6 ms·
U.S. on Track to Add $19T in New Debt over 10 Years
- Stevenjobss 4y ago[dead]
- dingusdew 4y ago[dead]
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoI wish I knew the truth on which camp is "right". You've got camp 1 saying "you can go to 300% Gross Federal Debt to GDP without side effects/it's a new paradigm that history can't guide us on/there are no downsides to printed funny money/everything is fine/there's no risk of the US defaulting/spending 7% of tax revenue a year on interest on the debt" and the other camp says it's going to lead to our demise, etc. Will we ever see a surplus or breakeven in the next 10-50 years? Why should/shouldn't we? Is it worth it to target a surplus? Obviously it must not be because we're nowhere near it.
- testTED 4y ago80% of currency printed very recently, plus effectively never existing in a surplus status, doesn't invoke huge confidence.
- gizmondo 4y agoI wonder how the first camp reconcile their views with the current struggle Italy has with their debt caused by excessive deficit spending in the past.
- mijamo 4y agoMostly by saying this is Italy's fault for being in the Eurozone and thus not being able to print its own money. Also the USA is in a unique situation in the world due to the status of the dollar, so comparison with other countries have very little validity. If argentina prints money it just loses value immediately and triggers crazy inflation. If the US prints money it is still not that big of a deal compared to all the dollars used everywhere in the world so the negative effects are much lower.
- TexanFeller 4y ago> Also the USA is in a unique situation in the world due to the status of the dollar I hope this remains true. I fear for the USD's status as the world's reserve currency due to our abusing it to print, our oil producing Arab allies starting to accept other currencies, our disconnecting Russia from our financial system motivating countries to try to be independent of us etc.
- yazzku 4y agoMust be sad for other countries to have an independent financial system, right?
- sashu123 4y agoThe simple answer is we are debasing our currency in a very complex way, that we cannot measure how much we debased it. In the past kings printed new coins to fund their wars or whatever and it was easier to track how much the currency lost value. In the present because economies have gotten complex + tools to debase have gotten complex we cannot estimate how much we have actually debased our currency by. If it’s 100% then there’s going to be a lot of inflationary pain, if it’s 10% we can probably handle it but I wouldn’t hold my breadth on getting any good estimate
- SQueeeeeL 4y ago>it was easier to track how much the currency lost value. I think this is a glamorization of the past. I'll bet most exchange throughout history was being done with some level of fraud baked into the system highly up the chain. Our modern fiscal institutions haven't even been cooking for 100 years and look at all the shit the weird sages in the crown city keep pulling with our green coinage.
- dsfyu404ed 4y ago>that we cannot measure how much we debased it. "it's a feature not a bug."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- arrosenberg 4y agoYou don't debase fiat currency, since there isn't a limited supply. Markets are distorted because of a poor distribution of money (too much where demand is low, too little where demand is high), because the Fed handed out money to the wealthy (who hoard it in the form of assets) and Congress refuses to tax it back and redistribute it to the working class who can't currently pay their rent.
- everforward 4y ago> You don't debase fiat currency, since there isn't a limited supply. That doesn't sound correct. There isn't a limited supply, but introducing more currency into circulation can reduce the value of it, which is a proper use of debasing. As a contrived example, if the treasury printed 100 trillion dollars and handed it out to everyone, I'm doubtful that bread would still be $1 a loaf.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoThere is no right, because a lot of people pull in all sorts of directions, which means there are simultaneously multiple perceptions of what is "right". It may not be apparent until you realize that 1) not everyone wants US to continue being a superpower 2) not everyone thinks expensive dollar is a good thing.. by which I mean, lots of people have different idea of what right actually is. And since I am looking at it all through a lens of an individual of US, to me it is clear that making US drown in debt is bad for USD price against, well, everything. For the longest time, US had been the place to park your cash due to stability alone ( and the fact that dollar was worth something ). That stability is currently not assured. That said, any analysis on the matter I heard was oddly optimistic ( and I will admit that I don't get the optimism ). Not sure if it is the lack of alternatives or something else, but it does not seem US treasury has problems selling bonds.
- paulpauper 4y agoIt is not as bad as the headline would suggest. The economy presumably is growing at the same time that the $19 trillion debt is being added. US GDP has grown a lot since 2012. Debt to GDP the highest since ww2, which seems bad, but the economy still boomed after ww2 anyway, so it's not saying much.
- yCombLinks 4y agoGrown on paper only. I don't think most people's lives are any better than 2012. Stock and house prices have skyrocketed is all.
- ALittleLight 4y agoMy intuition is that it's obviously right that borrowing money could be a neutral or positive thing - but that depends on the borrowed money being spent in ways that will have a positive return. If you borrow money, when borrowing is cheap, to buy a car so you can go to work, smart! If you borrow money to spend it on booze and concert tickets - not smart! I think the issue is that one side is saying "Borrowing is terrible!" And the other side is saying "No, borrowing cheap money is somewhere between fine and great!" And the real answer is "Borrowing can be smart if you use it well, but we are using it poorly." If the US was borrowing money to build and renovate roads, bridges, ports, update the electrical grid, build new nuclear power plants, engage in basic science research and similar projects likely to yield good return on investment - that was be amazing financial planning. My limited understanding of what the government actually spends its money on - wasteful healthcare, social security, the military, and intelligence agencies - is that the money is actually just being squandered.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoAs long as they can continue making interest payments on the debt then what's the problem? It's all relative.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhich the feds can always do since they can issue money. The relevant question is can the US continue producing goods and services that are desirable on a global scale, one of which is a trustworthy society where you can mostly depend on the judicial system keeping things in order, for better or for worse.
- Ekaros 4y agoAnd more importantly will others keep accepting USD. Or will they expect to be settled in something else be it other currency or some commodity. If others start to want something else than USD things can go sideways.
- scottiebarnes 4y agoThe problem is the fundamentals. The US will "never default on its debt" because it issues debt in its own currency, which it can control the creation of necessary to service that debt (money printer go brrrr). So nobody is ever concerned about debt; you just say screw it let someone else worry about it, usually future generations. The value has to come from somewhere, and in this case its from the debasement of the dollar.
- notch898a 4y agoThey defaulted when they stopped honoring gold backing, which was the debt against the legal tender.
- legitster 4y agoA budget surplus would be pretty irrelevant target in the grand scheme of things. There are foreign policy implications (other countries waiting for us to pay them back is a good thing). But also, just like corporate finance, if the government can get good rates on debt, it almost always makes sense to just take the money and make the payments. So some small and sustainable amount of budget deficit is probably a good thing. But we are clearly on the wrong side of that equation.
- jononomo 4y agoGo with the camp that doesn't immediately change their tune when a Republican is elected president.
- SilverBirch 4y agoThere's a lot of scary numbers, but here's a graph of the US budget deficit as a percentage of GDP[1] according to the CBO. Yes, the US has a deficit most years, and yes both the financial crisis and COVID lead to very large dficits. But between 1992 and 2000 a deficit of 4.5% became a surplus of 2.3%. So it's well within the possible to decrease the deficit by 7% of GDP over a relatively short period of time. If we started that process today we'd be back to the long term average deficit within 8 years - and we're starting from a crazy base because of all the hangovers of COVID. So whilst it's obviously a policy choice whether that happens, it's definitely well within the possible. [1]: https://www.cbo.gov/publication/58268 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/58268
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> If we started that process today But we're not, right? Not only are we not doing that, we're nowhere close to that? We're still on tracking to collect roughly the same in taxation (leaving loopholes open for corporations on purpose) and spending more than ever (growing every year).
- ashwagary 4y agoEven worse, $19T added to the debt is an extreme lowball by some expectations. Many estimates put the US national debt closer to $90T by the end of the decade. The country is right on the edge of walking into one of the most expensive wars in its history as well as a few delayed economic disasters that would kick the money printer into much higher gear. Trump adding $10T+ in a relatovely uneventful 4 years even before the massive inflation spike hit should give you an idea how quickly diminishing returns on QE can escalate spending.
- jbottoms 4y agoYou know who holds that debt? Consumers.
- credit_guy 4y agoNot really. It's savers. Which is by definition people who could consume more, but choose to postpone or forego some of this consumption.
- legitster 4y agoI encourage people interested in this topic to read up on the Fiscal Theory of the Price Level. I flippantly refer to it as "MMT without the magic". But it really did a good job of explaining our current situation. When you have a long-term fixed rate mortgage, only some of the value is paid off by principal payments. The rest is being paid off naturally by inflation. Imagine paying off a mortgage made in 2003 dollars with dollars you made in 2023. The payment is the same, but only a pittance of the same value. The theory goes that inflation is not completely a result of monetary policy - there is also a market adjustment of the dollar to the amount of government debt issued. To oversimplify, government debt will be paid back - if not through taxes, then through inflation. The implication is that MMT gets it partially right - worrying about debt to GDP is somewhat irrelevant. And if it can issue debt at less than the rate of inflation, the government can get free money! But we are clearly well past that point. The silver lining is that default is not really a risk here (maybe a political one) - inflation will cap out whenever the value of the money "catches up" with the debt level. (That said, if we continue to add to the debt, that means inflation will never stop).
- gitfan86 4y agoThis is what the bitcoin people got right. The dollar is going down A LOT. This is also what the bitcoin people got wrong. You don't want to to denominate your asset in dollars. Yes BTC will hit 100k some day. But 100k will only buy a crappy used car at that point.
- LikesPwsh 4y agoI wouldn't take those bitcoin forecasts too seriously. Some of them honestly believe that halving inflation doubles price no matter how many times you do it.
- ashwagary 4y ago>This is also what the bitcoin people got wrong. You don't want to to denominate your asset in dollars. Bitcoin people dont get that wrong, the "1 bitcoin = 1 bitcoin" meme is popular for that reason. Having said that, fiat has no bottom, so bitcoin has no top. It will continue to increase in fiat value for the rest of its existence as long as the network technicals stay sound.
- avalys 4y agoIn discussions like this, it's worth reviewing where total government spending in the US actually goes. This is actually not the easiest thing to pin down, but the best analysis I've seen is at https://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year2022_0.html https://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year2022_0.html. In summary: 17% to pension programs (e.g. social security) 23% to healthcare 19% to education 12% to defense 7% to welfare 3.6% to police/fire/prisons 4% to transportation infrastructure 14% to everything else (scientific research, the courts, the Department of Agriculture, etc.) The US budget deficit doesn't come from overspending in any particular area, and there is no single fix that is going to get us back to parity. A focus on efficient spending and reducing waste might help, but it would need to be applied systematically across the entire government. We are simply spending too much money everywhere, and getting too little value for the expenditure.
- sfe22 4y agoIsn’t this how empires fall?
- Axien 4y agoWhat is our defense relative to GDP?
- legitster 4y agoThis is a bit misleading though as it includes state spending as well. For the purpose of federal debt, we really only have three sources of spending that can move the needle: - Health Care 28% - Pensions 24% - Defense 20% Defense seems like an easy cut, but we are not currently in any major conflicts anyway. And our allies might not take to kindly if we start pulling bases from around the world. Pensions are entitlements and we can't really touch those. I think though that we are underrating the effectiveness of efficiency reforms around our healthcare system. For both private patients and taxpayers.
- manv1 4y agoWhat's interesting is that the US has been issuing a tremendous amount of debt, and the volume of that debt is a lot more than what should be possible under standard economic theories. Interest rate are still historically low, even after the inflationary bump. And there doesn't really seem to be crowding out; in fact, there's so much money floating around that it doesn't have enough places to go...which is presumably why the US debt is still finding buyers (the debt limit thing notwithstanding). If the US was under IMF supervision it would have been in violation decades ago. I don't follow this anymore, but does anyone know if there has been anything written about this bizarre financial era we live in, monetarily speaking?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> If the US was under IMF supervision it would have been in violation decades ago. IMF loans aren’t denominated in the recipients own currency, though.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 4y agoWhat's distressing to me about the debt situation is that Americans are willfully living in a total fantasy land about spending and taxes. The most recent pre-pandemic budget deficit was $1 trillion, while last year it was $1.4 trillion. Even the folks solidly on the left like Warren and AOC aren't talking about tax increases that would come close to closing that deficit. Their wealth and 70% top tax bracket proposals would raise less than $200 billion annually at the beginning. And of course, they want to combine that with $1 trillion+ in new spending. The issue is that Reagan dramatically lowered taxes on the middle class and upper middle class in the 1980s, and there's literally nobody in Congress willing to roll those back.
- shsbdncudx 4y agoWhat are the mechanics behind the US seemingly able to have infinite debt?
- x-complexity 4y ago> What are the mechanics behind the US seemingly able to have infinite debt? The root reason is due to the US government's control over its own currency. If you have your own currency, and if a lot of your debts are denominated in said currency, you can slowly make that debt less valuable over time with inflation. When debts almost always become less valuable relative to present value via inflation, there's less pressure to rein in on government spending than if your debts are denominated in another country's currency. This will eventually always happen even if a country decides to stick to a 1% annual inflation target. Within 100 years, said debt will be close to 37% of its current value: 1/(1.01**100) = 0.369711212 Even a 4% annual inflation target can cut that debt's Net Present Value (NPV) by to about the same level within a quarter of a century: 1/(1.04**25) = 0.375116802 The methods by which you can achieve this 1% inflation can be done in any number of ways, from quantitative easing, to regular old money printing, to government bond interest rate adjustments. Regardless of the methods used, inflation inherently makes any government debts held less valuable over time, making it easier for the government to eventually pay it off.