4 ms·
Ask HN:Lawyers ...Is Windows 11 forced upgrade not illegal in your jurisdiction?
Always use Linux, but unfortunately have a few corporate applications that are only available for Windows. So have two laptops with Windows 10. This morning was greeted by the full screen volunteering these machines for a Microsoft upgrade to Win 11. Providing only two options: Do it now or Schedule for later. Incredibly dark pattern and had to use task manager to dismiss it. The only other option seems to be accept the upgrade then say no to the license conditions. A button then appears that will "allow" you to proceed to your previously purchased Windows 10...The window takes the whole screen, has no minimize buttons visible, and until I decided the way to say yes, and then refuse the license agreement, or play with the task manager, almost caused it to launch the install. I would be late for an online meeting. This must be unacceptable behavior in some kind of jurisdiction?
- KingLancelot 4y ago[dead]
- theGeatZhopa 4y agoNot a lawyer, but it's up to you and your system. There are ways to stop updates and also to stop that nagging. Google a bit, use wintweak ... And then, there are ways to set the update time and to postpone that. That dark pattern is as long you have internet. No internet, another Button "no" will appear. I'm always on Windows. The first things I do after a fresh install is to remove bloatware (with scripts, or Software debloater, switch off the the telemetry (google for winaero, or shut up windows), switch off the auto reboot (google for a way to stop win10 reboot after updates. The one where you have to replace REBOOT.AC and other files is the proper one) and creating a fresh profile without the bloatware, delete the first created Profile. Takes around 15mins of time. Have fun, M8!
- belter 4y agoI did run this debloater in these two machines from the beginning of their setup: https://github.com/Sycnex/Windows10Debloater https://github.com/Sycnex/Windows10Debloater These are paid and fully licensed versions of Windows 10, and yes, I am now aware of the registry hacks to try to delay this. Only run these two laptops, because are forced to use some apps that are only available for Win10. Otherwise would dumpster fire the whole Microsoft crap. What shocked me was the whole intrusiveness of window. A complete grab of the screen that makes you believe this is some kind of forced emergency upgrade. Under Windows Updates, you can choose the "Delay for Now". It was not there before, and must have been installed in one of false Microsoft Security Updates. The whole Microsoft thing stinks of lack of respect for the user, and misleading dishonest patterns and I had enough of it...Win 11 is not yet stable, and not all apps are compatible and had or my assistant upgraded it, could have causes serious compatibility issues. Somebody else messes with your systems with no warning, before an important meeting, either at my office or 2000 km away from Redmond, I am going to bitch about it...
- theGeatZhopa 4y agoYes, that's absolutely wrong doing from Microsoft's side. I think, we'll need to wait until some legislative process in the work being disrupted by Windows :) Other wise, that doing-like-that seems legit. Win10 is soon 10 and in that 10 years no lawyer have seen the possibility to get some compensation of MS. Even in the U.S. The next thing is that telemetry Microsoft uses. No one knows exactly what is being telemetered. MS don't disclose that. ... Guess, the aren't things like a free beer :) Feel with you on that topic. Greets from Germany Let's hope for some laws that forbid dark patterns.