3 ms·
I can't agree. Ultimately, the article argues for spinoff because of 1) focus, 2) more subscription experimentation, and 3) regulators. But there's zero evide
by crazygringo 4y ago
I can't agree.
Ultimately, the article argues for spinoff because of 1) focus, 2) more subscription experimentation, and 3) regulators.
But there's zero evidence YouTube is a distraction, it's already done lots of experimenation with subscriptions, and YouTube seems like the last of regulators' concerns with Alphabet.
I do think it's true there isn't a whole lot of strategic synergy between YouTube and Google or the rest of Alphabet. It's not like YouTube and Maps reinforce each other the way Docs and Slides do.
But the biggest argument for keeping them together is that there are large economies of scale, mainly regarding datacenters and edge nodes and all of the like, and that for this reason alone YouTube is an essentially perfect part of Alphabet's portfolio.
- alldayeveryday 4y ago[dead]
- conductr 4y agoThe synergy is that google has active advertisers with payment information on file. They can cross sell ads on any vertical to that customer list. A new company would struggle just to get advertisers to sign up and struggle to get the content and struggle to get the views. This is why google bought YouTube to begin with, it’s a vertical for advertising which is their business.
- H8crilA 4y agoThat's on the revenue front and is indeed important. On the product front: some search and generally data processing technologies are similar or even identical in Search an YouTube (YT Search, but definitely not only that).
- conductr 4y agoYes, I’m sure that’s so but not quite sure of how that implies anticompetitiveness. If a YT competitor built a search feature that they thought was so good they spun up a search engine product, does that make them anticompetitive? Every competitor has to implement their own solutions to these problems. Or, don’t? Search isn’t a barrier to entry. You could launch a video service without a search feature. If you can leverage something from your existing assets, that’s not anticompetitive. It’s like a lawn mowing service starting a Christmas light hanging service because they already possess the truck and most of the tools and labor resources. It’s the definition of being competitive. They may be able to offer lower prices to consumers because they get to use their assets during middle of winter when grass isn’t growing. Or, and this is key to the bundled conglomerate argument, offer a service that wouldn’t otherwise be feasible (because the cost would be higher than what customers would pay.) In this case, bundling of the service is a net positive to consumers.
- CydeWeys 4y agoThe two companies would likely have more total value separate than together. The stock market doesn't price conglomerates correctly.
- crazygringo 4y agoCitation needed. When companies are split, sometimes they gain value and sometimes they lose it. There's no hard and fast rule, and I'm not aware of evidence of systematic downwards mispricing of conglomerates.
- Barrin92 4y ago>When companies are split, sometimes they gain value and sometimes they lose it Evidence suggests that spinoffs produce quite significant gains in shareholder value, here is one such study[1]. This isn't really that surprising as large conglomerates are slow, have managerial issues and are difficult to price and generally hold their best performers down. [1]https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1875857 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1875857
- mijamo 4y agoIt is the https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conglomerate_discount https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conglomerate_discount It is not mispricing, but it is a discount. Big companies, even very healthy ones, often split to satisfy their investors based on this phenomenon. It hasn't really played much in tech though which might be why you haven't heard of it, but is very very well known in industrial companies.
- lumb63 4y agoNot saying I disagree with you, but couldn’t the “economies of scale” argument be used to justify e.g. all cloud providers forming a monopoly, all hardware manufacturers doing the same, etc.? The only reason all tech companies shouldn’t aspire to monopoly status is to avoid regulators stepping in; they should aim as close as possible.
- notatoad 4y agothe main reason that all cloud providers don't form a monopoly is because they can't afford it. if google could buy microsoft or vice versa they totally would. of course they want the monopoly, but that doesn't mean they can have it.
- luckydata 4y agothis is very wrong. You can coordinate a campaign where you have video ads on youtube for let's say a new burger from McDonalds and then the same ads in Maps. Youtube is brand awareness, Maps is to bring customers to physical locations. There's TONS of synergy.
- hackernewds 4y agoYouTube Premium is a large part of Google One. Which also includes Google Photos, Google Fi, Google Drive etc benefits.