3 ms·
The root flaw in Marxism is the labour theory of value. It just doesn't lead to a workable theory of economics. That wasn't clear at the time he wrote Das Kapit
by jacques_chester 15y ago
The root flaw in Marxism is the labour theory of value. It just doesn't lead to a workable theory of economics. That wasn't clear at the time he wrote Das Kapital, because the leading summation of economics was Smith (which I believe Marx worked from), and Smith got it wrong also.
The concept of repeated crises of capitalism leading inexorably to socialism relies entirely on a slender reed that turns out to be broken.
Nevertheless, whether socialism is, regardless of inevitability, possible, is a matter of hot debate. Mostly down to which side of the calculability/use-of-knowledge debate you fall on.
Red Plenty is an interesting book for the days when it seemed as though the Soviet Union really was going to usher in heaven on earth. As for China, Mao: The Unknown Story is a terrifying account.
- sliverstorm 15y agowhether socialism is, regardless of inevitability, possible, is a matter of hot debate. I figure the only way to make it possible is through the ability to pick & choose members, and exile members. Not to be elitist, but rather to protect the community from those who would abuse it.
- derleth 15y ago> I figure the only way to make it possible is through the ability to pick & choose members, and exile members. Then you have a dictatorial state socialism, also known as Stalinism, Maoism, and the Khmer Rouge. It's been done.
- tomjen3 15y agoNot necessarily -- he may have a defense against the inevitable slide into corruptness that happened in those places. Of course this all depends on who gets to choose to exile members, and getting it to scale.