3 ms·
AFAICT, the statistics in this infographic only lists people involved with theaters and cinemas. I didn't see any categories that addressed people that perform
by malandrew 15y ago
AFAICT, the statistics in this infographic only lists people involved with theaters and cinemas. I didn't see any categories that addressed people that perform jobs like actors, lighting and special effects, props, costumes, writers, directors, etc.
To have an honest discussion on this debate we need to stop talking about raw job numbers lost in one industry and instead talking about:
(1) net job losses and gains
(2) discounted by the number of jobs that are likely to be eliminated due to changes in consumption patterns and increased productivity (read: automation) in those industries.
The whole debate about job losses is dishonest if you don't accept the fact that change happens.
This isn't HN quality material. Give us deep analyses instead of a poorly made and misleading info graphic.
- jasomill 15y agoAgreed: nothing to see here, especially as MPAA represents the major Hollywood studios, not "workers in the entertainment industry." Here's a study I'd personally like to see: spending on "legitimate" copies of entertainment products easily available through piracy versus availability of discretionary income. I can't help but think that MPAA, if they were _truly_ just a bunch of greedy bastards, would have an entirely different political agenda.
- antics 15y agoI don't mean to be crabby, but the infographic explicitly mentions that some of the jobs are from the service industry. If you look at the infographic in context[1], it lists the source[2]. Also, while I generally agree with your point about this meriting a very detailed and thorough analysis, I do not believe that it was "intentionally" misleading any more than my disagreement with you indicates that you are also being intentionally misleading. IMO, that comment (along with your guess about what is and is not "quality") is not helping in your goal of making this a constructive conversation. [1] http://maddox.xmission.com/ http://maddox.xmission.com/ [2] http://www.bls.gov/oco/cg/cgs038.htm http://www.bls.gov/oco/cg/cgs038.htm
- malandrew 15y agoI have no doubt that there is a discrepancy between the 361,900 figure from the BLS and the over 2 million figure from the MPAA, but that info graphic just isn't clear on several points and clouds the discussion. TBH, you may be right that I am wrong about it being intentionally misleading. It may just be confusing design due to proximity. But if that is the case, I wouldn't be surprised if agenda played some role in clouding out better judgement in how it was designed. I'm still trying to figure out if the 25% refers to: (a) 361,900 jobs, meaning there are 1,080,700 creative jobs in the industry for a total of 1,447,600 people employed; or (b) 25% of the 361,900, meaning that 90,475 people are doing jobs like janitor and concessions and that 271,425 are creative jobs. FYI, I removed the word "intentionally" from my original comment. I agree that including it wasn't constructive. Plus, the same argument can be applied to tech companies. It's disingenuous to talk about people like janitors and cooks and whatnot, when people in every industry need to eat and have the spaces they occupy cleaned up and cared for. The author of the info graphic shouldn't have discounted those jobs from the MPAA's figures without also discounting them from the tech industry figures as well. I'm as anti-SOPA and anti-PIPA as anyone here on HN, but truth and transparency are more important than agenda, and if you give those up, you become those you are critizing.
- pasbesoin 15y agoIt's a little unclear initially from the graphic design, but as I read it that section of the spreadsheet that is called out and enlarged relates to the section of text that follows the overall job count. That section reads: Some of those "motion picture" jobs include food prep workers, concession stand jobs and janitors. In fact, 25% of all "motion picture" jobs are comprised of fast food workers, ushers and other service occupations. If you look behind the callout, you'll see that the background spreadsheet image represents a partial view into the total count and breakdown. Again, I had to do a double-take, myself, to see this. So I'm not saying the infographic couldn't stand some tweaking. Two comments I'll make. 1) I take the point of the infographic, but I don't mean in my own observation to discount nor demean those particular jobs. 2) It would be nice to have some links to information backing this up. However, I see a web site address clearly provided at the bottom. Looking there, while it's hardly the most structured web site design, if you look for the portion of the page that begins "Update (01-20-12)", you'll find at least some linkage.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- chc 15y agoThat's because the infographic is highlighting the fact that 25% of the much-touted jobs created by the movie industry are menial positions primarily staffed by high schoolers that would probably not flat-out disappear even if the movie industry did. The actual BLS report[1] he's citing does indeed include all those categories you're talking about, and that's where the 361,900 number comes from. I agree, though — this infographic is not very enlightening. But Maddox's overall point in the article that the infographic comes from[2] seems pretty valid: The movie industry is flat-out lying about the impact it has on employment in order to get the government to take it more seriously. [1]: http://www.bls.gov/oco/cg/cgs038.htm http://www.bls.gov/oco/cg/cgs038.htm [2]: http://maddox.xmission.com/ http://maddox.xmission.com/
- malandrew 15y agoI'm wondering if job losses among high schoolers and teenagers are even a problem we should be concerned with. I may be completely off base here, but with the exception of gas money in suburbs, I imagine that most of the income from jobs performed by people in high school is discretionary income spent on entertainment (because food and housing are still provided by someone's parents). Now I know this is not universally true, especially in low income communities, but I imagine that loss of discretionary income among this segment of society is adequately replaced by cheap or free internet content. I would even suggest that society shouldn't even worry too much about the loss of discretionary income that is mostly being spent on goods whose price is falling together with the loss in purchasing power for those goods.
- anamax 15y agoIncome isn't the only benefit of a job for teenagers. (They also spend it on eating out.) Another benefit is that said teenagers learn how to hold a job when failure may not be as expensive as it will be later.
- JamesLeonis 15y agoI would like to tack on money management things that are learned when failure is not harsh.
- gillianseed 15y agoLet's not forget that while piracy likely costs jobs in the movie industry it's not as if the money that isn't spent there due to piracy simply disappears. It is spent in other sectors, which in turn may end up generating more jobs than those which were lost in the movie industry. I'm not saying that the movie industry has no reason to complain about piracy, but the whole 'America is losing jobs' argument isn't working for me.