3 ms·
Whenever somebody makes the argument "Hey, we've had lots of technical progress in the past, but that just opened up new jobs for people to do!" I always think
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Whenever somebody makes the argument "Hey, we've had lots of technical progress in the past, but that just opened up new jobs for people to do!" I always think "Have you looked at the state of the US job market and economy over the past 40 years?"
That is, we've had a huge hollowing out of all sorts of "middle" jobs in the US (e.g. someone mentioned secretaries used to be the most populous job in the US) so now we're largely (not exclusively, but largely) left with 2 categories of jobs: (a) dead-end jobs that are at present difficult to automate because they often involve manual labor: housekeepers, security guards, massage therapists, waiters, truck drivers (but, we see where that's headed...), etc. and (b) high level jobs that "manage the machines", e.g. tech jobs.
It's not that hard to see where this ends up with AI being capable of more complicated tasks - I wrote about an anecdote recently where ChatGPT had essentially already obviated some positions https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34862450 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34862450. There are a slew of very high paying jobs that AI is coming for next, e.g. there is currently a shortage of radiologists because many folks in med school see the writing on the wall and don't go into radiology residencies. While full diagnostic radiology AI may not be there yet, it certainly will be by the time folks in med school finish their career in 40 years.
- purerandomness 4y agoCargo jobs that exist for bureaucratic reasons, or because of industry inertia, will be disrupted. That's the job of new inventions. Nothing to complain about, in my opinion. Those however who think that radiologists (/lawyers/secretaries) will get automated away, don't really understand what a radiologist's job really is. The boring bureaucratic part of a radiologist's job will get automated away, yes, but that's because automatable/auto-completeable tasks should get automated at some point. Think of it as a healthy organism eating away the boring part of a dream job that you, as a kid, imagined doing when you'll grow up.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> Those however who think that radiologists (/lawyers/secretaries) will get automated away, don't really understand what a radiologist's job really is. As someone intimately familiar with the job of a radiologist, please then tell me what "a radiologist's job really is". A diagnostic radiologist's job is to take a series of images, and output a set of findings and diagnoses. There is essentially no better task suited to modern AI. Yes, radiologists can do procedures like biopsies and potentially other interventions, but diagnostic radiologists often solely read images or at least earn the vast majority of their RVUs by reading images.