9 ms·
Because it's really hard and there tend to be absolutely right and wrong answers in the work. You can't skate through with a b.s., content free essay on the pl
by bane 15y ago
Because it's really hard and there tend to be absolutely right and wrong answers in the work.
You can't skate through with a b.s., content free essay on the plight of the modern farmer in a consumer world, shackled by the inadequacies of an archaic nation-state governing system or a 5-paragraph essay on the plight of the Hellenic world during the rise and fall of the Roman Empire -- getting A's only because it's properly formatted and has the right number of words, arranged roughly into the right number of paragraphs.
The "soft" subjects in college were easy. I could put off any assignment until the last night, then whip something up before class and guarantee an A.
My engineering classes on the other hand, were so hard, so time consuming, that I spent at least 6-8 hours outside of class for every hour I spent in class. A 12 credit semester might mean 80 hours outside of class writing code, reading books, trying desperately to grok complex data structured and mind-bending math. Write it wrong, and it crashes, or the answer is wrong, and you get an F.
- cparedes 15y agoI think the problem isn't inherently the class content (in 'soft' subjects), but how decent the professor is in letting students get by with weak arguments in their papers. I think there's some correlation between how much they actually care about the class, and how tough the class will end up being. I took an English class in college that was probably one of my toughest classes in college (yes, about as tough as my math classes) - the professor and the TA's tore apart each paper ruthlessly, and judged them at a quality slightly below academic papers. I wrote a paper that was well formatted and had decent grammar in it, but it was summarily torn apart and was given a C on the paper, because my arguments in the paper sucked. Also, I'd say that Philosophy is also a pretty damn tough subject in the 'soft subjects' of college. You're expected to be nearly as technical as a mathematician in your arguments, except you're writing essays/articles in prose, rather than with terse explanations and symbols. Philosophy took about as much time for me to study for as my math classes.
- jseliger 15y agoThe only word missing in your comment is "incentives:" in academia, professors, especially in soft subjects, don't have much of an incentive to grade accurately; they have an incentive to publish "research" that leads to jobs, tenure, and promotion. If you want professors on the whole to be better and more accurate graders, you have to give them incentives to do so. Which I discuss in more detail here: http://jseliger.com/2011/04/02/grade-inflation-what-grade-inflation/ http://jseliger.com/2011/04/02/grade-inflation-what-grade-in....
- arctangent 15y agoI'd agree that Philosophy is a tough subject. The reason I'd give for this is that in some sense philosophy does have correct answers, if and only if a question is framed within an existing philosophical model. The point of philosophy (as I see it) is trying to work out which philosophical model is most correct - a bit like a choosing between scientific theories. Instead of testing against measurable things in the real world, philosophers derive logical outcomes from propositions within linguistic/logical systems and compare them to detect inconsistencies. Therefore it's fine to ask a question about the consequences of a particular line of thought if a particular philosophical framework is specified, because you can mark a student not only on whether they arrived at an expected answer but also on the quality of their argument (i.e. how they got there).
- sliverstorm 15y agoWould it be wrong to call philosophy "abstract {math|logic}"?
- wtvanhest 15y agoIs it possible that soft subjects are easier not because they are soft, but because weak competition self selects in to those classes?
- bane 15y agoI have to agree w/r to Philosophy. But I've never considered Philosophy as a "soft" subject in the same way as a history class, English lit class, or some similar class. Philosophy is every bit as difficult as any advanced Math course I'm familiar with. You learn the rules and axioms of the philosophy, and work within it, and those rules can be as complicated as any other kind of complex logic. I'm specifically talking about what's considered an undergraduate degree in "English" or "History" or "English History" or some such. I had the fortunate happenstance to go through an undergraduate program that really wanted their engineers to be well rounded. Back in those days we were required to take 3 years of 2 classes a year of English Lit, 2 years of History (a year of Western Civ and a Year of some non-Wester civ), Speech, Communications, etc. for every Engineering Degree and a couple other "soft" courses. These classes were more annoying than hard. Once you figured out what the teacher was looking for (usually within 2 or 3 short essays), you could write all day on that subject and in that style and get A's. It was literally "programming" for the teacher. Good grades were programs that ran well, bad grades due to grammar or spelling issues were syntax errors, bad grades due to content were run-time.
- FreakLegion 15y agoYou're making two mistakes here. The first is that you're confusing the quality of your (from the sound of it, lower division) undergraduate English program with the quality of English as a discipline. The study of literature, in English or any other language, is, at its core, philosophical. The second is that no discipline, not even engineering, is immune to students coasting by doing the bare minimum. Criticizing English because you breezed through a couple of lower division surveys is like criticizing computer science because you breezed through a class on HTML.
- quanticle 15y agoThe difference is in the level of the bare minimum. Engineering and science have objective, right-or-wrong answers. At the end of the test, either you got the right answer, or you didn't. This imposes a certain minimum level of rigor that, in my experience, is wholly missing from the liberal arts. Yes, if taught well, the liberal arts can be as rigorous as mathematics. But teaching, say, English, well is whole lot harder than teaching mathematics well. There's just a lot more subtlety that has to be communicated. This means that in practice, there are proportionally fewer good Liberal Arts teachers than there are good math teachers. The quality and rigor of undergraduate liberal arts suffers as a result.
- shareme 15y agocome on..that was my senior English in high school 20 years ago..and yu call that hard?
- underreact 15y agoI'm working on a bachelors degree in cognitive science so I end up taking some classes related to math and programming, and some softer classes related to psychology. And I like to choose liberal arts subjects when I can for general ed, for the sake of being well-rounded. I find non-hard-science courses to be a little easier in general, but not much easier and not always. You sometimes get professors in a subject like art history who have very specific ideas about how an essay should be structured and what elements are legitimate topics of discussion. Being grammatically correct is often not good enough. There can be quite a bit of intellectual challenge in figuring out what type of essay will result in a good grade, and being able to do this sort of thing may translate into increased chances of success in terms of dealing with customers, coworkers, or managers. At this point I consider it easier to write a program than an essay. At least with a program there is a standard for the language, and a compiler for me to test the outcomes with before I turn it in. The absolute nature of discrete math can be a comfort, not a difficulty. I think some CS Engineers get a biased view of other subjects because they only take the introductory or elementary versions of other courses. Some English major may have to stretch his brain for many hours to decipher the meaning of something written hundreds of years ago, in a different dialect and with the context of a different time period; it would be wrong for him to dismiss electrical engineering just because he thought that applying the power rule in calculus 1 wasn't that hard. And philosophy majors get this type of "soft-major" criticism the most, but let us not forget that our computers are philosophy machines. Edit: I add this to note that cparedes made similar points as I typed this
- bane 15y ago"You sometimes get professors in a subject like art history who have very specific ideas about how an essay should be structured and what elements are legitimate topics of discussion. " As it turns out, this is exactly why I thought those subjects are not as challenging. Once you figure out how to program a teacher, the classes can lose their challenge.
- underreact 15y agoIt's interesting. I guess to me programming a computer seems more clear, because presumably whoever created the programming language did so with the intention that it should actually be useful for programming ( C++ jokes aside. ) But people can be complicated, inconsistent, and resistant to the idea that they can be won over with a simple formula. I suppose it just depends on the teacher.
- lrobb 15y agoDid you even read the article?
- rand_r 15y ago> Write it wrong, and it crashes, or the answer is wrong, and you get an F. As a former math/cs student, this seems a tad dramatic. A large portion of the marks on tests tended to be awarded to the process of how your worked out your solution, not just the final answer.
- eigenvector 15y agoIt's not about whether the work is harder or not. That will vary with each student's abilities. Many who could graduate engineering with honours would flunk out of an arts program, and vice versa. A small subset of well-rounded high achievers have the raw intelligence to succeed in nearly all fields. What differs drastically, and objectively, (and FYI, I'm an engineering grad) is the QUANTITY of work. I had a very enlightening conversation with the professor who taught my 2nd year differential equations course (who was a math, not engineering, professor, and also the chair of undergraduate studies for that department, meaning that he was responsible for pretty well all undergraduate curriculum matters) where he told me that the entire BSc in mathematics program was designed to contain no more than 15 lecture hours per week, and to require a capable student to spend approximately 20-30 hours per week in addition to that in home study to master the material. A course would be considered well taught and well balanced if capable students were getting As while putting in this level of work. He went on to say that the Faculty of Applied Science had forced him to add 3 hours per week (one additional 1hr lecture and 2hr lab/tutorial) to his ODEs course for engineering science majors even though the content was identical to course offered for math majors. This is because the Canadian Engineering Accreditation Board uses one and only one metric to determine a student's level of learning in a particular top - number of instructional hours. That is, if you teach people to solve y = y' for 6 hours a week for one semester (13 weeks), that is entirely equivalent to having taken ODEs for math majors (2 hrs / week), PDEs for math majors (2 hrs / week), and advanced PDEs for math majors (also 2 hrs / week). I was of course appalled by this and went on to discuss the topic with the Undergraduate Chairs of as many departments as I could - physics, chemistry, economics, philosophy, biology, and of course, my home department, engineering science. Without fail, the chairs of the non-engineering departments described a similar ideal schedule to what the math prof had said - and all of them emphasized that they felt students should have at least one day a week to devote to entirely extracurricular interests, while still having enough time to attend all scheduled lectures and tutorials, mastering the material and generally achieving 80% or better in all courses. In other words, you shouldn't need to be a slacker in order to have fun. What did the chair of my department tell me? "We expect students to spend 30-40 hours per week in class, in order to meet accreditation board requirements for instructional hours, and further, to spend about 30-40 additional hours per week to complete their assignments and master the material. Also, when I was an undergraduate I had it just as bad so STFU and get on with it." In sum, engineering educators have a fundamentally different view on what a full-time student's life should be like. And it is a view that necessarily compels a lower quality of life for the student.
- cafard 15y agoLet's say that the limits of charlantism are reached sooner in the STEM fields. To study the liberal arts properly involves a good deal of effort.