4 ms·
His model of human nature and projections for capitalistic growth were also totally off. Correct. The model of human nature proposed by Karl Marx was demonstra
by tokenadult 15y ago
His model of human nature and projections for capitalistic growth were also totally off.
Correct. The model of human nature proposed by Karl Marx was demonstrably incorrect, and the demonstration continues in the few countries that continue to proclaim allegiance to Marxist thought.
An interesting fact about free-enterprise (Marx might say, "capitalist") economies is that they are based in part on the writings of Adam Smith in the book On the Wealth of Nations. But before Smith wrote The Wealth of Nations, he first wrote a book called The Theory of Moral Sentiments, pondering what motivates human beings to behave morally. Smith had deeper insight into human nature even before he began writing about economics proper than Marx ever had.
- forensic 15y agoThey aren't in competition. They both were geniuses. Smith did not advocate laissez-faire capitalism. He was against any kind of cartel, oligopoly, or monopoly, and wanted the state to be more powerful than corporations, not controlled by corporations. Marx was right about capitalism but wrong about incentives. Both of them should be drawn from in the creation of a next generation economic system.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nextparadigms 15y agoHow do you get a state that is "more powerful" than Corporations? I don't think Government size has anything to do with it. Are you referring to having many strong law enforcement agencies to threaten the corporations? I'd say the US Government already has that, and Corporations still seem to control it. And if you want to give China as an example, that's not an acceptable model. In a democracy, the best way for the Government to be more powerful than Corporations, is for the people themselves to have more direct power over the Government. The more the people loosen up their grip on the Government, the more one of the 2 things happen: 1. The Government becomes more powerful than both the people and the Corporations. 2. The Corporations become more powerful than the Government, who in turn is also more powerful than the people.
- Fargren 15y agoThe problem is the feedback loop: the people who work at the government want money, and the big corporations make a lot of money. My opinion is that we should device a system in which money is meaningless to people who make decisions about enterprise. What should matter to them is how their decisions affect the people. Obviously, I have no idea how to do this.
- weekendlogic 15y ago1. Democracy allows people to control the government. 2. Corporations are people. (In the US) 3. Corporations are the richest, most powerful, psychopathic people. It is not hard to see the problem here.
- spindritf 15y ago> 2. Corporations are people. (In the US) I could never understand that point. Corporations are people everywhere. Corporation is just a group of people (shareholders/owners and management/employees) with a contractual hierarchy owning some property (equity). Same way NGOs are people, HOAs are people, football teams are people... And it's like that everywhere in the world, it's a very basic property of human societies. That's why corporate donations traditionally include donations from "members" of the corporation as donation from the corporation BTW. Now, in civilized countries, individuals within these groups are given some legal protection from responsibility for the group's actions. There are certain advantages to that approach (more innovation, risk taking, investment, etc) but most importantly collective responsibility is simply wrong.
- Tangaroa 15y agoThe idea of corporations being people goes back to Rome when someone decided that the laws regarding disputes between persons could be applied to an organization as well. Corpus == body, the body of people being treated as a person in considering the accusation. That said, governments have always been able to regulate what corporations can do until the Citizens United decision of 2010. Corporations used to be chartered by the government to meet a specific objective and were only allowed to spend money towards that objective; government regulatory policy was deny-by-default. Aaron Burr's Manhattan Company in 1799 was the first modern corporation in the US that was allowed to spend its money freely.
- vidarh 15y agoI'm curious as to what you think Marx' think human nature was like. I ask, because most people who make this argument make it out of an assumption that Marx argued for a system based on widespread altruism. But a central part of Marx' argumentation about the workers movement is that the working class needed to learn to understand the nature of class struggle, and reject bourgeois/capitalist morality, which is designed to support capitalist rule. E.g. the capitalist class supports strong private property rights because they have property and its in their interest to perpetuate it. In effect, he argues that the working classes are too selfless - they in fact today actively support a system that puts them at a disadvantage. If anything, he thought it would be easier to get people to pay more attention to their own self-interests than what they have been most places so far. Marxist socialism is what you get if the vast majority pay recognize that they will never be "the 1%" and decide to band together to gain collective advantage.