4 ms·
Here the courts have said the question itself is out of order because there's no prior precedent of such a reasonably similar case having been pursued. How is
by jfengel 4y ago
Here the courts have said the question itself is out of order because there's no prior precedent of such a reasonably similar case having been pursued.
How is that possible? Police have harassed people in every conceivable way since time immemorial, and people must have tried to sue over it.
What made this case so utterly unprecedented that they couldn't even imagine hearing it?
- aesh2Xa1 4y agoI don't know what made this particular case utterly unprecedented. However, one criticism of qualified immunity is that it protects law enforcement on the basis of otherwise irrelevant facts. https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/qualified-immunity-legal-practical-moral-failure https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/qualified-immunity-lega... > In practice, this legal standard is a huge hurdle for civil rights plaintiffs because it generally requires them to identify not just a clear legal rule but a prior case with functionally identical facts.
- sbuttgereit 4y agoWhether prior precedent is possible or not really shouldn't be the issue. Such a standard itself is the problem: if your rights are violated in a legally novel way, why do courts pre-judge such a case against the victim? Sure, precedent matters, but when a legally new situation arises (a distinction which might be different than what a reasonable layperson would consider "new"), it seems the more morally correct approach is to hear the case and set precedent. Courts do that all the time in other matters so this distinction in judging government agent's actions is particularly absurd.
- mrguyorama 4y agoIf you aren't allowed to sue the police without precedent, precedent will never be created, so you can never sue the police. There's a bootstrapping problem. It's just another way that the justice systems infatuation with "precedent", as if that's any way to democratically decide things, fucks each and every one of us constantly.