5 ms·
I’d like to know what the author or any of these commenters think the process would look like that would have actually stopped this advertiser. Some guy wants t
by jeffbee 4y ago
I’d like to know what the author or any of these commenters think the process would look like that would have actually stopped this advertiser. Some guy wants to advertise their Thai restaurant. They’ve got the domain name, the site is up, it works. What else is the ad marketplace supposed to check? It’s not like you can’t have the same name as another Thai restaurant. After all, the domain registrar gave them that name.
So what would it look like?
- mcculley 4y agoIf my paid ad for my restaurant is right above the organic search result, how is Google adding any value?
- jeffbee 4y agoHypothetically? You just recently moved your site to a new domain name (your reasons are your own) and you want to advertise the new one even though the old one is “organically” first. You want to control the snippet in a way that’s impossible with organic search. Among other hypothetical situations.
- mcculley 4y agoGoogle could notice the paid link goes to the same page as the organic link and choose not to charge the advertiser as they are obviously not adding or creating value. Instead, because Google chooses to charge for that first link, it creates a situation where the business owner knows they have to outbid the competition to get the link above their own. This is great for Google’s shareholders, bad for the restaurant.
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoIt would look a little bit like a company that's got a fuckton of relatively well curated data about the world and maybe combining that data with some kind of "artificial intelligence" to maybe produce something useful to society like a reduction in the number of scams it gives advertising space to. But maybe that's just me being shortsighted and valuing benevolence over revenue.
- jeffbee 4y agoIf you think it's so easy describe how it would work in this case, where a human already familiar with the business fell for the scam anyway.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoYou look for it. Because you know that it might be a possibility and you own the platform upon which the banner will be placed. The poor human just wanted some food, they didn't realise they were going to have to navigate scams when searching Google for a local, unique business name. Maybe the human is just a rube and they deserve all the trickery served up to them.
- burkaman 4y agoAmex: The phone number you've provided for your business account appears to be incorrect. Please correct the number and provide some evidence that you are the same person who registered your business with the state. Google: You've registered ads for hundreds of unrelated businesses. We've suspended your account for fraudulent automated activity, please provide evidence that you own or are acting on behalf of these entities.