5 ms·
After defending false data, Comcast admits another FCC broadband map mistake
- bastard_op 4y agoSounds like a perfect job for ChatGPT to verify every address against their website.
- jt2190 4y agoChatGPT is not the right tech for the job, but I don’t think you should be downvoted for suggesting that verifying the database entries is something that can be facilitated with as bit of tech.
- db48x 4y agoThere is one small problem with that. submitting a challenge requires agreeing to this statement: I hereby certify, under penalty of perjury, that: I have examined the information contained in this challenge and, to the best of my actual knowledge, information, and belief, all statements of fact contained in it are true and correct. If an individual, I own or reside at the location being challenged or am otherwise authorized to request broadband service there. I acknowledge that the information provided in this form will be shared with the provider selected above for the sole purpose of reviewing and resolving the challenge. If this form is being submitted by the representative of a company, organization, government, or other entity, then the certification must be signed by an authorized officer or signatory of the entity (e.g., corporate officer, managing partner, sole proprietor, or government official) who has reason to be aware of the truth and correctness of the information submitted herein. [] The entry of my name above constitutes my electronic signature to this certification. Persons making willful false statements in this form can be punished by fine or imprisonment under 18 U.S.C. § 1001. I’d like to see the news stories about them fining or imprisoning someone for correcting their database at an address where they don’t actually live, but I bet it discourages a lot of people from doing it.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoWhat is it in that quoted text that would discourage you from submitting a challenge?
- db48x 4y agoI didn’t say that it would deter me, only that it probably deters a lot of people, but this line in particular: If an individual, I own or reside at the location being challenged or am otherwise authorized to request broadband service there. Basically, they only want people to challenge the service where they actually live, not at every address in their neighborhood.
- justinclift 4y agoPersonally, I'm kind of surprised someone hasn't set up a website for people to submit their address for contesting bogus FCC data. Having a bunch of affected people working together gives extra power as a group, and potentially allows more ways forward legally (more clout, maybe class action, etc).
- uoaei 4y agoYou mean the website everyone on this thread is talking about? https://broadbandmap.fcc.gov/home https://broadbandmap.fcc.gov/home
- justinclift 4y agoNo, because the FCC doesn't appear to be in any way proactive. ;)
- uoaei 4y agoCan you read out loud for the class the title of TFA, Timmy?
- 4y ago
- barkerja 4y agoThere's a national (fiber) ISP that claims -- according to the FCC broadband map -- to provide 1000/1000 to my entire village. According to their own website, the closest address they service is about 25 miles away. I submitted an FCC challenge about 2 months ago, and just today received notice "provider subject to your challenge has conceded the challenge and is required to submit a correction for the challenged location in the online portal within 30 days". I am curious what benefit a provider receives from feeding this false information to the FCC? Is it funding (grants, etc.) related? It will also be interesting to see if the updated data will only reflect for my specific address, or if it will also apply to other areas around me that aren't serviced by the provider. If it's the former, I will be submitting more challenges.
- gurchik 4y ago> Correcting false data is important because the map will be used to determine which parts of the US are eligible for $42.45 billion in federal grants to expand broadband availability starting in mid-2023. > One of those investigations began after our report about an Ohio ISP called Jefferson County Cable, which admitted to lying to the FCC about the size of its network in an attempt to block funding to rivals.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- barkerja 4y agoThanks for that info! I live in a somewhat rural area (central NY) and my Town is in the process of rolling out its own municipal broadband. They are relying on grants to continue the rollout of service. I've brought this to their attention, a neighboring ISP has fed false data and it could potentially be harming their options for funding.
- aidenn0 4y agoIn that context, it's really hard not to see this as intentional. Be aware that only the challenged address must be fixed, so (after the 2 week update period) you might want to randomly sample some addresses in town to challenge as well.
- FireBeyond 4y agoAT&T is bad at this too. In fact, they lobbied to have a bunch of 1.5mbps DSL results removed from average speeds because "the technology is obsolete", and the FCC obliged. Now, to be clear, they are still SELLING said technology, and in many cases they present it to you as their only option, but y'know, since it's obsolete, we'll just not count it.
- causi 4y agoI only found out my dad was being scammed into paying them $35 a month for that 1.5mbit service when I was helping him troubleshoot why his Alexa kept losing connectivity.
- beauzero 4y agoI wish you could provide a "reverse" challenge. In Carroll County, GA Spectrum/Charter provide or are rolling out underground rural fiber. CarrollEMC/Crossbeam are rolling out "on the power pole" fiber in the same rural area. Neither show up on the map to the extent they are provided. It would significantly help my neighbors to know these are options.
- dzdt 4y agoIs it an option? Probably they are running the fiber but only for long haul and 5g wireless backhaul and wont actually sell you a connection to it.
- beauzero 4y agoIts available. Have been on 1G Spectrum for about 2 months now. Love it. They are competing with CarrollEMC/Crossbeam to get in first and sign up as many as possible before CarrollEMC is done with their rollout (which has a 6 year rollout plan).
- bsagdiyev 4y agoFYI with Spectrum fiber make sure you're getting 500mbit upload. I had to fight them to get that fixed since my address still showed up as copper and was provisioned as such (1000/30 or whatever it is)
- aidenn0 4y agoThis is pretty bad considering Comcast's website itself is a bit optimistic as to which addresses have service.
- chrismeller 4y agoI do find it odd that Ars never mentions anything about the website search tool not being 100% accurate. It’s not until a human looks at it that they can really confirm or deny availability.
- olliej 4y ago"mistake" - this is clearly intentional and deliberately fraudulently misrepresenting their coverage in federal documents. Once or twice is a mistake, but a consistent pattern of over claiming coverage in a way that cuts funding to support competition is clearly intentional.
- polygamous_bat 4y agoUnfortunately, if there's anything Americans fear more than losing basic rights to to pad corporate profits, it's "government overreach" in the form of holding such a corporations liable.
- coleca 4y agoIs there any decent tool to determine areas where symmetric broadband coverage in a given area is available? From what I can see on the FCC map it just using their "broadband" definition of 25down/3up which is akin to dial-up for most of the folks on HN.
- db48x 4y agoThere’s a little icon to the right of “Broadband” that you can click on to change the search criteria. It wasn’t obvious to me at first either.
- Zigurd 4y agoI'd bet operators of major conferencing software have a pretty good idea of how well ISP connections work nationwide. Aggregated (or even maybe not) they would paint a very accurate picture. Now we just need to get someone in government, who will probably become a lobbyist after, to care.
- db48x 4y agoA few years back Microsoft mentioned that something like 42% of all Windows computers have less than the 25Mbps broadband that the government is aiming for. Of course, not all computers run Windows, and even then it doesn’t tell you the difference between broadband availability and the desire or ability to pay for it.
- mistrial9 4y agoyes this is true -- it turns out that MSFT has easily measured the time it takes to download upgrades on a very large scale. This private data is mentioned in the Princeton study "No WANs Land: Mapping broadband connectivity"
- db48x 4y agoYes! I’m glad that they have at least gotten rid of their old map, based on census areas. That is progress at least.
- CyberDildonics 4y agoJust another very profitable mistake.
- DanielVZ 4y agoTelecommunications is one of the only things stopping me from wanting to migrate to the US. I live in a third world latinamerican country but we have one of the best internet service in the world (it was awful when I was growing up). The recipe? Regulation to avoid monopolies and market manipulation.
- DangitBobby 4y agoYou could always move somewhere with municipal fiber. Chattanooga Tennessee has arguably the best connectivity in the country!