also run into issues, but it’s believed YouTube is inherently profitable.
- scarface_74 4y agoActually, you're kind of making my point. Absolutely nothing came of the DOJ case with regards to IE bundling. But that still isn't logical. Are you really going to say that a company shouldn't be allowed to use resources to create a new product? Should it have been illegal for Netflix to use profits from shipping DVDs to later bundle video streaming? Should it also be illegal for companies to "subsidize" open source contributors? Should it be illegal for YC and other VCs to "subsidize" money losing startups based on previous successes? How long should a company be allowed to spend money on money losing products to gain a foothold? Microsoft probably lost money on the first 2 generations of the Xbox. Should that be illegal? Should Microsoft not be allowed to throw billions at ChatGPT?
- Retric 4y agoMicrosoft lost. They avoided being broken up, but it’s absolutely clear they had broken the law. It’s not IE bundling alone that was at issue but Microsoft making it harder to install competitors and limiting access to some API’s to IE. They where legally required to change this and did in fact do so. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp.#Settlement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor... And the critical thing you don’t seem to understand is resources aren’t the same thing as money. Suppose Intel decided to change their CPU design so only their compiler would have access to the full instruction set, that’s not something money can buy. Anyone can bring lots of money to the table, only the monopoly can leverage the resources associated with that monopoly. As to spending money, again it’s not about gaining a foothold because anyone can spend money. The issue is if someone is subsidizing a business to maintain their monopoly rather than operate a profitable business. Google didn’t get into fiber because they wanted to operate a profitable business they got into fiber to defend their websites. They didn’t cross the line, but you can see how long term subsidies of different business could be seen as desirable/problematic.
- scarface_74 4y agoMicrosoft did not in fact have to change anything about bundling the browser with Windows. And just in case you haven't noticed, Intel isn't exactly doing great against AMD these days and doesn't even have a monopoly on chips with the x86 instruction set. Do you think its also illegal for the cable companies that originally lost money on cable infrastructure and to subsidize the cable infrastructure to sell subscription content? DirecTV probably wouldn't have made money selling satellite internet. But it was able to do it cheaply because of its content delivery. Every company leverages its resources to have margins of scale. Even HN can only exist as a free service because it leverages the resources it has from the rest of its business. No one pays dang to moderate HN. The moderation is subsidized.
- Retric 4y agoI will say it again Microsoft broke the law and lost. The case was more complicated than a simple sound bite which is why you’re confused. People get away with breaking the law constantly, you can do 57 mph in a 55 every day for 60 years and never get a ticket. Shipping Windows with a copy of IE was like doing 57, nominally illegal but not something they would have gotten in much trouble over. But like a speeder they pushed even further and got slapped down over it. Intel has had an X86 monopoly at various points. Doing something when they aren’t a monopoly can be legal when doing the exact same thing as a monopoly is illegal. Whether they currently qualify as a monopoly is debatable, but you don’t need a 100% market share to be considered a monopoly. AMD having a 20% market share is right at the edge of where Intel would be considered a monopoly but Intel has a great deal of market power.
- giantrobot 4y ago> Aka YouTube isn’t paying market prices on unused compute therefore Google is leverage its search monopoly to expand into another business. What in the hell is "market rate" for compute? Google bought a zillion CPUs and hard drives and put them in data centers that they pay for. There's no "market rate", they own the infrastructure. They can do whatever they want with the equipment they own. A division using another division's spare compute capacity isn't in any way an anti-trust violation. What you're saying makes no sense at all.
- Retric 4y agoGoogle cloud exists... Anyway, monopolies have specific legal restrictions on what they can do with their infrastructure be that railroads, cables, or data centers. “Amazon EC2 Spot Instances let you take advantage of unused EC2 capacity in the AWS cloud. Spot Instances are available at up to a 90% discount compared to On-Demand prices.” https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/spot/ https://aws.amazon.com/ec2/spot/ As a monopoly Google could sell the same capacity YouTube is using on Google cloud services and YouTube could then buy that capacity. If YouTube was treated as any other customer it’s fine, if YouTube got preferential treatment it’s not fine. I doubt anyone is going to take them to court over this but it is likely illegal.
- giantrobot 4y agoSo companies can't leverage their own infrastructures between divisions? They should have to offer every bit of their infrastructure at "market rates"? What's the market rate for me shipping boxes using Walmart's trucks? Should McDonalds be forced to charge "market rate" rent to Subway for counter and kitchen space?
- Retric 4y agoMonopolies not random companies. Also, what’s legal isn’t particularly relevant only what’s enforced as nobody actually cares as about what infrastructure YouTube is using.
- danielrhodes 4y ago