7 ms·
TikTok banned on EU executive staff devices
- krmbzds 4y agohttps://archive.is/0VWo3 https://archive.is/0VWo3
- drooopy 4y agoAll social media apps should be automatically banned on managed devices, especially those operated by government officials.
- toastal 4y agoWould something like a federated option for politicians be acceptable—where the government itself hosts then platform and only allows official accounts on the instance? There could be a reason to get across content in a digital medium, but what option has the least compromises?
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoThat sounds so convoluted and would never actually be used by regular users as long as more intense options exist (see Mastodon). I'm not sure why it needs to be a right to waste time consuming information about random celebrates and people you haven't spoken to since high school.
- ceejayoz 4y agoMastodon is actually perfect for this. The EU has already set one up. https://social.network.europa.eu/explore https://social.network.europa.eu/explore
- toastal 4y agoThat is Mastodon. But I framed the question in a way that doesn't limit options to only Mastodon as there are and could be different Fediverse platforms that may be better suited for the task.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- giancarlostoro 4y agoI was about to say "except for PR" but I guess they're better off having dedicated campaign / marketing / PR phones for just those cases.
- Ekaros 4y agoI would even extend that to all apps not necessary to carry out the duties.
- stingraycharles 4y agoYou have no idea how pervasive WhatsApp is with government officials over here. It’s a huge problem, and those with the power to do something about it don’t seem to care.
- mk89 4y agoWhatsapp is owned by an American company, who cares... thanks to the CLOUD act US can do whatever they want. Here the message is very clear (about tiktok, I mean) - you have no power at all over them. Or very limited. Plus, who knows what this app collects about you... EDIT: I know it's about EU, but the principle remains the same. There is clearly more trust towards US than somewhere else...
- stingraycharles 4y agoIt may surprise you, but in general the EU doesn’t feel that great about US companies having access to all this data, let alone private discussions between leaders of countries of the highest level. And that company being FB/Meta makes it so much worse.
- themitigating 4y agoThen why haven't they done anything about it?
- washadjeffmad 4y agoThat's what GDPR and every other human- and privacy-centric policy enacted in the past twenty years has been for. US adtech today argues that individuals have the right to give up their privacy and personal information in exchange for creating value for others, but that that information is inherently valueless without the markets, relationships, and processes they have created. This largely hasn't been (openly) discussed at the public policy level in the US because our lawmakers are terrified of accidentally passing a law that "kills Google". The world is getting close, which was part of the Alphabet/Google and Meta/Facebook maneuvers, as subtle entry into new markets becomes less possible.
- michaelt 4y ago[flagged]
- rvz 4y agoAnd all of them should be fined in the millions of euros for privacy and GDPR violations in order to comply and continue operating in the EU. No company shall get away from these fines and it doesn't matter if it is Facebook, Instagram or Twitter. Given that TikTok is far worse than all of them with an atrocious history of privacy violations that if investigated, the recurring fines will be at least in the tens of millions and even nearing the hundreds of millions of euros once repeated again which will certainly happen. They are already getting warnings from the EU of a ban [0], and have already been fined in the past by French regulators [1] so it is only a matter of time for them to get slapped with another fine in the tens of millions or even up to hundreds of millions of euros. [0] https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-leaders-fire-warning-shots-at-tiktok-over-privacy/ https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-leaders-fire-warning-shot... [1] https://www.politico.eu/article/tiktok-fined-e5m-in-french-privacy-case/ https://www.politico.eu/article/tiktok-fined-e5m-in-french-p...
- Quikinterp 4y agoI'm confused as to why anybody is downloading non work apps on a work device
- halgir 4y agoMany work devices are also personal devices. I have an employer-issued phone, and my income tax interprets that as a "benefit". I could avoid that by claiming I don't use it for personal reasons, and instead buy my own separate device. But I don't.
- beardyw 4y agoYes, I know multiple people who carry two phones for that reason (ie not criminals!)
- ghaff 4y agoAnd the vast majority of people don't. They have one phone--or even one laptop.
- c0wb0yc0d3r 4y agoIn my experience it's because, for many, the concept of a "work device" is extremely foreign to them. They see no difference between work email on a personal device, and personal email on a work device. Even I, a tech-literate person, use work devices in a personal manner. Sometimes because I can't be bothered to keep them separated. Other times it's because I believe it's required. For example, I have some scripts that I execute from my synced (personal) Google drive. Why? Because I made them in my free time, and they are useful at work too. To me I think that every company should be strictly managing work devices but I also know how much of a pain that is as well.
- Xenoamorphous 4y agoI always have gmail open in a tab on my work laptop, is that also not acceptable? What’s the difference, really? That being a web app instead of a native one it doesn’t go through an install process?
- shantnutiwari 4y agoI know the question has been asked but I'll ask again: Why does a bureaucrat need Tiktok on their workphone? Can they not work without watching twerking videos in the background? Unlike say, Facebook, which is sometimes used for communication (I know several online businesses that use Facebook groups/pages for their main website-- yes I know we should have our own website but non-techy types find it easier to use FB), or Twitter for keeping up with trending topics, Tiktok has no use case? Personally, I would ban all social media apps from official phones. But especially tiktok
- dpflan 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34909855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34909855
- hammock 4y agoSame reason they might have twitter. Lots of people tweet for work purposes, or read twitter to keep up with the trades, etc
- saiya-jin 4y agoIts not the same thing at all. Twitter has for example politicians and official spokespersons stating things that frequently move stock prices for example, tiktok has asocial media-addicted teens looking for their next social kick looking at how other people are having better lives than themselves or various hebophilia content (oversimplifying a bit but not that much). Twitter can definitely be used for non-work waste of time but tiktok can't be used for for any serious work for ie politicians.
- jasonlotito 4y ago> tiktok has asocial media-addicted teens looking for their next social kick looking at how other people are having better lives than themselves or various hebophilia content The amusing thing about this is, anyone with knowledge knows that this comment shows either you are ignorant on the topic, or you are admitting to what YOU look at on TikTok.
- steponlego 4y agoShow your parent's home office challenge paying off I see!
- valenterry 4y agoWhat? I would imagine they have a whitelist for their workphones, not a blacklist. Or not even allow the user to install anything by themselves at all...
- throw10920 4y agoI suppose that their devices currently occupy the stratum between "MDM profile prevents installation of apps by user" and "minimal MDM meddling" - probably wrongly, because like you said, a whitelist would probably be better for this particular group of persons! Perhaps there are a lot of them and their IT staff isn't large enough to handle all of the "please add this obscure app to the whitelist because I need it for this niche (but work-related) purpose" requests?
- ghaff 4y agoMy experience with MDM is that it satisfies occasional customer requirements that employees have MDM on devices that they may use to access work information. And basically the MDM requires that employees have a password set and that's about it. There are certainly situations where there should be entirely separate work and personal devices but, in my experience, most people freely intermix usage.
- icare_1er 4y agoThe Cybersecurity concern is valid, and good to address it. Now on to how TikTok is a weapon clearly aimed at turning a whole generation of kids into zombies. It baffles me that "the West" is blind to that.
- KyeRussell 4y agoOh please. “The West” had the last two iterations of this, at least.
- icare_1er 4y agoCorrect. But that's not a reason to voluntarily let others use weapons against us. This behavior that you exhibhit, of being a willingful victim, is one of the issues that foreign powers are glad to exploit.
- LatteLazy 4y agoGiven the level of access to EU executive (and legislative and presumably judicial) staff the US has been shown to have the works horse door and bolted come to mind...
- tristor 4y agoWhy would someone ever be putting personal apps on a work device? Setting aside the issues the company/organization may have with it, why would you personally want to subject yourself to your company/organization not only having the legal right, but possibly a compliance duty, to monitor and inspect all of your personal communications? There are a LOT of things that some people do in their personal time that might be considered a violation of company policy, and arguably a reason for termination, if found out by their company but are generally considered socially acceptable to do in your personal time because the company doesn't know about it and has no reasonable way or desire to find out. When you put personal apps and communications on work devices, you've now created a situation where the company may be required to know about those things and you are putting your job at risk for zero benefit. It's frankly none of the company's business if you get utterly shithoused on the weekend and sleep with random strangers at the bar, but if the evidence (pictures/videos/social media posts) of this are now being stored on and transmitted by a company device, they may have a legal obligation or duty to inspect it to ensure that device isn't storing/transmitting confidential data they have compliance obligations for, and now they know. Now that they know, they may have an obligation to terminate you because your behavior reflects poorly on the company. Maybe this is my US-centric worldview, because I know the EU is much less prudish, but I know that there are a lot of white collar workers in the US that smoke weed on the weekend with friends and engage in casual encounters, and yet both of these things would be considered to be morally suspect (and in the case of weed is still federally illegal, even though many states have locally decriminalized it) and are generally against company policies even when the official stance is a wink, nod, and a look away. By doing these things on a company device, you're putting it front and center and forcing the company to know about it. Your boss does not need to know about your weekend bong hits, or which clubs you go to in order to meet partners, and neither does company HR, so why are you forcing them to know? I'm now older and much more strait-laced than I was in my youth, but I had already well-established my personal policy not to mix work and personal devices more than two decades ago. How is this a lesson people are having to re-learn?