3 ms·
"In March 2016, Novak set up a Facebook page that purported to be that of the Parma Police Department." Honestly why does anyone think this is not wrong? Here
by jasmer 4y ago
"In March 2016, Novak set up a Facebook page that purported to be that of the Parma Police Department."
Honestly why does anyone think this is not wrong?
Here is a link to some of his posts [1]
The guy was straight up impersonating the Parma Police - he used their branding/badge and started posting 'as them'.
There are some trying to defend that as justifiable because some forms of comedy require that the comedian be 'in character' and not overtly flag it as parody from the start, but I suggest this is a very bad argument - especially when people could confuse the target as 'real' - and imperatively when we're dealing with Emergency Services.
There is a 100% chance that some members of the community would have inferred this to be a 'real' account, there's hardly a reason to believe otherwise. The headlines were a bit nutty, but not entirely unbelievable to the point the parody was clear.
There is no reasonable argument he could make as a 'comedian' that he couldn't just put 'parody/satire' on the logo, and, there's every reason to believe that people would have confused it as real.
He's literally using Police Badges!
What would happen if he 'parodied' actual police officers, with a real uniform, but as a joke wore a 'red nose'. Would that be sufficient for people to be sure he was not a real police officer?
Would it be legal to use Amazon's brand/logo and misrepresent yourself as them?
I'm a bit disturbed by all of the people arguing this man was maligned, I suggest this is upside down and that it's irrational that someone should be able arbitrarily impersonate Emergency Services and the justice system and then just hide under the 'I'm a comedian' moniker.
I'll bet $100 the Police found out about it because they were getting calls around the confusion.
Nobody confuses 'Bush/Obama' impersonators as the real thing, the parody is implied, and those parodies are not creating a disruption. Nobody confuses 'Reno 911' as 'real' police officers.
I'm sure he didn't realize the extent of possible disruption and I would hope that he doesn't get some kind of record for this, but I do suggest he committed a crime and at very least this should not be allowed.
And can't fathom how people could think this ok to do.
[1] https://ij.org/case/novak-v-parma/ https://ij.org/case/novak-v-parma/
- SilasX 4y ago>Honestly why does anyone think this is not wrong? Probably because they think they're such superior detectors of satire that they will never themselves be hookwinked, and then Just-World-Fallacy away anyone who is. While also, of course, bragging about all the places they got into by carrying a clipboard, and what an extreme injustice it is every time someone is falsely identified as an intruder.
- gcanyon 4y agoThe page offered pedophiles the opportunity to pass a few quizzes to expunge their record and become an honorary officer of the Parma police. https://fox8.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/12/2022/10/AD65F490E4A768BA1E2C06D9FD4CB52E_3.jpg https://fox8.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/12/2022/10/AD65F49... It said the department was hiring, asked minorities not to apply, and said that passing a hearing test and a short multiple choice vocabulary test guaranteed employment. https://fox8.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/12/2016/03/3.png?w=443 https://fox8.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/12/2016/03/3.png?w... That seems pretty clearly parody to me.
- berry_sortoro 4y ago[dead]
- tssva 4y ago> but I do suggest he committed a crime Evidently a jury presented with the facts of the case disagrees with you since he was acquitted of all charges at trial.
- jasmer 4y agoNo, a Jury didn't find him guilty of a felony and specific charges. They did not 'disagree' with me that such an account is innapropriate. Go ahead and find out yourself: make a 'parody' account of your local police office by using their logo, badge etc. and then some fun posts. Have people call 911 out of confusion. See what happens.