2 ms·
Giving the donation should not be the illegal bit... Accepting the donation should be the illegal bit... Which means I'm hoping to see 300 politicians headi
by londons_explore 4y ago
Giving the donation should not be the illegal bit...
Accepting the donation should be the illegal bit... Which means I'm hoping to see 300 politicians heading to jail any day now...?? Right??
- mock-possum 4y agoIt’s unethical to offer a bribe, it’s only unethical to accept a bribe if one actually follows through on the action the bribe is intended to encourage. Unfortunately, policing the second part is practically impossible, and the effect of successful bribes is too harmful to risk - so accepting a bribe must be condemned in the same breath as offering.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoAccepting a bribe without intent to follow through is dishonest and therefore unethical. Two wrongs don't make a right.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Giving the donation should not be the illegal bit… I disagree. Giving donations of with stolen corporate funds (listed as "loans" in documentation of the transfers, but with no supporting terms or accounting for the liability that should have been created with a loan, or anything beyond the notation on the transfer supporting that it was treated as a lona) should be illegal. Fraudulently misrepresenting the giver of donations should be illegal. Both of these were on the giving side. > Accepting the donation should be the illegal bit… Which means I’m hoping to see 300 politicians heading to jail any day now…?? From the accepting side, most of these looked like legitimate donations. that was the whole point of the fraud, to conceal where the money was really coming from, in both a personal sense (e.g., that it was being donated by SBF) and in a broader sense (that it was with stolen corporate funds.)
- khuey 4y agoHow, precisely, should a political candidate have determined that the donation was not compliant with the law?
- jfengel 4y agoIt's not easy for a politician to know that they're accepting an illegal donation. The law that was violated here was created specifically to prevent behavior that disguises illegal donations. When the money was given, one person knew that they were doing something that was forbidden, and the other did not. This looks just like any other donation, a check for a few thousand dollars, just like hundreds or thousands of other such checks that they'll receive in the process of getting elected. It's not as if this was handing over a bag with a million dollars in it in order to change a politician's mind. It was an attempt to get a politician elected who already agreed with them. Had the former been the case, it would indeed have been illegal. But this was not a suspicious amount of money or given with any kind of instruction on how to vote.
- idlewords 4y agoI know we all hate politicians, but think this through for half a minute. It is already illegal to knowingly accept donations from people you know are not allowed to make them (like foreign nationals). What you're advocating is a setup where if someone commits fraud, it sends someone else to jail.