3 ms·
I totally believe that the risk of this stuff is "less" than an uncontained lithium fire, but 500C is nothing to laugh at. There are significant risks to the pe
by ggm 4y ago
I totally believe that the risk of this stuff is "less" than an uncontained lithium fire, but 500C is nothing to laugh at. There are significant risks to the people around this, contact with water, water vapour, volatiles released from plastics.
I don't want to "but.." because lots of industrial processes are inherently dangerous, and we still do them. The thing is to design the systems to contain the risk. Thats cost, and may go to the same place as the containment costs for lithium systems. For the right engineering outcome in terms of operational cost and responsiveness, it's worth it. For energy density, it may be really good value.
They say that after initial heating, the process is inherently exothermic and so maintains it's own heat. Thats beneficial because it means external heat sources don't have to be continuously maintained.
Antimony is poisonous. Assuming normal operations don't volatalize this, or create dust and aerosols, the problem would be what happens if there is an uncontained fire, or some problem which causes it to be released in smoke or water. Again, not a problem unique to this technology, proposed energy storage with Ammonia is going to have to confront NH fume risks. (for instance)
These aren't things people will build out in their back yard. Things like flow batteries are much more deployable into rural and remote: maybe this technology is deployed in light industrial, heavy industry or at the electricity substation and plant.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoThe good news is that there's a really easy solution to 500C being dangerous near people: don't put it near people. You don't want one of these in your car or your basement, but you can just put a ton of them in a big gray building that isn't next to anything and it's pretty much completely safe.
- bhawks 4y ago> maybe this technology is deployed in light industrial, heavy industry or at the electricity substation and plant. With all the wonderful people shooting at electrical substation in populated areas maybe this isn't the best place? They aren't well secured and there is already enough risk there from the high voltage - not to mention the end user impact when they go off line.
- Doxin 4y agoWhile 500C is a lot when compared to the average process in a kitchen, on an industrial scale it's not really even all that impressive. Any steel mill deals with temperatures over twice as high. Never mind that a steel mill does a lot of moving around of steel in crucibles and such which is the main danger, which I don't reckon would be required for this process. The local trash incineration facility gets hot enough to melt copper, which is over twice as hot as this molten salt process. Heck, the inside of your average wood stove gets up to these temperatures. Painting 500C as some sort of very high temperature that's hard and dangerous to contain isn't quite fair, seeing as there are myriad industrial processes that are generally considered safe that run at much much higher temperatures.
- knewter 4y agoMy grill can hit 700 if I want to make a pizza. Handwringing over this is ridiculous