4 ms·
> He started the company, built it up to be a large, successful firm, and is the main reason why they now have so many long-term, institutional clients. Maybe.
by lmm 4y ago
> He started the company, built it up to be a large, successful firm, and is the main reason why they now have so many long-term, institutional clients.
Maybe. Or maybe hard-working employees are the main reason for that success, and the figurehead at the top was just in the right place at the right time.
> He could do that, or he could sell the firm, or take it public, or anything else that his voting shares legally allow him to do.
In most developed economies a company owner cannot arbitrarily destroy their employees' careers. You have a responsibility to the people who've devoted a substantial chunk of their lives to you.
> Selling the firm to the top employees, and offering them generous "seller financing" terms to do so over 10 years, actually seems like a good deal for them, and has the added benefit of clearly determining who actually believes in the company and its prospects over the long term.
If you can't see how it's inherently inappropriate for a superior to pressure a subordinate to take on a large personal debt to buy an asset of questionable value from that superior, with the implication that their continued employment depends on this, then I don't know what to tell you. What's next, expecting them to "volunteer" to work unpaid hours to prove their commitment to the company?
- theteapot 4y ago> In most developed economies a company owner cannot arbitrarily destroy their employees' careers. You have a responsibility to the people who've devoted a substantial chunk of their lives to you. Bahaha. Hilarious.
- jquery 4y agoHilarious how?
- oh_sigh 4y agoThose employees were silly for not just starting their own firm if they were the main cause of success.
- eigenvalue 4y agoAgain, these aren't poor downtrodden factory workers toiling away in the mines... these are unbelievably well compensated non-founders who have made far more than even the founders of most successful startups, all without taking true entrepreneurial risks. They are already rich beyond measure, and yet their greed is so extreme that they think they are entitled to extort the founder's shares at some knock-down price because of "reasons"-- to the point where they cry about it to the NYT in violation of their NDAs. Also, you are quite mistaken about the legal duty owed to employees in any capitalist society. You absolutely can wind down a firm, especially if you give sufficient notice in advance to employees (i.e., "we will shut down in 1.5 years from today").
- lmm 4y ago> Also, you are quite mistaken about the legal duty owed to employees in any capitalist society. You absolutely can wind down a firm, especially if you give sufficient notice in advance to employees (i.e., "we will shut down in 1.5 years from today"). Not necessarily. In Germany for example the employees are entitled to set up a works council (under certain conditions), and that council has a right to negotiate for the worker's interests if a restructuring is proposed, including on the point of whether it happens at all, and if they can't reach agreement with management then they're entitled to independent arbitration.
- refurb 4y agoSo you're saying in Germany the government can force a company to keep operating? That's doesn't sound like a good thing.
- lmm 4y agoThe US government also can and does "force a company to keep operating" in the case where e.g. there's a dispute between two groups of shareholders and/or creditors, one of whom wants to shut it down and the other doesn't. Bankruptcy courts do that all the time; for the court of chancery to do it is rarer but it happens. The difference is that Germany recognises that the workers are also legitimate stakeholders with an interest in the business' continued operation.
- dgs_sgd 4y agoTo say that Ray Dalio was just a figurehead who was in the right place at the right time is about as ridiculous as saying he should get 100% of the credit. I'm sure he had very hardworking employees and they were necessary for his success and the success of the company. But those employees had to be working on _something_. Deciding what that _something_ is (i.e. the company goal/strategy) and then coordinating the actions of hundreds of employees and motivating them towards that goal is what a leader/CEO does. Doing that successfully over many decades is not easy.
- chollida1 4y agoI mean, this is how most successful hedge funds get transferred and how most partnerships do as well. The next gen takes on loans, often provided by the company to buy out the founders or previous partners. There is nothing strange or in appropriate about that. > In most developed economies a company owner cannot arbitrarily destroy their employees' careers. You have a responsibility to the people who've devoted a substantial chunk of their lives to you. No ones career was destroyed unless you know something I don't. Can you cite what you are referring to here? Most of the people taking over are long term employees who have been making 7+ figures a year for 15+ years now. They aren't been taken advantage of, these are incredibly savvy people.
- lmm 4y ago> No ones career was destroyed unless you know something I don't. Can you cite what you are referring to here? My point is that even if he's the "owner" (actually not true, he just retains voting control through super-voting shares, which is a whole other rant) he wouldn't (under most developed economies' laws) generally have free rein to arbitrarily do what he wants with the company when that negatively affects the employees. He can probably retire and sell it to the highest bidder, that seems eminently reasonable, but he'd be unlikely to be allowed to arbitrarily downscale or wind up a business that was operating profitably. So the idea that he's somehow doing the employees a favour by keeping the business running at all is pretty lopsided.
- jquery 4y agoPrecisely. It’s very… ahem… American… to think that company owners can and should basically treat their employees like livestock. And also that the figurehead deserves thousands of times more compensation than anyone else, by virtue of them being there first. It’s all based on the myth of meritocracy.
- smabie 4y agoIn what world is Bridgewater an asset of "questionable value"?
- lmm 4y agoValuing a hedge fund is inherently difficult (past performance is no guide to future returns, after all); valuing one whose reputation is centered on one individual who's about to leave is even more so.
- cscurmudgeon 4y ago> Or maybe hard-working employees are the main reason for that success, and the figurehead at the top was just in the right place at the right time. Then why don't/didn't they start a company where they are more in control?