4 ms·
One problem — nowadays politicians would be absolutely DDOS’d by duel challenges. We might bring back more explicit ideas of classes… but I mean, at least any
by bee_rider 4y ago
One problem — nowadays politicians would be absolutely DDOS’d by duel challenges.
We might bring back more explicit ideas of classes… but I mean, at least any congressperson would have to be able to challenge any other, right? So we’d have candidates successfully running on “I’ll duel <lightning rod congressperson of the day>.”
I mean, that, on top of all the other reasons the idea of dueling is ridiculous, hahaha.
- gostsamo 4y agoEvery rule that is worth breaking will be broken as fast as humanly possible. People will be killed outside of the dueling rules, will be challenged for stupid reasons, or their seconds will be bribed to cover the unfair duel circumstances. I'm doubtful that social deficiencies could be resolved with technical means. Instead of resolving the issue this will change how the issue is manifested.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- denton-scratch 4y ago> at least any congressperson would have to be able to challenge any other, right? Duelling was a matter for gentlemen; men of honour. If you have no honour to defend, duelling is inappropriate. A "gentleman" in England, at least, was a man with land, but no aristocratic title. Aristocrats often duelled, so I guess it's "gentlemen, and men of higher rank" that were thought honourable enough to duel with. Most politicians deserve only to be horsewhipped.
- calvinmorrison 4y agoNO GODS NO MASTERS and certainly no silly british titles
- mcv 4y agoI find it odd that violence, and not words or wit, was seen as the proper way for gentlemen and aristocrats to settle disputes. It's seen as barbaric now, and I think it's better this way.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt’s because they were barbaric, they just happen to have been rich in a time far back enough that we’ve forgotten some of the details.
- mywittyname 4y agoThe book calls out that "lesser men" could be horsewhipped if they committed an offense that would be considered an insult if spoken by a gentleman (implying that lesser men are not capable of actually insulting a gentleman). This not-so-subtly hints at the levels of abuse that average people suffered at the hands of privileged classes.
- denton-scratch 4y agoIt went further than just implying it; they said (paraphrasing, I haven't re-read it) that a gentleman should never take offence at an insult from a pleb. I think there's something in that; if an insult causes you offence, you are implicitly granting that your abuser's opinion deserves consideration. A true gentleman would rise above it - a man of rank need not concern himself with the views of plebs. Plebs always insult gentlemen; if you horsewhipped them every time, you'd need a new horsewhip every week.
- bee_rider 4y agoConveniently this also means that gentlemen don’t have to fight anyone who labors for a living.
- denton-scratch 4y agoWell, yeah. In most of historical warfare, noblemen fought noblemen, yeomen fought yeomen, and peasants fought peasants. When English yeoman archers fired on advancing French cavalry (noblemen) at Agincourt, it was considered awfully bad form. Swords were expensive things, you needed money to own one. And there were many laws restricting who was allowed to carry a sword and who wasn't.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]