3 ms·
> I always like seeing Common Lisp links, but personally I was a bit put off by the very strong anti-commercial comments about LispWorks and Franz. What? I fo
by lelanthran 4y ago
> I always like seeing Common Lisp links, but personally I was a bit put off by the very strong anti-commercial comments about LispWorks and Franz.
What? I found it informative - clear and to the point about what frustrations you can expect with the licenses.
I mean, FCOL, he even made the effort to search google for the cost of the licenses because Franz hides them.
What exactly in the following texts do you describe as "strong anti-commercial comments"?
------------------------------------------------------
> Moving to proprietary implementations; Lispworks has been around for more than 30 years and the company producing it still release new versions on a regular basis.
> While Lispworks supports most features you would expect from a commercial product (native compiler, multithreading, FFI, GUI library, various graphical tools, a Prolog implementation…), it is hampered by its licensing system.
> The free “Personal Edition” limits the program size and the amount of time it can run, making it pretty much useless for anything but evaluation. The professional and enterprise licenses do not really make sense for anyone: you will have to buy separate licenses for every single platform at more than a thousand euros per license (with the enterprise version being 2-3 times more expensive). Of course you will have to buy a maintenance contract on a yearly basis… but it does not include technical support. It will have to be bought with “incident packs” costing thousands of euros; because yes, paying for a product and a maintenance contract does not mean they will fix bugs, and you will have to pay for each of them.
-----------------------------------
Releases are uncommon, the last one being almost 6 years ago. But Allegro is a mature implementation packed with features not easily replicated such as AllegroCache, AllegroServe, libraries for multiple protocols and data formats, analysis tools, a concurrent garbage collector and even an OpenGL interface.
Allegro suffers the same issue as Lispworks: the enterprise-style pricing system is incredibly frustrating. The website advertises a hefty $599 starting price (which at least includes technical support), but there is no mention of what it contains. Interested developpers will have to contact Franz Inc. to get other prices. A quick Google search will reveal rumours of enterprise versions priced above 8000 dollars. No comment.
- varjag 4y ago> It will have to be bought with “incident packs” costing thousands of euros; because yes, paying for a product and a maintenance contract does not mean they will fix bugs, and you will have to pay for each of them. This is something the author made up on the spot. They will most definitely fix the bugs regardless if you have support contract.
- galdor 4y agoI did not "make it up on the spot", I simply read their website: "Typically incidents are chargeable when they require work from us such as writing, compiling or testing patches, updating documentation, analysing or debugging your code, finding workarounds, providing technical advice or other significant effort. In particular, please note that we may regard fixes for bugs in its own Lisp products, and for shortcomings in the documentation, as chargeable." Source: http://www.lispworks.com/support/description.html#chargeable http://www.lispworks.com/support/description.html#chargeable Note how the list and following text clearly indicate that you can and will be charged for bugs in their own products.
- lispm 4y agoYou wrote: > Of course you will have to buy a maintenance contract on a yearly basis… One does not have to buy a maintenance contract. It's entirely up to the customer if he/she does that. > but it does not include technical support. It will have to be bought with “incident packs” costing thousands of euros; because yes, paying for a product and a maintenance contract does not mean they will fix bugs, and you will have to pay for each of them. You don't have to pay for each of them. They clearly say that they "may" charge you money and they inform you if that is the case. I have been reporting many things and for most fixes (for their bugs) I didn't have to pay anything additionally. For a lot of those I got patches immediately, sometimes they told me that it will be fixed in the next release, especially if it was in combination of a new feature. For example I once complained that the terminal listener/debugger wasn't supporting UTF-8. That feature got added in some release later. If I would have wanted to have it earlier, I surely would have had to pay for it.
- aidenn0 4y agoI've never worked for or with Franz, but I have worked support. The cost of supporting a customer is relatively uncorrelated with any of the typical ways of charging for maintenance (e.g. per dev seat, company market-cap &c.). This leads to maintenance contracts that are very limited in scope. OTOH Companies really want a way to be guaranteed that you will support them. This often leads to some form of tiered support system. If you are not noisy, you can get away with a low tier. If you are noisy you'll be pushed to a higher tier. If you are rich and don't want to bother with that nonsense you just buy the top tier. Also there's a difference between "Thanks for the bug report, it will be fixed in the next release" and "Here's a patch against <whatever version you are using> 24 hours after we fixed it in our development branch". The former is free pretty much everywhere (bug reports are like free QA). The latter is going to cost money.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoI don't think the licensing model is wrong but I think it is stupid, because it keeps new customers away. There should be a way to charge for the produced value. If many users are using the produced programs, charge for that. For instance keep the basic development environment reasonably priced but charge for the ability to create executables. My favorite IDE (Integrated Development Environment) at the moment is WebStorm by JetBrains. It is about $60 (?) for personal license with updates per year. I can develop JavaScript programs and run them on any JS platform. It is a nice product which truly adds to my productivity. And I can afford it. And I read that JetBrains is doing financially great.